“Black Mirror Season 6: Ranking the Episodes from Best to Worst”

Nilufer Ozmekik
8 min readJun 22, 2023

--

The official poster of “Black Mirror season 6”

Can we all agree that “Black Mirror” is one of the most mind-boggling, thought-provoking, and jaw-dropping series in the history of television? If you’re on board, let’s delve into what sets this series apart by exploring its unique qualities, the criticisms it has faced, and the reasons why it has engrossed viewers, myself included. So, let’s jump right in:

“Black Mirror”, created by Charlie Brooker, has become a cultural phenomenon with its thought-provoking narratives and dystopian themes. Since its inception, the series has captivated audiences worldwide with its unique storytelling and unsettling portrayal of the dark side of technology. In this article, we delve into what makes Black Mirror truly distinctive, explore its main philosophy, examine its criticism points, and highlight some of the best episodes that have left an indelible mark on viewers.

Uniqueness:

Black Mirror stands out for its ability to blend speculative fiction with a chilling reflection on society’s relationship with technology. Rather than presenting a linear narrative, each episode offers a standalone story, allowing viewers to explore different dimensions of a dystopian future or a twisted present. The show’s anthology format grants the creators the freedom to experiment with diverse genres, tones, and perspectives, making every episode a unique viewing experience.

Salma Hayek, Anjana Vasan, and Aaron Paul: Stellar Cast of “Black Mirror Season 6"

Criticism Points:

While Black Mirror has garnered widespread acclaim, it has also faced criticism on certain fronts. One common critique is its tendency to focus on the darker aspects of technology, often portraying a bleak future without fully exploring the potential benefits or positive aspects. Some argue that this narrow perspective may create an imbalanced portrayal and fail to acknowledge the potential for technological progress to enhance our lives. Additionally, the series has been criticized for occasionally relying on shock value and disturbing imagery to evoke a reaction from viewers, which may overshadow the underlying message.

Now, let’s dive into Season 6, starting with the best episode and working our way down. Here’s my choice for the best episode of the series:

  1. BEST EPISODE: ”Beyond The Sea” (Season 6 episode 3)

My stars: 8/10

Genre: Sci-fi, thriller, mystery

Starring: Aaron Paul, Josh Hartnett, Kate Mara, Rory Culkin, Audren Thornton.

Director: John Crowley

Written by: Charlie Brooker

Aaron Paul and Kate Mara: Actors in “Beyond the Sea” Episode of Black Mirror Season 6

Synopsis: In an alternative 1969, two men, Cliff Stanfield (played by Aaron Paul) and David Ross (played by Josh Hartnett), leave Earth with their replicas to live with their families, embarking on a perilous high-tech mission in space. However, when David Ross’ family on Earth is massacred by a group of wannabe cult members led by Kappa (played by Rory Culkin), Cliff suggests that David fill his replica’s place to reunite with his wife Lana (played by Kate Mara) and his young son Henry (played by Daniel Bell). However, this seemingly kind offer may lead to unforeseen and striking consequences.

Aaron Paul and Josh Hartnett: Actors in “Beyond the Sea” Episode of Black Mirror Season 6

What makes the episode special: The brilliant acting by Aaron Paul and Josh Hartnett, combined with a mind-boggling ending that will leave you screaming in astonishment!

2)” ‘Joan is Awful’ (Season 6, episode 1)

Rating: 7.5 /10

Genre: Comedy, sci-fi, mystery

Starring: Annie Murphy, Salma Hayek, Michael Cera, Himesh Patel, Ben Barnes.

Director: Ally Pankiw

Written by: Charlie Brooker

Poster of “Joan is Awful” episode on Season 6.

Synopsis:

Joan (played by Annie Murphy) is an average woman trapped in a dissatisfying job and an unfulfilling relationship that has lost its spark. When her ex-boyfriend returns to town with a proposition, it stirs up rekindled feelings within her. Upon returning home and streaming on Streamberry (an alternative version of Netflix), she discovers a new show called ‘Joan is Awful,’ which depicts an exact copy of the day she just lived, portrayed by Salma Hayek. As Joan tries to break free from the control of the streaming platform executives, she finds herself in a web of complications she never anticipated.

Annie Murphy and Salma Hayek: Actors in “Joan is Awful” Episode of Black Mirror Season 6

What makes the episode special: The captivating performances by both Annie Murphy and Salma Hayek, along with the intriguing and highly entertaining concept, add to the episode’s smart and mind-boggling nature. With a satisfying conclusion, it delivers a positive message.

“3) ‘Loch Henry’ (Season 6, episode 2)

Rating: 7/10

Genre: Thriller, Mystery, Suspense, Murder Mystery

Starring: Samuel Blenkin, Myha’la Herrold, Daniel Portman, John Hannah, Monica Dolan Director: Sam Miller

Written by: Charlie Brooker

Samuel Blenkin and Myha’la Herrold Actors in “Loch Henry” Episode of Black Mirror Season 6

Synopsis:

Davis (played by Samuel Blenkin) and Pla (played by Myha’la Herrold) are a couple who visit Davis’ widowed mother, Janet (played by Monica Dolan), in a quiet Scottish town called Loch Henry. During their visit, they encounter Davis’ old friend Stuart (played by Daniel Portman), who manages the family’s bar business while caring for his grumpy and alcoholic father, Richard (played by John Hannah). Their discussions revolve around the town’s infamous serial killer, Ian Adair, which sparks an idea in Pla’s mind: making a true crime documentary about the brutal murder of a couple at the hands of Ian Adair. However, their pursuit of the truth uncovers dangerous secrets that could ruin their lives forever, including those involving Davis’ police officer father.

