Book Review: A Court of Frost and Starlight by Sarah J. Maas | Book 3.5 of A Court of Thorns and Roses Series [Spoiler]

M Hussain Naheen
6 min readMay 30, 2024

--

A Court of Frost and Starlight is the next book in the A Court of Thorns and Roses series by Sarah J. Maas. But it is not the fourth installment in the series. The events of this book happen between the A Court of Wings and Ruin (Book 3) and the A Court of Silver Flames (Book 4).

It continues the story of Feyre Archeron and her life in the magical world of Prythian. The book takes place after the great war against the King of Hybern, where Feyre and her friends fought to save Prythian. The story explores the emotional and psychological impact of war on the characters as they struggle to rebuild their lives and find peace.

Set a few months after the war, the story unfolds during the winter solstice, portraying how Feyre and Rhysand, along with their friends and family, navigate the aftermath of trauma and loss. It also illustrates their journey in celebrating the newfound peace and joy they have discovered.

Here are some of the important non-spoiler takeaways from A Court of Frost and Starlight:

Rebuilding and reconciliation

The characters concentrate on the reconstruction of the battered Night Court, Velaris. They are collaborating to mend the devastation left by the war and fortify their alliances with other courts. The story underscores the significance of unity and forgiveness following the triumph over a shared adversary.

Dealing with trauma

The aftermath of the war leaves the characters grappling with trauma, compelling them to confront their past wounds and seek avenues for healing. The narrative delves into their individual journeys of self-discovery and recovery, underscoring the significance of recognizing and processing trauma.

Exploring relationships

The book centers on the intricacies of relationships among the characters, encompassing both romantic and platonic bonds. It delves into the complexities inherent in these relationships, underscoring the crucial roles of communication, trust, and understanding. Additionally, the story explores themes of found family and the resilience derived from strong friendships.

Preparing for the future

Even with the temporary peace, the characters brace themselves for potential future conflicts and threats. Their focus turns toward enhancing their powers and alliances, recognizing that the world remains fraught with dangers. The narrative underscores the significance of preparedness and vigilance in the face of ongoing uncertainty.

Exploring the fae world

The book further expands on the enchanting world of Prythian, delving deeper into its diverse courts and the distinct cultures they embody. It intricately explores the history, traditions, and magic that intricately shape this fantastical realm.

The promise of future adventures

The story concludes with a glimpse of potential future adventures and challenges awaiting the characters, effectively setting the stage for the next installment in the series. This leaves readers filled with excitement and anticipation, eager to continue the unfolding journey.

A Court of Frost and Starlight Spoiler Summary

A Court of Frost and Starlight by Sarah J. Maas is a novella that continues the story from A Court of Wings and Ruin, the third book in the A Court of Thorns and Roses series. The novella unfolds after the war against the King of Hybern and centers around Feyre, Rhysand, and their circle of friends as they celebrate the Winter Solstice and grapple with the aftermath of the conflict.

The story is intricately woven from multiple perspectives, offering insights into the thoughts and experiences of key characters such as Feyre, Rhysand, Cassian, Nesta, Mor, and Elain. Feyre, waking up to Rhysand’s absence due to his involvement in political matters and the reconstruction of the Night Court, decides to engage in Solstice gift shopping. During her excursion, she encounters Mor, and together they select presents for Amren and Azriel. The story also anticipates an upcoming visit to the Hewn City, the Court of Nightmares’ capital, where the characters must connect with the other High Lords and their families.

Rhysand deals with a dispute between Cassian and Devlon, the leader of the Illyrian war camps. Devlon is hesitant to allow women in the camps to train for combat, but Rhysand and Cassian advocate for equal opportunities. Rhysand also faces resentment from some Illyrians who hold him responsible for the deaths of their kin during the war. Despite attempts to appease them through compensation and support, some remain hostile and suspicious.

