Eyebrow Pencils For Sparse Brows

Joseph Alvarado
16 min readSep 17, 2024
Eyebrow-Pencil-For-Sparse-Brows-1

Welcome to our roundup of the best eyebrow pencils for those with sparse brows! We understand the struggle of dealing with unruly and light eyebrows, so we've gathered a list of top-rated pencils to help you achieve the perfect natural look. Get ready to discover the perfect tool to enhance your eyebrows and boost your confidence!

As an Amazon Affiliate, we receive compensation from qualifying purchases!

Reviews

Benefit Eyebrow Precisely, My Brow Pencil

Benefit Eyebrow Precisely, My Brow Pencil | Image

Enhance your brows with Benefit's Precisely, My Brow Pencil, a waterproof mechanical eyebrow pencil designed for precise application. With an ultra-fine tip and rich, blendable colour, the pencil glides effortlessly through the brows, filling out uneven patches whilst defining their natural shape.

The precision pencil delivers the perfect amount of colour with a feather-stroke finish and offers 12-hour wear. Integrated with a spoolie for easy blending, this pencil provides a professional-looking finish for your brows.

Essence Eyebrow Designer Pencil: Quick and Easy Brows with Natural, Long-Lasting Color

Essence Eyebrow Designer Pencil: Quick and Easy Brows with Natural, Long-Lasting Color | Image

I've been using the Essence Eyebrow Designer Pencil for a while now, and I must say, it's a game-changer for my brow routine. The rich brown shade, 02, provides an excellent color match that's perfect for me. The creamy texture of the pencil glided on my brows smoothly, giving me an even application every time. One of the best parts is the included brush that lets me blend the color effortlessly, making it look natural and not overly drawn on.

The pencil's staying power is impressive, meaning I don't have to worry about touching up my brows throughout the day. It's also great for those who prefer a more natural look, as it can be used for subtle strokes or built up for a bolder effect. Additionally, it doesn't smudge or run, even on oily skin.

One downside I've experienced is that the pencil's softness makes it slightly fragile and can lead to a shorter lifespan. However, the affordable price makes it a worthwhile purchase, especially since it provides good coverage and a smooth, natural-looking finish. Overall, I'm a big fan of the Essence Eyebrow Designer Pencil and highly recommend it for anyone looking to enhance their brow game.

Burt's Bees Brunette Brow Pencil for Natural Eyebrow Look

Burt’s Bees Brunette Brow Pencil for Natural Eyebrow Look | Image

Burt's Bees Brow Pencil, Brunette, is a game-changer when it comes to filling in your brows. With its smooth application and long-lasting finish, it's no wonder it has received a rating of 4.3 and 135 reviews, including many praises for its "natural-looking" result.

The pencil is formulated with natural ingredients such as Jojoba Oil and Shea Butter, providing a gentle, 99.9% natural formula that's gentle enough for the delicate eye area. The brush helps shape your eyebrows for a fuller appearance, and the natural cedar wood pencil is responsibly sourced.

However, some users have experienced issues with the pencil smudging and the tip going down too quickly, requiring frequent sharpening. Despite this, the pencil's ability to provide a natural-looking, long-lasting finish is a highlight for many users.

This Brow Pencil is a cruelty-free and dermatologist-tested product, and PETA certified. It's free from parabens, phthalates, synthetic fragrances, and is suitable for those with sensitive skin.

In conclusion, Burt's Bees Brow Pencil, Brunette, is a great choice for those seeking a long-lasting, natural-looking brow solution. Despite the occasional smudging issue, its ability to provide a precise, fuller-looking brow makes it a top pick for many users.

Maybelline Tattoo Studio Longwear Waterproof Brow Pencil

Maybelline Tattoo Studio Longwear Waterproof Brow Pencil | Image

As a brow enthusiast, I recently tried the Maybelline Tattoo Studio 36HR Pigment Brow Pencil in Light Blonde, a drugstore eyebrow pencil that promises long-lasting performance and natural-looking results. The convenience of not having to twist it up caught me off guard, as it seemed like a unique design. But after a few tries, sharpening it was a breeze, and it provided a precise, clean application.

