Mine is blueberry unfrosted. You know what else? Even “homemade” Pop-Tarts that you find at expensive coffee shops are good, eve…Pop-Tarts Are So Good That It Is Crazy949Kelly ConaboyJim ReevesFollowJul 27, 2017 · 1 min readGood choice. That “frosting” is like marshmallow goo in a jar that hardens to concrete in the toaster.