Your declination to “address the math” is telling.

Adam Selene

603

It seems you have a basic misunderstanding about how math applies to the real world. Math can’t be used to prove anything about the real world, it can only prove things about a model of it. If the model is similar enough to reality, the mathematical observations can be insightful. Murch has demonstrated that the model in the original post is broken beyond repair, and hence the math is moot. There is nothing to address.