Antifragility, Bitcoin, and Fantasy Football Draft Strategy

Nick Ward
Nick Ward
Jul 8 · 8 min read

Fantasy Football players and Bitcoiners use the same strategic thinking principles when building for an uncertain future.

Image for post
Image for post
“Nassim Nicholas Taleb is a Lebanese-American essayist, scholar, mathematical statistician, and former option trader and risk analyst, whose work concerns problems of randomness, probability, and uncertainty.” — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nassim_Nicholas_Taleb

INTRODUCTION

Life is a constant stream of decisions, the outcomes of which shape our futures. In this constant churn of decisions, we seek to improve our odds against the inevitability of randomness, whenever possible. We want to make well-informed decisions to best position ourselves to benefit from these external uncertainties. All people use this probabilistic approach in their daily lives, whether it is realized it or not, i.e., If I want the best outcome, should I do X or Y? Which one has the higher probability of a favorable outcome? That’s the one I choose.

As it turns out, Bitcoin believers and Fantasy Football players are kindred spirits when it comes to making decisions that benefit from chaos. Bitcoiners and a certain sect of Fantasy Football drafters are both betting on probabilistic outcomes using the same foundational principle. A principle that was conceived and popularized by scholar, mathematical statistician, and former risk analyst, Nassim Nicholas Taleb. That principle is called “antifragility

Qualities of the antifragile are outlined by Taleb as follows:

Image for post
Image for post
As exposure to stressors accumulate over time, the ‘fragile’ break, but the ‘antifragile’ grow stronger.

In recent years, many fantasy footballers gravitated towards a new drafting strategy, popularized by Shawn Siegele in 2013. That strategy is called “Zero-RB” drafting. Simply put, not drafting any Running Back position players until the later rounds in their drafts.

HOW DOES THE “ZERO RB” DRAFT STRATEGY WORK?

The aim for the Zero RB draft strategy is to utilize your early round, higher draft capital on players with less downside risk. Since the Running Back position experiences significantly more injuries than other player positions, Zero RB drafters look to avoid spending high draft capital on players that carry added risk. Instead, they load up on positions with more favorable risk profiles in early rounds, like Wide Receiver. This allows them to use the middle and late rounds of drafts to take a bunch of antifragile bets, by accumulating low-cost, high-upside Running Backs.

Not only does avoiding drafting Running Backs in early rounds minimize risk exposure, but taking a bunch of late round dart throws at Running Backs pays off at a higher risk/return rate than any other position. Why? Because Running Backs disproportionately benefit from the highly fragile landscape that the NFL offers. Like any antifragile bet, mid-late round Running Backs benefit from chaos, disorder, and/or random events like multi-week or season ending injuries. These events can cripple a fantasy team, and break what once seemed like a well-balanced roster construction.

Some direct examples of the NFL’s highly fragile landscape:

  • Player sustains injury in training camp.
  • Player sustains multi-week or season-ending injury.
  • Player fails a drug test; suspended multiple weeks.
  • Rookie player outshines expectations; unseats incumbent player.
  • Player has a psychotic breakdown and gets released by multiple teams.
  • Player involved in sexual assault allegations, put on Commisioner’s exempt list rendering him unable to play.

Those that gain from these fragile circumstances are not typically the teams that drafted Running Backs in the early rounds. Instead, many of these fragile events increase the probability that a Zero RB roster construction is the winning strategy. These multi-week or season ending injuries cause the Running Backs accumulated in the mid-late draft rounds to increase in value, as it becomes more likely that they crack the starting lineup for their team.

These players are the low-risk, high-upside bets that you want to have made in the wake of “Black Swan” events. They are the backups, the rookies, and the players with freak athletic profiles who’s opportunities to accrue fantasy points for your team are about to increase significantly in the face of chaos.

TL;DR: The Zero-RB strategy is simple. Flip fragility on it’s head, and find a way to benefit from it. Build an antifragile roster in a fragile NFL landscape.

Image for post
Image for post

WHAT DOES THIS HAVE TO DO WITH BITCOIN?

The strategic balancing of economic incentives has allowed Bitcoin to achieve something that has never before been achievable by humankind; absolute scarcity. A provably finite supply. Easily verifiable, and openly displayed to anyone across the world.