Samuel Blenkin in “Loch Henry” Episode of Black Mirror Season 6

What makes the episode special: Although it starts off a bit slow, ‘Loch Henry’ gradually draws you into the gripping murder mystery of a small town. Monica Dolan’s performance as Janet Blenkin and the seasoned actor John Hannah (whom we adore from the ‘Mummy’ series, don’t we?) are outstanding. The shocking twist at the end will leave you screaming for at least five minutes!”

4) “Demon 79” (Season 6 , episode 5)

Rating: 6/ 10

Genre: Horror, apocalyptic, mystery, dark comedy.

Starring: Anjana Vasan, Paapa Essiedeu, Katherine Rose Morley, David Shields

Director: Toby Haynes

Written by: Bisha K. Ali, Charlie Brooker

Paapa Essiedeu and Anjana Vasan: Actors in “Demon 79” Episode of Black Mirror Season 6

“Synopsis:

Nida Huq (played by Anjana Vasan) leads an unhappy life as a shoe sales assistant in Northern England in 1979. She struggles to tolerate her bullying co-worker, Vicky (played by Katherine Rose Morley), and her boss’s racist remarks, which force her to eat lunch in the mall basement (as her bully coworker claims that ethnic foods can be excessively smelly). However, when she stumbles upon an ancient entity in the basement, she unknowingly opens a Pandora’s box that could lead her to orchestrate the end of the world. The best part is that she has a partner in crime who resembles Bobby Farrell from Boney M (played by Paapa Essiedeu, whom we may recognize from the second season of ‘Capture’ — a highly recommended watch).

Paapa Essiedeu plays “demon” in “Demon 79” Episode of Black Mirror Season 6

What makes it stand above average: Anjana Vasan shines in her portrayal of Nida Huq, a shy and introverted shoe seller who fantasizes about eliminating everyone around her. Her performance feels genuine and natural. Paapa Essiedeu is also brilliant as the devil in disguise. The episode does slow-down in the middle with the repetitive concept of finding the worst person to kill, and the exaggerated rise of a Hitler-incarnated fascist leader may feel a bit excessive. However, the unexpected and enjoyable conclusion adds a fun twist!”

5) THE WORST EPISODE OF SEASON 6: “Mazey Day” (Season 6 , episode 4)

Rating: 4/6

Genre: Horror, supernatural, mystery

Starring: Zazie Beetz, Clara Rugaard, Danny Ramirez, Robbie Tann

Director: Uta Briesewitz

Written by: Charlie Brooker

Zazie Beetz and Clara Rugaard: Actors in “Mazey Day” Episode of Black Mirror Season 6

Synopsis:

A troubled starlet decides to lay low after being involved in a hit-and-run incident. She must confront the consequences of her dark past while evading persistent paparazzi.

Zazie Beetz and Clara Rugaard: Actors in “Mazey Day” Episode of Black Mirror Season 6

Why you shouldn’t bother to watch it:

The writing in “Mazey Day” is plagued by sloppiness, with inconsistencies and plot holes that detract from the overall experience. The concept itself feels out of place within the thematic scope of Black Mirror, a series known for its thought-provoking exploration of the dark side of technology and society. This departure from the show’s established vision is a major letdown for fans eagerly awaiting another mind-bending installment.

Furthermore, the execution of the episode suffers from weak acting performances, making it difficult for viewers to fully immerse themselves in the story. The direction by Uta Briesewitz lacks focus, resulting in a disjointed and aimless narrative that fails to engage. As the plot unfolds, the lack of a clear direction becomes increasingly frustrating, leaving audiences dissatisfied.

Regrettably, “Mazey Day” has already garnered a reputation as the worst episode in the entire six-season run of Black Mirror. It is even ranked lower than the widely criticized “Rachel, Jack and Ashley Too,” the disastrous final episode of Season 5 that starred Miley Cyrus. This serves as a strong indication that this particular episode may not be worth your time.

Why Should We Keep Binge-Watching Black Mirror?

There are several compelling reasons why we should continue binge-watching “Black Mirror”. Firstly, the series offers a unique and thought-provoking exploration of the dark side of technology and society. Each episode presents a self-contained story that delves into the potential consequences of our increasing reliance on technology, challenging our perceptions and raising important questions about its impact on our lives.

Binge-watching “Black Mirror” allows us to fully immerse ourselves in its thought-provoking themes and narratives. The interconnectedness of the episodes often reveals subtle connections and Easter eggs that add to the overall richness of the viewing experience.

Moreover, “Black Mirror” sparks important conversations and encourages critical thinking. The series serves as a catalyst for discussions about the ethical implications of technology, the erosion of privacy, the impact on social dynamics, and the potential consequences of our actions in a technologically advanced world.

--

--

Nilufer Ozmekik

New York Winter Film Awards judge since 2017, screenwriter for TV series and international award-winning feature films, most popular reviewer of Goodreads..