Trey, interesting post! I think everyone’s favorite villain, Jeff Bezos, echoes a lot of your ideas: http://www.businessinsider.com/jeff-bezos-explains-the-perfect-way-to-make-risky-business-decisions-2017-4
In particular, Bezos tries to make decisions at 70% of desired information. 70% is quite a bit, and I’d still call it data driven, but 70% is not a definite space. Instinct counts for a lot when making decisions around where the group or data should move.