The Hidden Gems: 10 Underrated RPGs That Defined an Era

Jonathan Kennedy
5 min readAug 3, 2023

--

As a seasoned RPG enthusiast, I have traversed the vast landscapes of gaming since the dawn of the new millennium, unearthing hidden treasures that remain underappreciated despite their immense contributions to the genre. In this post, I will take you on an unforgettable journey through the annals of gaming history, exploring ten underrated RPGs that graced our screens between the years 2000 and 2023. From epic tales to innovative gameplay mechanics, these gems are bound to captivate your imagination and reignite your passion for RPGs.

  1. Vagrant Story (2000):

This captivating gem, developed by Square Enix, blends action and tactical gameplay in a dark, gothic world. With an intricate crafting system and an engrossing story set in the kingdom of Valendia, Vagrant Story pushed the boundaries of RPG storytelling. Its depth of character development and challenging combat mechanics deserve much more recognition in the RPG hall of fame.

  • Platforms – PlayStation(various)

2. Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura (2001):

Troika Games gifted the gaming world with this unique steampunk-fantasy RPG. In a world where magic clashes with steam-powered technology, players navigated a morally ambiguous narrative, encountering varied choices and consequences. The game’s unparalleled freedom allowed players to shape their destiny, making Arcanum a standout in the realm of open-ended RPGs.

  • Platforms – PC

3. Legend of Grimrock (2012):

Reviving the classic dungeon crawler genre, Almost Human presented a modern take on the genre with Legend of Grimrock. This game perfectly combined old-school exploration and puzzle-solving with a fresh, immersive environment. Grimrock’s brilliant design and nostalgic charm deserve the attention of RPG enthusiasts seeking a taste of gaming’s roots.

  • Platforms – PC, Mac, iPhone

4. The Banner Saga (2014):

Created by Stoic Studio, The Banner Saga marries breathtaking hand-drawn artwork with a gripping narrative inspired by Norse mythology. This tactical RPG introduces players to heart-wrenching decisions that shape the fate of their caravan and its inhabitants. The Banner Saga showcases the power of storytelling in RPGs and offers a poetic experience that should not be missed.

  • Platforms – PC, Mobile Phone, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch

5. Divinity: Original Sin 2 (2017):

Larian Studios delivers a true masterpiece with Divinity: Original Sin 2, redefining modern RPGs with its deep and immersive gameplay. This game effortlessly blends tactical turn-based combat with a reactive and engaging world. Its vast, open-ended narrative and creative freedom make it a must-play for anyone seeking a truly immersive RPG experience.

  • Platforms – PC, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, macOS, Nintendo Switch, iPad

6. Disco Elysium (2019):

ZA/UM’s unconventional RPG, Disco Elysium, sets itself apart from traditional RPGs with its unique narrative-driven mechanics. Set in a world of political turmoil and crime, players assume the role of a troubled detective in a journey of self-discovery. The game’s thought-provoking dialogues and artistic expression earned it accolades and critical acclaim, though it remains underrated in the larger gaming community.

  • Platforms – PC, Mac, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Stadia, Nintendo Switch, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S

7. Outer Wilds (2019):

Venturing beyond the confines of traditional RPGs, Mobius Digital’s Outer Wilds is an exploration-driven experience set in a dynamically evolving solar system. The game’s enchanting blend of mystery and science fiction captivated players as they uncovered the secrets of a time-looped universe. Outer Wilds’ innovative approach to storytelling and gameplay earned it accolades from critics but deserved even more recognition from the broader gaming audience.

  • Platforms – PC, Xbox One, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S

8. CrossCode (2020):

A love letter to retro gaming, Radical Fish Games’ CrossCode transports players to a pixel-art MMO world filled with engaging puzzles and fast-paced combat. With its deep character progression, challenging dungeons, and endearing story, CrossCode pays homage to classic RPGs while crafting a unique and thrilling adventure.

  • Platforms – PC, Mac, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, Amazon Luna, PlayStation 5

9. GreedFall (2019):

Spiders’ GreedFall offers a fresh take on the colonial era with a focus on diplomacy and political intrigue. Set in a fantastical island teeming with magic and monsters, players navigate complex relationships with factions and companions while unveiling the island’s mysteries. GreedFall’s ambitious storytelling and world-building stand as a testament to the RPG genre’s potential for innovative narratives.

  • Platforms – PC, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S

10. Hades (2020):

Supergiant Games’ Hades is a fast-paced roguelike RPG that redefines the genre with its seamless gameplay and compelling character development. The game’s vivid artwork, dynamic combat, and immersive storytelling blend effortlessly, creating an experience that resonates with players on a deeply personal level. Hades’ success with critics and its dedicated fanbase have placed it on the map, but its impact deserves even more recognition in the wider gaming community.

  • Platforms – Mac, Nintendo Switch, PC, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S

These ten underrated RPGs are a testament to the ever-evolving landscape of gaming and the genre’s potential for creative storytelling and innovation. As a seasoned RPG enthusiast, I encourage all gamers to explore these hidden gems, as they have shaped the RPG genre and left a lasting impression on the gaming world. In doing so, you may discover new favorites that redefine your gaming experience and reignite your passion for role-playing games. Happy gaming!

Thanks for reading this post, made possible with AI assistance. If you loved it, show your support by clapping, sharing, and subscribing. Let’s spread the word and keep the positive momentum! 🌟😊

--

--

Jonathan Kennedy

Stealth game & RPG lover | Self-taught developer | Crafting immersive experiences that blend shadows, strategy, and storytelling with a touch of AI magic!