Elden Ring DLC Review: A Detailed Analysis of Player Reactions

Mavis Conor
3 min readJun 23, 2024


The Elden Ring DLC launch has ignited a firestorm of opinions across the gaming community, with players expressing a wide spectrum of reactions. This blog post dives deep into the diverse feedback, exploring the reasons behind the fervent discussions and providing an in-depth look at the DLC’s impact.

Elden Ring DLC Review: A Detailed Analysis of Player Reactions

Initial Impressions and Expectations

Upon its highly anticipated release, the Elden Ring DLC was met with both excitement and trepidation. Promises of challenging gameplay and expansive new content set high expectations among fans of the Souls series. However, for many players, especially those new to the franchise or unaccustomed to its signature difficulty curve, the initial experience proved daunting.

Gameplay and Difficulty Analysis

Central to the discourse surrounding the Elden Ring DLC is its steep difficulty spike compared to the base game. Seasoned players accustomed to the main storyline found themselves grappling with adversaries and bosses that demanded heightened skill and strategic finesse. This shift in challenge level has led to accusations of artificial difficulty and has sparked debates over the balance between accessibility and the franchise’s hardcore roots.

The gameplay dynamics have also evolved significantly with the introduction of new mechanics, such as the requirement to scavenge for fragments to bolster combat effectiveness. This scavenging system, unique to the DLC, adds a layer of complexity that rewards exploration but also demands meticulous attention to detail from players.

Content and Exploration Depth

A recurring critique leveled against the Elden Ring DLC is its perceived lack of content depth in certain areas. While the game’s sprawling, open-world design is praised for its grandeur and intricacy, some players have lamented sparse regions devoid of meaningful interactions or narrative depth. This disparity in content perception highlights the subjective nature of exploration-driven gameplay and the challenges in catering to diverse player expectations.

Technical and Aesthetic Aspects

From an artistic standpoint, the Elden Ring DLC has received accolades for its visual aesthetics and atmospheric design. The game’s world-building and art direction have been lauded for their attention to detail and immersive qualities, drawing players deeper into its fantastical realms. However, criticisms regarding reused assets and recolored enemies have surfaced, suggesting potential shortcuts in development that may impact the overall experience for some players.

Community Response and Review Bombing

One of the most contentious aspects of the Elden Ring DLC’s release has been the phenomenon of review bombing on platforms like Steam. This backlash, driven largely by dissatisfaction with the difficulty spike and perceived shortcomings in content and design, has polarized the community. While some dismiss these reviews as knee-jerk reactions, others argue they reflect genuine concerns about the DLC’s direction and execution.

Developer Perspective and Future Expectations

Insights from FromSoftware’s development team, including statements from director Hidetaka Miyazaki, underscore their commitment to maintaining the DLC’s challenge level. Interviews and developer commentary emphasize the importance of difficulty in enhancing player satisfaction and fostering a sense of achievement. This stance suggests that any potential adjustments to gameplay mechanics or difficulty levels are unlikely in the near term, reinforcing the studio’s dedication to their artistic vision.


In conclusion, the Elden Ring DLC has sparked impassioned debates within the gaming community, highlighting the divergent expectations and experiences of players. While the DLC’s steep difficulty and exploration-driven gameplay have proven divisive, its artistic merits and commitment to challenging gameplay have also garnered acclaim. As discussions continue to unfold, the future reception and legacy of the DLC remain uncertain but undeniably significant.

Final Thoughts

The controversy surrounding the Elden Ring DLC underscores the complex interplay between player expectations, developer intentions, and the evolving landscape of gaming culture. Whether viewed as a triumph of design complexity or a misstep in player engagement, the DLC’s impact on the broader gaming community is poised to resonate for the foreseeable future.



Mavis Conor

I’m Mavis Conor, a Medium writer blending pet care and tech. 🐶🐱💻 Passionate about making pet parenting smarter! 🐾✨