Starting with Anthony Powell and ending with De Kooning via Hegel

Several weeks ago I was invited to lunch by a good friend,Addison Parks, who asked several mutual acquaintances to join us. I recalled that one of the guests in his role

of gallery director had shown the work of a friend of mine, Don Shambroom ,whom

I had met at college almost forty years ago. I told the gallery director,John Wronoski,

that this friend had appeared and disappeared in my life and had

recently reappeared after an absence of ten years by being highlighted

as someone I might want to link up with on LinkedIn. The gallery director,

who is also an antique book dealer, said that my description of this

relationship reminded him of the Anthony Powell twelve volume book

”A Dance to the Music of Time”, that follows the lives of a group of Oxford

graduates over a lifetime as their movements conjoin or pull apart.

Recently I decided to make the leap from virtual reality to

the real world and actually get together to chat with this artist friend.

We arranged a visit at his home in Massachusetts.

One thing we learned in our five hour talk is that there

were other people, whom we both knew, who were participating in

this dance, some, in particular, art professors from College whom we

both knew and others whom we had become friends with separately. The first

of these latter connections was our visits with Norman Rockwell in the

Sixties as aspiring young teenage artists. We both got the same

advice from him to go to art school and not college, which

we both ignored.

Our conversation touched briefly on my blog and in particular the piece on

the “Humpty Dumpty Effect”. My description of this process had a strongly

entropic bias to it. As Yeats said in “The Second Coming: ” Things fall apart
the center cannot hold”. De Kooning’s name came up as someone who took
things apart and then tried to put them back together again. Cubism allowed him
to tear apart but the holism of the human body and the force of his gesture
allowed him to tie everything back together in a way that the human body had
 never before been subjected to: centripetal and centrifugal

at each others throats. Last night I came across a book on Heidegger’s late

writings entitled “Four Seminars” that are transcripts and analyses of

gatherings of Heidegger and his students in the South of France to discuss

in particular some portentous Hegelian sentences. All of this is off the cuff.

His references range from Wittgenstein to Marx to Norbert Weiner. A quote

from Hegel becomes the source material for a long discussion, which I think is

relevant to what has been said above in regards to de Kooning.The original

statement by Hegel goes as follows:” A mended sock is better than a torn one”.

Heidegger transforms it into his preferred form:” A torn sock is better than

a mended one.” His discussion revolves around unity. When the sock is whole

and being worn we are not aware of its unity. When it is torn we become aware

or self-conscious of what holds it together in its being as sock. Therefore the split

points to a preceding wholeness. To mend it brings it whole again but with a

self-awareness of an underlying unity. Is this not what de Kooning does: he

takes the world apart and then tries to mend it. Hegel says that the scission

points to a need for philosophy. I think that this bringing

back together is explosive in two ways: #1 the effort to tie things back, the

mending. #2 The force that resists this mending and wants to dissolve again.

His work participates in a dialectic as it moves back and forth between

the whole and its parts and back again to a new whole.


Posted by Martin Mugar at 11:50 AM

Email ThisBlogThis!Share to TwitterShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest

Labels: Addison Parks, De Kooning, Don Shambroom, Hegel, Heidegger, John Wronoski, Karl Marx, Norman Rockwell, Wittgenstein


  1. Carl BelzOctober 18, 2014 at 8:56 AM
  2. Just wanted to say I enjoyed traveling along with your words.
  3. ReplyDelete
  1. AnonymousMay 31, 2016 at 6:06 AM
  2. (from FB) Thanks Martin. I think you’ve hit the nail on the head. Was just struck by the power and the simultaneous discord and grace of a de Kooning at the Whitney last week.
  3. ReplyDelete