Do trans women ‘retain male pattern violence’?

Gemma Stone
5 min readJan 9, 2018

Obviously not. But lets look at the claim, the evidence for it and see if we have any evidence to disprove the claim anyway. You know, for shits and giggles.

This claim is thrown around online an awful lot, especially by a lot of the TERFs I talk to. It’s their ultimate GOTCHA! as to why trans women should be considered men and kept out of muh female safe spaces, such as bathrooms. If there is a significantly increased risk of violence against women because of trans women, then they’ve got a good basis on which to continue arguing for sex segregated spaces.

So where did they get this idea from? It comes from a Swedish study which looked at a cohort of trans people across years to measure their outcomes. It’s the infamously misquoted and misrepresented Karolinska Institute study.

This study is so over misquoted and misrepresented that the author herself had to come forwards and give an interview to try and dispell the myths surrounding it. More on that later, first lets look at what the study actually says about violence regarding trans women.

regarding any crime, male-to-females had a significantly increased risk for…

--

--

Gemma Stone

Transgender journalist. All of my writing is available for free @ TransWrites.World.