I know what you’re saying — but there are serious flaws here. Sometimes your gut is wrong. It can lie. (For example, the terror of uncertainty that your brain knows you should lean into, but your gut screams ABANDON SHIP).
One of the reasons Mark Watney (‘The Martian’) was so appealing was his ability to sit down and absolutely think the shit out of the problems he was facing. Deep-thinking is one of the great lost arts of creativity and business. We should all want to deep-think like that — as long as it doesn’t stop us acting, when we draw our conclusions.