Bitcoin may be the most significant alignment of computer science, economics, and game theory ever discovered. Since 2009, its network has continued to grow consistently and globally. Bitcoin’s core value proposition is not that you can pay people instantly and cheaply. It’s not coming for the likes of PayPal or Visa. It’s coming for Store of Value assets like gold, real estate, or fine art, and eventually the US Dollar. Bitcoin is being accumulated by investors because they are recognizing that not only does it have similar monetary properties to gold, but that Bitcoin significantly outperforms them across most of those measures. It also offers a few additional properties that we’ve never seen before in a monetary asset. Being purely digital information, Bitcoin is incredibly portable, highly divisible, and openly programmable.

As of today, the opportunity cost is low because we are still early in Bitcoin’s technology adoption cycle. While being early also does mean it carries more risk, the potential upside if Bitcoin succeeds in becoming an internet-native global money significantly outweighs that downside. It’s a strategy that Nassim Taleb would say has highly favorable ‘asymmetry’. Taleb explains this opportunity as follows:

Image for post
Image for post

In CONTRAST with Zero RB draft strategy, where players seek to accumulate Running Backs in the later stages of a draft, Bitcoiners seek to accumulate Bitcoin in the early stages of its technology adoption life cycle.

In SIMILARITY with Zero RB draft strategy, where players seek to construct an antifragile roster. Bitcoiners seek to accumulate Bitcoin, strengthening their position in the face of a precarious and highly uncertain surrounding environment.

When you’re allocating some of your money into Bitcoin, no matter how big or small your holdings, you’re placing an antifragile bet. It is a bet that Bitcoin has the properties, qualities and ability to outperform other Store of Value assets, and forms of money. Bitcoin also carries the much lower probability outcome of replacing the US Dollar as the global monetary base in the longer time horizon. The potential returns in these scenarios highly outweigh the current opportunity cost, creating an investment opportunity with asymmetric upside potential.

WHY DOES BITCOIN BENEFIT FROM FRAGILE EVENTS?

Bitcoin is programmable. This allows it to adapt, manuever around and overcome the roadblocks that it faces. Bitcoin is an antifragile choice that exists inside a fragile complex system, just like the injury-wrought fantasy football landscape. It is antifragile because it runs on a decentralized, globally distributed network of computers and is built with open-source code that is fully verifiable to any and all observers. This assures that 2 key rules stay in place:

  • RULE #1: There will never be more than 21 million Bitcoin. The entire supply must be openly auditable by anyone.
  • RULE #2: No one can change Rule #1 without an overwhelming consensus from 51% of the network’s users.
Image for post
Image for post

Bitcoin does not merely just resist change with these rules. Each failed attempt also means that Bitcoin adapts, improves, and belief in its permanence grows stronger as a result.

For a deeper dive into the specific traits that make Bitcoin so antifragile, I highly recommend reading Parker Lewis’ series “Gradually, Then Suddenly”. Here is a quick snapshot:

ON A LONG ENOUGH TIMESCALE…

The timescale for the antifragile bets of Fantasy Football players to play out is ~17 weeks, the length of the NFL regular season. However, for Bitcoin the timescale is unknowable and indefinitely extending. One potential timescale to consider for context might be the historical timeline of world reserve currencies, visualized below:

Image for post
Image for post

The reserve currency transition is a cycle that has typically lasted in history somewhere between 80 to 110 years. The US dollar has been the official global reserve currency for 73 years now.

As it stands today for Bitcoin, we’re currently in the late rounds of the draft. As more time goes by, assuming Bitcoin continues to strengthen and gain adoption, the opportunity cost becomes higher. Today, it might cost you a 12th or 13th round pick for some Bitcoin. In a few years, you might be paying up with your 1st rounder.

TL;DR: The Bitcoiner’s strategy is simple. Flip fragility on it’s head, and find a way to benefit from it. Build an antifragile portfolio in a fragile financial landscape.

CONCLUSION

Zero RB drafters and Bitcoiners are both using the same decision-making principle (antifragility) to aid them in decision-making amongst inevitable randomness. They put faith in provable math instead of human error. Each use computer science as a tool for enhancing their decision making, in the hope’s of increasing their odds of an advantageous future outcome.

As Tyler Winklevoss has said of himself and other Bitcoiner believers:


If you are here because you are a Fantasy Football player:

If you are here because you are a Bitcoiner:

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store