What truly stood out to me was the pigmentation. The product was packed with intense color that filled in my sparse brows with ease. The waterproof formula held up well throughout the day, and I didn't have to worry about smudging or fading, which was a major plus. The spoolie brush on the opposite end allowed me to blend it seamlessly for a more natural look.

However, there were a few drawbacks. Firstly, the packaging seemed a bit low-quality and didn't give clear instructions on how to properly use and sharpen the pencil. Additionally, I found that the product was a bit tough to remove at the end of the day.

Overall, the Maybelline Tattoo Studio 36HR Pigment Brow Pencil in Light Blonde offered impressive performance, but some improvements in the packaging and ease of removal would make it even better.

MISSHA Stylish Gray Eyebrow Perfector

MISSHA Stylish Gray Eyebrow Perfector | Image

Introducing the MISSHA Perfect Eyebrow Styler, the ultimate solution to achieving perfectly defined and polished brows. This long-lasting automatic brow pencil is designed to provide a natural-looking finish while being effortless to use, making it an ideal choice for beginners or those with a busy lifestyle.

The pencil is equipped with a soft and smooth texture that glides effortlessly onto your skin, delivering a natural color that enhances your eyebrows without appearing too harsh. Its unique shape and size provide precision in shaping and extending your eyebrows, allowing you to achieve a perfectly balanced look.

A major highlight of this product is its water- and sweat-resistant formula, which ensures your brows stay in place even in harsh weather conditions or during physical activities. The long-lasting nature of this pencil means you won't have to worry about frequent touch-ups, giving you the freedom to focus on other aspects of your daily routine.

One of the best aspects of the MISSHA Perfect Eyebrow Styler is its ease of use. Its automatic twist-up feature allows you to reveal the desired amount of product, while its distinct cap lengths make it simple to place the correct cap back upon use. The pencil comes with a convenient spoolie brush at the other end, which helps to blend and groom your eyebrows into perfection.

Although the MISSHA Perfect Eyebrow Styler has received overwhelmingly positive reviews, some users have reported minor issues with smudging and ease of removal. However, these concerns are outweighed by the pencil's overall quality, ease of application, and long-lasting performance.

In conclusion, the MISSHA Perfect Eyebrow Styler is a fantastic choice for anyone seeking a reliable and effective eyebrow pencil that offers a natural-looking, long-lasting finish. Its user-friendly design and affordable price make it a popular choice among makeup enthusiasts, making it a worthy addition to any beauty routine.

e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil - Deep Brown (Natural, Sleek, Compact)

e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil — Deep Brown (Natural, Sleek, Compact) | Image

In a roundup review, I'd be remiss not to mention the e. l. f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil in Deep Brown. This pencil is a game-changer, with its dual-sided design that combines a fine tip liner for defining and filling in brows, and a spoolie brush to help shape and comb them into place. The slim mechanical pencil is easy to use and creates a natural, polished look, without being overly flashy or attention-seeking.

One of the standout features of this product is its cruelty-free and vegan status, which aligns with many consumers' values. The product is also long-lasting, ensuring that your brows stay in place all day long without smudging or fading. Moreover, the formula is easy to remove, making it a more convenient option for those who prefer to clean up their makeup look before turning in for the night.

Some users have reported that waterproof formula can be a little too effective, remaining stubborn even when attempting to remove it with makeup remover. However, this could be considered an advantage for others who are looking for a long-lasting and waterproof brow solution.

The shade selection is vast enough to cater to a variety of skin tones and hair colors, ensuring that the pencil works well for a wide range of users. The application quality is also praised by users, with the pigment being described as high-quality and the texture smooth and creamy.

Despite these positive reviews, the packaging quality is criticized by some for feeling cheap and not in line with the product's overall quality. Additionally, some users have experienced difficulty in finding the perfect shade match, with the product falling short in terms of exact replication of hair color.

In conclusion, the e. l. f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil, in Deep Brown or any other shade, is a high-quality and effective eyebrow product that is worth considering for its ease of use, long-lasting formula, and natural appearance. With a reasonable price point and a focus on being cruelty-free, this pencil is a firm favorite amongst users and an excellent choice for anyone seeking a well-rounded brow solution.

Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat: Medium Brown for Natural-Looking Sparse Brows

Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat: Medium Brown for Natural-Looking Sparse Brows | Image

As someone who appreciates natural-looking brows, I've been using the Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat in Medium Brown for a few weeks now. It's been a game-changer in my daily makeup routine. What stood out to me is the formula's rich emollients that allow for easy application without tugging or dragging. The micro-precision pencil's angled tip makes it simple to mimic natural brow hairs, adding both definition and shape.

While the pigmentation is spot-on, creating natural-looking brows that blend seamlessly with my own, the longevity leaves a little to be desired. It doesn't seem to last as long as some other brow products I've tried.

Another aspect that I find quite enjoyable is the packaging. The sleek black pencil looks stylish and professional in my makeup bag. However, it can be a bit tricky to twist it open, so I recommend having your nails slightly shortened to make it easier to grip.

When it comes to the applicator, it's a bonus that it's double-ended. The spoolie brush makes blending and fluffing a breeze, providing the perfect amount of product without overdoing it.

Despite the pros, I do wish the company would be a bit more transparent about discontinuing shades, as it happened with the black brown shade for those with dark skin.

Overall, I believe this pencil is a great option for those looking for a natural-looking brow product that offers precision and quality. It's definitely a product I'll continue to use and recommend.

Bobbi Brown Sparse Brow Eyebrow Pencil - Honey Brown (Ophthalmologist Tested)

Bobbi Brown Sparse Brow Eyebrow Pencil — Honey Brown (Ophthalmologist Tested) | Image

Experience the Bobbi Brown Micro Brow Pencil, your go-to eyebrow tool designed to help achieve the perfect brows. The pencil's precise tip makes it effortless to create natural, hair-like strokes, perfect for filling in sparse areas or defining and shaping your brows with ease. With its long-lasting, waterproof formula providing up to 24 hours of wear, this versatile eyebrow pencil ensures a flawless, confident look all day long.

With a blend of emollient oils and waxes, it offers a creamy glide for effortless application and a natural appearance. Embrace the versatility of this high-quality, cruelty-free brow makeup.

Jones Road Beauty: The Brow Pencil - Natural-Looking, Easy-to-Apply, Long-Lasting for Sparse Brows

Jones Road Beauty: The Brow Pencil — Natural-Looking, Easy-to-Apply, Long-Lasting for Sparse Brows | Image

Introducing the game-changing Brow Pencil from Jones Road Beauty, designed to elevate your brow game effortlessly. This versatile pencil is available in five shades, catering to a variety of hair tones from fair to black. With a natural-looking formula, this pencil ensures a smooth, controllable application. It boasts of a buttery consistency that glides on seamlessly, providing perfect dimension and fullness to your brows.

The Brow Pencil is waterproof, ensuring that your brows stay put all day long, making it perfect for those with an active lifestyle. In addition, its fibers create a feathery effect, transforming your sparse brows into lush, full arches. Whether you're looking to fill in sparse patches or define your brows, this pencil has got you covered.

The packaging of the product is sleek and easy to use, with a comfortable grip that allows for a precise application. However, some users have reported minor issues with the pencil's applicator, which may take some time to master for optimal results.

While the majority of reviewers have expressed satisfaction with the product, a few have pointed out concerns with smudging and formula waterproofing. Nonetheless, the pencil has managed to impress many users with its ease of removal and quality formula.

Overall, the Jones Road Beauty Brow Pencil is a must-have for those seeking a natural, long-lasting solution to enhance their brows. With its blend of functionality and style, this pencil is sure to become a staple in your beauty routine.

Waterproof Microblading Eyebrow Pencil with 4-Prong Micro-Fork-Tip for Define

Waterproof Microblading Eyebrow Pencil with 4-Prong Micro-Fork-Tip for Define | Image

Our Eyebrow Contouring Pen is the perfect tool for anyone looking to achieve defined and waterproof eyebrows that last all day. This pencil is designed with a unique four-prong micro-fork-tip applicator that makes application effortless, letting you create natural-looking, vivid eyebrows with ease.

Its smooth and rich texture ensures a seamless and flawless finish, while the long-lasting formula guarantees your eyebrows will stay perfect even under challenging conditions. Plus, its versatile design lets you easily match any look and choose different colors to match your hair color and preferences. With this pen, you can enhance your eyebrows and create the appearance of fuller, more defined brows in seconds.

