After a breach, the moral rules which apply are not the rules of peace, but the rules of broken peace, and the rules of war. We might ask, is the response proportional? Is it necessary? Does it serve the larger purpose of restoring the peace?
Tolerance is not a moral precept
Yonatan Zunger

This strikes me as the right way to think about violence and property damage at anti-Trump and anti-Nazi rallies. The people who want to take away rights don’t deserve peace, but does the property damage serve the purpose of restoring peace by actually silencing them? Or does it just reinforce their message?

And that’s just the question of whether it’s justified for the core of a protest to use violence or property damage. It’s definitely wrong for a black bloc to come in and hijack the main protest by forcing it to appear violent.

Like what you read? Give Jeffrey Yasskin a round of applause.

From a quick cheer to a standing ovation, clap to show how much you enjoyed this story.