Gamification and learning — benefits and trapdoors Part 1
This is an updated version of an article that was published a few years ago
It empowers creativity, trigging
curiosity, gets the mind spinning and gives pride when finishing a task, the list can be made very long on why computer games engage so many people. It is estimated that one billion people around world play games at least one hour per day. At the same time 81 per
cent of the global labour force does not feel engaged in their work, says the game-design-guru Jane McGonigal in an IDG interview. There is a reason to believe that the amount is similar when it comes to the formal educational system and its pupils and students. With this in mind, how can the engaging power of computer games be used for learning?
How gamification adds value to learning
The engine of a game-environment is based on individual and/or group performance, which has more similarities with the working life than traditional school education. Thereby gamification can be a functioning bridge between the school and its efforts to prepare the students for the working life.
Gamification could also probably benefit to lower the number of dropouts from the school system. In a report from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation 467 high school dropouts were asked why they left school 47 per cent responded: “The classes were not interesting.” Meaning that the classes were not engaging enough and they could not see the benefits for their future everyday life and working life. With performance-based games for learning where understanding and creativity is required added with a more authentic visual environment the number of dropouts would probably be much lower.
The main characteristics of edugames are that they produce an environment that is based on creativity, problem-solving, persistence and collaboration, in other words, training of competencies. They also require to develop an understanding of the content. Meaning the requirements to complete tasks are a manifold of skills and to put knowledge into action. The contrast is rather sharp to the traditional teaching-by-telling education which main focus is set on knowledge and in its brighter moments some understanding. This means that an introduction of gamification as a pedagogical method would add crucial value to the learning process as well as give a pre-taste of the working life.
Gamification trapdoors for learning
Above some of the main benefits are shown of using gamification as a pedagogical method, but what are the trapdoors?
1. It is expensive to create qualitative computer games for learning. Since ads cannot be a source of income for the game-producer because of the target group, the cost for the schools could be high. Solution: Create game-platforms that could be recycled to more subjects and approaches.
- Comment: This problem we have solved on our platform Storyteller on eLearningworld (SOE) by including gamification mechanisms among other interactive features in a very affordable concept. The Storyteller LearningLab edition for educational organisations will be launched during the autumn 2018, while Storyteller On Demand where we build the learning application already is available.
2. Quality, the developer should not firstly focus on entertainment, instead, an edugame’s engagement should origin from developing understanding and use of different competencies to develop skills. But still, have an ingredient that spins the gamers mind in amusement.
- Comment: The solution could be to use our 30 years joint experience of education and development of learning applications to build an engaging and effective learning experience.
3. People are different, in the same way as traditional teaching-by-telling pedagogy does not work for many pupils and students, gamification is not the miracle medicine for everybody.
- Comment: Our recommendation is personalisation and blended learning since one size does not fit all.
The next part of this article series will focus on an area where great improvements can be made with gamification; assessment of knowledge, understanding and skills. Especially since traditional assessment tests often mostly focus knowledge-based facts, a well-designed edugame focus on understanding and skills related to a subject and in that environment the student just have to have the knowledge to perform well. The third part of this article series will then focus game-based learning in the working life.
Author of the book Learning Design in Practice for Everybody
Stealth Assessment — Measuring and Supporting Learning in Video Games by Valerie Shute and Matthew Ventura MacArthur Foundation
Originally published at eLearningworld.