It's small and travel-friendly, making it perfect for on-the-go touch-ups.

Natural-looking Waterproof Brow Microfill Pencil for Filling Sparse Hairs

Natural-looking Waterproof Brow Microfill Pencil for Filling Sparse Hairs | Image

The Benefit Cosmetics Brow Microfilling Pen in Light Brown is a brow pen designed to create the appearance of natural brow hair with three ultra-fine lines in a single stroke. This pen is perfect for filling in sparse hairs and making brows appear fuller. Crafted with the user's skin in mind, the formula glides on smoothly and blends easily, ensuring no harm to the skin. The Lightweight fabric is not heavy on the skin, making it an ideal choice for those seeking a natural look.

The waterproof formula looks natural and is smudge-proof and long-wearing, as it can last for up to 24 hours, creating a microbladed effect. It's easy to apply and suitable for various skin tones. The product's applicator tip is ideal for creating thin and natural strokes, ensuring no heavy or unwanted appearance.

Although some users have reported issues with pigmentation, the pen's ability to blend colors and provide an incredibly natural look may outweigh those concerns. The ease of application and smooth, lightweight formula make it a great choice for those seeking a natural, fuller-looking brow.

Benefit Cosmetics Gimme Brow+ Mini Volumizing Fiber Eyebrow Pencil - Warm Light Brown

Benefit Cosmetics Gimme Brow+ Mini Volumizing Fiber Eyebrow Pencil — Warm Light Brown | Image

I recently tried the Benefit Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Fiber Eyebrow Pencil in Warm Light Brown, and let me tell you, it's a game-changer! This pencil is the first of its kind to blend fibers AND powder, providing incredible volume and dimension. The formulation adheres to both skin AND hair, ensuring the best possible result.

The long-wearing formula is transfer-proof and waterproof, and even in the summer heat, this pencil hasn't smudged or run. I also appreciate the lightweight feel and natural appearance that Gimme Brow+ provides – it looks like I naturally have full, beautiful brows.

However, my one gripe is with the applicator – the spoolie seemed a bit poorly-made, making it difficult to use. I wish it would sharpen with the Benefit All-Purpose Sharpener I already own, but instead, I had to purchase a separate one.

Overall, the Benefit Gimme Brow+ is a fantastic product that has made a noticeable difference in my daily routine, as I enjoy the natural look and feel it provides. With its unique blend of fibers and powder, this pencil is certainly a game-changer for those looking to achieve more volumized brows.

Buyer's Guide

Eyebrow pencils can be a lifesaver for those with sparse brows, providing natural-looking definition and fullness. In this buyer's guide, we'll go over essential features to consider when selecting an eyebrow pencil, as well as general advice for achieving the best results with your chosen product.

Important Features to Consider

When purchasing an eyebrow pencil for sparse brows, the following features should be at the top of your list:

  1. Formula and color selection. Make sure the pencil has a smooth, blendable formula and offers a variety of shades to suit your natural brow color and desired intensity. 2. Precision tip or spoolie. A precise tip helps create hair-like strokes for a natural appearance, while a spoolie brush is useful for brushing brows into place.

How to Choose the Right Shade

Selecting the right shade is crucial for achieving a naturally filled-in look. Start by comparing the pencil's color swatches to your actual brow hair. It's best to choose a shade that closely matches your brow hairs, or slightly lighter if you prefer a more subtle appearance. If you're unsure, it's always a good idea to opt for a taupe or ash-toned pencil, as these shades are universally flattering and blend well with most hair colors.

Application Tips

To ensure a natural and flawless finish, follow these tips when applying your eyebrow pencil:

  1. Use light, hair-like strokes to mimic individual brow hairs. 2. Start at the inner corner of your brow and work your way outward, filling in any gaps or sparse areas. 3. Use the spoolie brush to blend and shape the brows, creating a soft, feathered look. 4. Clean your pencil occasionally with a sanitizing spray or makeup remover to prevent a buildup of product and maintain a sharp tip.