Meanwhile, Feyre, Rhysand, and Mor journey to the Hewn City, where they meet with Keir, Mor’s father, and Eris, the heir of the Autumn Court. Discussions revolve around territorial boundaries and post-war reconstruction efforts. Rhysand decides to visit the Spring Court alone to assess the damage and extend a helping hand. The court appears nearly deserted, except for Tamlin, who lives in isolation and depression. Rhysand attempts to engage in conversation, but Tamlin remains hostile, blaming him for past misfortunes. Despite Rhysand’s advice to move forward and find a new purpose, Tamlin rejects it, insisting that Rhysand leave.

As preparations for the Solstice party unfold back at the Night Court, Feyre and Rhysand engage in festive activities, decorating their townhouse and exchanging thoughtful gifts. Feyre presents Rhysand with a painting of the night sky, while Rhysand gifts Feyre a necklace adorned with a star pendant. The couple opens up about their hopes and fears for the future, deepening their emotional connection. Feyre shares a vision of a potential child, evoking happiness and sentimentality in Rhysand.

The celebration includes the gathering of their friends and family, with one notable absence: Nesta. Despite the joyous occasion, Nesta has distanced herself and lives in a dilapidated apartment in the city, grappling with vices like drinking and gambling. Feyre, concerned for her sister, has been sending financial support, but Nesta remains unresponsive. Attempting to include her in the festivities, Feyre extends an invitation, but Nesta refuses and abruptly ends the conversation.

The Solstice party unfolds as a festive and joyous occasion featuring an abundance of food, drinks, music, and games. The air is filled with expressions of gratitude and love as everyone exchanges gifts. Feyre, in the spirit of giving, presents Amren with a set of knives, Azriel with a cloak, Cassian with a new sword, Mor with a necklace, and Elain with a gardening book. Rhysand reciprocates the sentiment, offering Amren a rare book, Azriel a spyglass, Cassian a bottle of liquor, Mor a ring, and Elain a pair of earrings.

The gift exchange continues with Amren giving Feyre a bracelet, Azriel presenting Feyre with a dagger, Cassian gifting Feyre a painting, Mor offering a dress, and Elain giving a scarf. Their generosity extends to absent friends, including Lucien, who resides with the Day Court, and thoughtful gifts are also extended to Varian and Cresseida, visitors from the Summer Court. The festive atmosphere reflects the camaraderie and strong bonds among the characters.

Nesta makes a belated appearance at the end of the party solely to collect her check from Feyre. Her demeanor is rude and dismissive, particularly towards Cassian, who has been attempting to reconnect with her since the war. Despite his efforts, Nesta remains unresponsive, causing Cassian to react with hurt and anger. In a fit of frustration, he hurls the gift he purchased for her, a music box, into the river. Nesta departs without uttering a word, and Cassian, grappling with emotions, follows her.

The novella concludes with a tantalizing glimpse into the next book, hinting at the focal point of Cassian and Nesta’s relationship. The teaser features a heated argument outside Nesta’s apartment, where Cassian expresses his unwavering commitment despite her attempts to push him away. Nesta, conflicted and fearful, senses a spark between them. Despite slamming the door in Cassian’s face, she retains the music box that he retrieves from the river, suggesting a potential turning point in their complex relationship.

Conclusion

A Court of Frost and Starlight serves as a poignant glimpse into the lives of Feyre, Rhysand, and their friends in the aftermath of a transformative war. It delves into their collective efforts to cope with trauma, loss, and the optimism they hold for the future. Additionally, the novella acts as a prelude to the forthcoming installment and the fourth book in the series, titled A Court of Silver Flames, which will center around the intricate relationship between Cassian and Nesta — two characters grappling with their painful pasts as they navigate the complexities of the present.

The novella is a celebration of love, friendship, and family while also serving as a stark reminder of the challenges and lurking dangers that persist. It weaves a narrative of healing, forgiveness, and resilience, portraying the characters’ journey to find joy and peace amid the lingering shadows of darkness.

Originally Published at https://www.booksandlore.com/ on December 16, 2023.

--

--