Member preview

Magazine Idol: It’s Time to Ditch Weight Loss Success Stories

I grew up surrounded by women’s lifestyle magazines. At my parent’s house. At my aunts’ houses. Grandmas’ houses. Libraries and doctors’ waiting rooms and car repair shops and grocery store racks. I loved them all. As a girl, reading Women’s Day and Good Housekeeping and Self and O and Prevention and Better Homes & Gardens and Real Simple and Martha Stewart Living and Ladies’ Home Journal and that tabloid-esque Women’s World made me feel like I had unlocked the secrets of how to be a woman. Inside the covers, I had all the cleaning tips, holiday hosting etiquette, and signs of premature aging that I would ever need.

And even though I know from my research on weight loss success stories that women’s lifestyle magazines are an important tool in the project to discipline women’s bodies, I still read them. In fact, my favorite way to spend a Sunday morning is out on my deck with a cup of coffee, a mimosa, and a Marie Claire.

I don’t subscribe to the magazines. They just show up at my house every month. Right now, I get Better Homes & Gardens, Woman’s Day, Family Circle, Marie Claire, Glamour, & the occasional Vogue. I read with a skeptical eye, knowing that all the “best of” beauty product recommendations are sponsored and that I’ll never actually make the apple maple spice cake that I saved to Evernote. But I’ll admit that part of the appeal is imagining what my life would be like if I rehabbed a quaint 1950s Cape Cod with a cool, retro nautical vibe and an open floor plan.

And that’s the whole point, isn’t it? To show white, middle class women what our lives could be like if we bought the right moisturizer, served the right food, and cleaned our bathrooms properly. In a word — ideal. The magazines work very hard to show us what the ideal American woman looks like, what she knows, and how she cares for herself and others. So, of course, there are weight loss success stories. Lots of them.

[Image: 10 women’s magazine covers (two are duplicates). All but one has a direct reference to weight loss and that one uses a “sculpt” metaphor for weight loss.]

When you start noticing how often weight loss success stories appear in our everyday media, it’s hard to ignore. I see them in obvious calls to action in articles about hot weight loss tips and in sneaky metaphors that suggest I can “sculpt” a better butt. These dramatic weight loss tips function in many ways just like the idea of throwing the meticulously detailed luxury tapas party or hand-sculpting radishes into woodland creatures for edible after school snack bento boxes — a completely unattainable and unrealistic ideal.

Is it possible that someone learned something about heart disease in a magazine and scheduled a life-saving doctor’s appointment? Yes. Is it possible that someone was inspired by someone else’s work with non-profits and upped their volunteer efforts? Yes. I’m not here to argue that media in general or women’s magazines, specifically, lack significant educational value. In fact, the opposite is true. These lifestyle magazines have a lot of power to influence not only what products people should buy but the kinds of stories that guide our lives.

I believe that it’s time for these stories to change. Magazines like Teen Vogue has responded to the call to expand the range of issues it covers and the voices it represents in publication. Self, admirably, issued a style guide to publicly state a commitment to define their ethical promotion of health and wellness.

So, what would happen if women’s magazines took weight loss out of their content? Would we even buy magazines anymore if we didn’t have the chance to learn what detox tea to buy this month? What else would writers fill those columns with?

Last month, I indulged in the latest Woman’s Day while making dinner and I noticed yet another weight loss success story in “Live Longer & Stronger,” a column about women making lifestyle changes for overall health. I usually flip right past this column, but something about this story struck me. This Before and After weight loss success story didn’t have much about weight loss in it at all.

Consider the headline: “Heart Smart for Good.” Hm. Improved cardiovascular health isn’t something you can see in a Before and After photo set. So, I read on. “On a path to improve her blood pressure, Janet Cervantes-Hageman, 55, has lost 111 pounds. Here’s how she’s keeping it off.”


Do you mean to suggest that Janet’s dramatic weight loss is what improved her blood pressure? Says here in the article Janet attributes her lower blood pressure to the following activities:

~ reducing her stress

~ adding intentional movement into her routine

~ making nutrition choices that support her heart health goals

~ shifting her mindset to make self-care a priority

Every one of those activities can be done with or without intentional weight loss, yet Janet’s body shape was the main hook of the story. So, I took out my editor pen and revised the article to find out what would be lost or how the meaning would change if I removed all the references to weight loss. I changed the subheading text and struck 29 words of text.

Removing references to weight loss changed NOTHING about the story itself.

And this is all to say nothing of the truly unnecessary Before and After pictures. Bad, Before Janet is pictured with someone she clearly cares about — her granddaughter, maybe. Good, After Janet stands alone. It sends a message that Janet’s life before her dramatic weight loss wasn’t as good as her life after weight loss. If readers identify with Before Janet, does this story as written help them see a healthier future, or do they feel daunted (again) by the message that dramatic weight loss as the only way to a happier life? How can these readers see themselves as worthy of care and capable of making changes to their wellness habits now?

All it takes is changing a few words to help people go from “I wish I could do that” to “I could do that!”

If you want to try this experiment on your own, Woman’s Day just posted a similar web article about a woman with diabetes who improved her quality of life by making more supportive nutrition choices. If you’re up for an experiment, mentally remove any reference to weight loss and see if it changes the point of the story or if the advice would change. (Hint: it doesn’t.)

I hope more women’s magazines will follow in the inktrails of their fellows Teen Vogue and Self by critically examining their role as mainstream culture makers and take that responsibility seriously. Telling better stories about what it means to take care of yourself and others is a great place to start.

About the Author

Dr. Kate Browne is the founder of Taking Up Space, a blog that educates consumers about positive marketing in the health, wellness, and fitness industries. Kate helps others find their place in wellness communities and works as a messaging consultant for brands who want to bring wellness to as many people as possible. Kate is a member of the Body Positive Fitness Alliance, a TEDx speaker, and has been a featured guest on podcasts like Lean the F*ck Out, Not Your Average Runner and Plus Performance. Follow her on Instagram at @takeupspacewithkate