General Advice and Maintenance

To get the most out of your eyebrow pencil, consider these additional tips:

  1. Store the pencil in a cool, dry place to prolong its lifespan. 2. Sharpen the pencil regularly, using a sharpener designed for wooden pencils to maintain a precise tip. 3. If you're new to eyebrow pencils, practice using the product on your hand or arm before applying to your brows. This will help you get a feel for the strokes needed to achieve the desired result.

FAQ

How do these eyebrow pencils for sparse brows work?

Eyebrow pencils for sparse brows are designed to mimic the appearance of natural hair, providing a subtle and blended appearance. They are typically available in a range of colors, allowing you to choose a shade that closely matches your eyebrows. The pencils are usually waterproof and long-lasting, ensuring your eyebrows stay in place throughout the day.

To use the pencil, simply draw fine, hair-like strokes along your eyebrows, blending them in for a natural look. You can use them to fill in sparse areas, define the shape of your brows, or create a more prominent arch. With a bit of practice, you can achieve a flawless and well-groomed look that makes your eyebrows appear fuller and more defined.

Are these eyebrow pencils suitable for all skin types?

Yes, most eyebrow pencils for sparse brows are suitable for all skin types, including sensitive skin. They are typically formulated with natural ingredients and are free from harsh chemicals, making them gentle and safe for use on the face. It is always recommended to perform a patch test before applying the pencil to your eyebrows to ensure that you do not experience any adverse reactions.

Additionally, there are hypoallergenic options available for those with sensitive skin. These products are specifically formulated to minimize the risk of irritation, making them an excellent choice for those with skin sensitivities or allergies. When shopping for an eyebrow pencil, look for products that are labeled as hypoallergenic or gentle for sensitive skin.

How do I choose the right color for my eyebrows?

Choosing the right color for your eyebrows is essential for achieving a natural and flawless look. To do this, consider your natural eyebrow color and the shade of your hair. You can also refer to the color wheel, which can help you determine which shades complement your skin tone and hair color best.

The best way to find your perfect match is to select a few shades and test them on your eyebrows. Apply the pencils and blend them in, taking note of how the color looks against your skin tone and the individual hairs in your eyebrows. This will help you make the best decision and choose the color that most closely resembles your natural brows.

Do these eyebrow pencils come in a variety of shades?

Yes, most eyebrow pencils for sparse brows are available in a range of shades. This allows you to choose a color that closely matches your natural eyebrow color, ensuring a more natural-looking finish. Some pencils even come in dual or tri-color options, giving you the versatility to blend multiple shades together for a more dimensional look.

When selecting a shade, consider your skin tone, hair color, and the overall aesthetic you are trying to achieve. Some pencils may also be available in more natural or ash-toned shades, which can be a great choice for those who want a more subtle, everyday look without being too bold. Be sure to read the product descriptions carefully to find the shade that best suits your needs.

How do I maintain and care for my eyebrows between applications?

To maintain and care for your eyebrows between applications, follow these simple steps: first, keep your eyebrows clean by washing them daily using a gentle, non-comedogenic cleanser. Avoid using harsh skincare products or scrubbing your eyebrows too vigorously, as this can lead to irritation or breakage of the hairs.

Second, use a spoolie brush to comb your eyebrows in an upward direction daily. This will help keep your hairs in place and prevent them from becoming matted or tangled. Additionally, it can help you remove any excess product and ensure that your eyebrows look neat and well-groomed throughout the day.

Are these eyebrow pencils easy to remove?

Yes, most eyebrow pencils for sparse brows are designed to be easy to remove, even if applied in thicker layers or left on for longer periods. They are typically waterproof and long-lasting, but they can still be easily removed at the end of the day with a gentle makeup remover or face wash. To ensure that your pencil comes off more easily, consider using a makeup remover specifically formulated for eye makeup.

As always, be gentle when removing your makeup, as excessive rubbing or scrubbing can cause irritation or damage the delicate skin surrounding your eyes. Opt for a soft, damp cloth or cotton pad, and gently pat your skin to loosen the product before washing it away with a cleansing agent. This will help ensure that your eyebrows are left in the best possible condition, ready for your next application.

As an Amazon Affiliate, we receive compensation from qualifying purchases!

--

--