The Product Development Triathlon

The Moment of Insight

Explore/Expand/Extract

Explore/Expand/Extract
  1. Explore–the risky search for a viable return on a viable investment. Successful exploration is unpredictable, so the highest expected value strategy is to reduce the cost of experimentation and put a little investment into many, uncorrelated experiments. If you’re lucky, one of these experiments turns out to be unexpectedly successful, which leads to:
  2. Expand–now things are going nuts (think Pokemon Go or Facebook Live Video). Unanticipated bottlenecks appear. All you have time for is to eliminate the next bottleneck just before it derails you. Once growth becomes routine, it’s time to:
  3. Extract–now the shape of the problem and solution spaces are clear. One euro in equals three euros out. Playbooks emerge: here’s how you roll out the service in a new city. Economies of scale matter: delivering the service at lower cost is more profitable.

Lessons from the Triathlon

  • Each phases requires different equipment, different technique, different training. Software product development requires different tools, techniques, and value systems in the three phases. (The answer to the ??? in my notebook is “Efficient Extraction”.)
  • You can’t mix the phases. Just because biking is the fastest phase in kilometers per hour doesn’t mean you can go faster by taking your bike into the water. (I was dealing with a project prematurely moving from explore to expand just yesterday.)
  • The transitions are awkward, but they count. If a project goes from one phase to another and the team doesn’t notice, it’s like trying to swim on a bike. Not so good.
  • Only organizations that can execute all three phases can complete a race. If you just don’t feel like running, then it’s not a triathlon.
  • Unlike a triathlon, the same people don’t have to complete the phases. I specialize in exploration. As soon as expansion starts, I’m ready to start exploring again. As long as there is someone I can hand off to, this works fine.
  • The relative progress of the three phases roughly maps. Exploration (swimming) seems slow. Experiment after experiment fails. False hopes are dashed. Repeatedly. Then comes the “overnight success” of expansion (biking). Progress that would have taken months now happens in days or hours, just like a mile on a bike is way shorter than a mile swimming. Extraction (running) is more of a slog than expansion.
  • ??? [hoping for suggestions from actual triathletes or poets]

Application

  • Choose exploration. If you’re extracting and starting to feel hopeless or burned out, deliberately switch to exploration.
  • Accelerate experimentation. If you’re following all the rules and your experiments aren’t getting anywhere, break the rules to experiment faster. If experiments aren’t likely to last, quick and easy won’t cost you in the long run.
  • Transition. If things aren’t going smoothly, see if you’ve changed phases without noticing. If so, change the rules to match the phase you’re in.
Gratuitous Puppy Picture

--

--

--

Kent is a long-time programmer who also sings, plays guitar, plays poker, and makes cheese. He works at Gusto, the small business people platform.

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

Lambda Labs: The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

Understanding OpenAI baseline source code and making it do self-play! Part 3

Tips to survive code review for junior software engineer

Starting DSA with CodeChef as a Beginner — Guided Self Learning

Advice to ambitious/smart 2020 High School (and college) Grads

INVERS Increases Focus on Developer Community

What is Enterprise Content Management?

enterprise content management

Design to Scale (Part 1 — Pitfalls of Monolithic Application)

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Kent Beck

Kent Beck

Kent is a long-time programmer who also sings, plays guitar, plays poker, and makes cheese. He works at Gusto, the small business people platform.

More from Medium

unFIX vs Pipedrive Agile Framework

What’s wrong with delivery management?

A Clash of Mindsets: When New Products Depend on Existing Products

Riot Games: Using Agile to Build the World’s Largest e-Sport.