I agree with a lot you said but this is still my favorite one of all and I suppose nostalgia has a ton to do with it. I played this game when it first came out many many years ago. I love point and click adventure games and this one and the Monkey Island games have always been my favorites. And I think there can be and is a difference in, “best adventure game” and “favorite adventure game.” I know DOTT isn’t the “best” adventure game out there, but it is my favorite. I am curious though, what IS the best adventure game you have played.