…ssues, the method of “critique by redesign” may be just the blend that will help advance the field. The truth is that perceptual psychology and related sciences can provide some guidance for visualization, but are nowhere near advanced enough to completely answer all real-world design questions. Ultimately, human judgment remains essential to the process. And while the lack of context and col…
…onfusion in criticism by redesign. Seen from a tradition where critique largely happens in private, a public redesign can feel unduly personal and exposed. A critique that happens in public, available to anyone who clicks the right link, loses much of the…