Salary and Negotiation for New Grads: Data and Insights

Katie Siegel
Sep 28, 2016 · 4 min read

Interview season is almost here! Earlier this year, I interviewed around 250 of my fellow recent grads on their offers for employment after college. I compiled results capturing salary and negotiation data for new-grad positions in the tech industry, finance, and consulting. If you are a current student wading into interview season, I hope you find these results helpful when negotiating your offer.


The graph below shows initial, pre-negotiation compensation offers from a wide spectrum of companies. Mid-to-late-stage startups offer the highest base salaries, with an average of $102,513. Public tech companies offer the largest bonuses and greatest overall compensation packages. However, it is worth noting that consulting and finance companies award large performance-based bonuses, while tech companies grant equity packages.

60% of respondents negotiated their offers, even though 62% of respondents had never negotiated a job offer before. Overall, offer negotiation led to a boost in earnings across all industries — an average increase of around $2,600 in base salary and $5,000 in signing bonus. Startups allow the largest salary gains via negotiation, with an average increase of around $12,200 for early-stage startups and an average increase of $5,000 for mid-to-late-stage startups. Companies across the board increased signing bonuses dramatically during negotiation. Mid/late stage tech startups and large finance or consulting firms provided the largest increases in signing bonus.


Tech startups grant equity packages as part of an offer. Earlier-stage tech startups often offer award equity packages containing larger percentages of the company. The graph below shows the average equity grant size for various types of startups. For new-grads joining a post-Series A startup, the average equity package amounted to around 0.79% of the company; however, the median value was around 0.15%. Those joining late-stage startups can only expect to receive an equity package of around 1 or 2 hundredths of a percent of the company.

Equity grants from large tech companies contained shares with an average total value of $107,153. Most equity packages are vested over four years.

Company Choice

Respondents received an average of 2.6 job offers, and had around 4 weeks to decide which company they would join. Overall, respondents rated their negotiation experience a 3.5/5 with regards to stress, indicating that most people felt at least moderately stressed out by the experience.

Among my peers choosing tech companies, around half chose to join a large public company, and half chose to join a startup. 41% of respondents accepted a return offer to a company at which they had previously worked.

Demographic Differences — The Gender Gap

Examining trends across different demographics, I found that women were more likely than their male peers to choose a large, public tech company over a startup. Among all surveyed women entering the tech industry, around 55% chose large tech companies. In contrast, 67% of men entering the tech industry chose startups. The difference is statistically significant (p-value < 0.01) and mirrors other studies’ findings that women are more risk-averse than men.

Looking just at the tech industry, I examined differences in base salary across different demographics. There was no statistically significant difference across races or ethnicities, largely due to low response rates from minorities. However, new-grad women were initially offered almost $10,000 less in base salary than their male peers — before any negotiation. The difference is statistically significant (p-value < 0.01). Upon closer inspection, offers from large tech companies account for the difference. These large, public tech companies offer new-grad women over $10k less than men for new-grad positions (p-value < 0.038).


Across the board, a majority of students are successfully negotiating their new-grad offers. Yet, I was alarmed that large, public tech companies offer new-grad women so much less than new-grad men. This discrepancy anchors salary negotiation at a far lower number for women than for men, placing women at a disadvantage even before negotiation.

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade