Understanding hot vs cold Observables
When i started to get the hang of Observables it took me quite some time to understand what is meant by a hot or a cold Observable. Once i started to grasp the concepts i better understood how my Observables where behaving. Hence i’m going to explain it to you, the easy way.
If you’re not sure that you already understand how Observables work in general, i would recommend to first read my other article: Understanding, creating and subscribing to observables in Angular.
To understand the concept of a hot and cold Observable it’s good to always refer to what the data producer is. To make it simple:
When the data is produced by the Observable itself, we call it a cold Observable. When the data is produced outside the Observable, we call it a hot Observable.
We jumped a few steps ahead, so let’s go back and dive in.
So, we call an Observable “cold” when the data is produced inside the Observable. As you might have read in my previous article, Observables are lazy. Observables are lazy in the sense that they only execute values when something subscribes to it. For each subscriber the Observable starts a new execution, resulting in the fact that the data is not shared. If your Observable produces a lot of different values it can happen that two Observables that subscribe at more or less the same receive two different values. We call this behaviour “unicasting”. To demonstrate this:
As you see the data is produced inside the Observable, making it cold. We have two subscriptions which subscribe more or less at the same time. Since the Observable does a new execution for every subscriber and the Observable generates a random number, the data the subscriber receives is different. This is not a bad thing, you just have to be aware of this behaviour.
Of course this behaviour is not always desirable. Luckily it’s easy to change this behaviour:
Woah, that was easy! All we did was moving the data producer out of the Observable. We still have two subscribers and the Observable will still execute two times, but since the data is produced outside the Observable our subscriptions will receive the same data.
I hope this rings a bell, because we just turned our cold Observable into a hot Observable.
Yes, it is that easy. An Observable is cold when data is produced inside the Observable and the Observable is hot when the data is produced outside the Observable. As we just saw the hot Observable is able to share data between multiple subscribers. We call this behaviour “multicasting”.
Generating a random number is not a good real life usecase. A good usecase would be DOM events. Let’s say we’re tracking clicking behaviour and have multiple subscribers do something with the coordinates:
The data is produced outside of the Observable itself. Which makes it hot, because the data is being created regardless of if there is a subscriber or not. If there is no subscriber when the data is being produced, the data is simply lost.
Is one better than the other?
Well, that depends on the usecase. A cold Observable is usually fine, unless:
- You want to make sure multiple subscribers get the same data.
- Your creating a new instance of something on each Observable execution, let’s say a websocket connection. You don’t want to create a new connection for each subscriber, but instead just share it to all the subscribers. Moving the instantiation of the connection outside the Observable will make it hot and fixes this.
I hope this article helps you understand better how Observables work and what the implications are of producing data inside (cold) or outside (hot) your Observable. If you want to dive deeper into rxjs i recommend you to read one of my other articles about Subjects or BehaviorSubjects, ReplaySubjects and AsyncSubjects.
Looking for a job in Amsterdam?
I work for Sytac as a Senior front-end developer and we are looking for medior/senior developers that specialise in Angular, React, Java or Scala. Sytac is a very ambitious consultancy company in the Netherlands that works for a lot of renowned companies in banking, airline, government and retail sectors. You can think of companies like ING, KLM, Deloitte, Ahold Delhaize, ABN AMRO, Flora holland and many more.
From a personal opinion Sytac really sets itself apart with their client portfolio, but also with how they take care of their employees. They do really care about the wellbeing of their employees. Apart from a good salary (50K-75k), you will notice this in regular meetings with the consultant managers but also by the amount of events they organise and all the other perks they offer to keep all employees happy.
If you think you have what it takes to work with the best, send me an email on email@example.com and i’m happy to tell you more.