Chasing Dreams in Japan: Challenges and Dynamics of Indonesian Migrant Workers in Japan
As one of the most developed countries in the world, Japan is a popular destination for job seekers, especially from developing countries like Indonesia. The motivations driving these Indonesian migrant workers to leave their hometowns include the pursuit of better job opportunities, higher incomes, and life experiences in a country with different languages and customs. The cultural differences between life in Indonesia and Japan necessitate that Indonesian workers adopt various strategies to survive and thrive until their work contract terms are fulfilled.
There are significant and different cultural contrasts between living in Indonesia and Japan. Indonesian migrant workers frequently must adjust fast to a strange and new environment. Because of this adaptation, they must use a variety of techniques to get by and prosper until the end of their employment contract.
One of the most immediate challenges that Indonesian migrant workers face is language limitations, which forces Indonesian migrant workers to either learn Japanese or figure out how to communicate successfully in a work environment. Furthermore, it is essential to comprehend and respect Japanese traditions and workplace etiquette. Japanese work culture is renowned for its emphasis on accuracy, timeliness, and a strong sense of respect for teamwork and hierarchy, all of which can be very different from customs in Indonesia.
Furthermore, the physical and emotional distance from family and familiar support networks can be difficult. Indonesian workers must find new social circles and support systems in Japan, which can help mitigate feelings of isolation and homesickness. Some may engage in community activities or connect with fellow Indonesian expatriates to build a sense of camaraderie and mutual support.
In addition to social and cultural adjustments, there are practical considerations such as housing, healthcare, and financial management. Navigating these aspects in a foreign country requires careful planning and resourcefulness. Many migrant workers take advantage of support services provided by both governmental and non-governmental organizations to assist with these transitions.
The journey of Indonesian migrant workers to Japan is driven by the quest for improved economic prospects and enriched life experiences. While the cultural and logistical challenges are significant, the strategies they employ to adapt to their new environment demonstrate resilience and determination. Their ability to navigate these differences not only enables them to succeed professionally but also enriches their personal growth, contributing to a broader understanding between the two cultures.
Countries such as Japan and South Korea are experiencing an increasing need for foreign workers due to their low workforce numbers. Low population growth as a result of low birth rates, increasing numbers of elderly people who have entered the unproductive category, have resulted in a low number of productive workers. Consequently, there is a high demand for foreign workers to fill these gaps. For Japan and South Korea, the influx of foreign workers is essential to maintain economic stability and growth. These workers are not only filling crucial roles in various industries such as manufacturing, healthcare, and services but are also bringing diverse skills and perspectives that can drive innovation and efficiency.
From the perspective of Indonesian workers, Japan and South Korea offer opportunities that are often unattainable in their home country. The prospect of higher wages, better working conditions, and the chance to experience life in a technologically advanced society are compelling motivators. In addition to economic benefits, these workers often seek personal growth through exposure to new cultures, languages, and ways of life.
The motivation behind an Indonesian migrant worker to Japan is not solely by material or collecting money that usually these migrant workers will send money from their work to their families in Indonesia or commonly called remittances. Seeking new life experiences and increasing insight is also a dominant motivation for Indonesian migrant workers in Japan. This happens because the majority of their age is still young and unmarried, which is one of the factors that life experience and breadth of insight are very necessary for their self-development in the following periods. They as migrant workers in Japan also usually look for better job opportunities in Japan compared to working in Indonesia because in Indonesia they usually work with small salaries. They do not only focus on work and making money, but they also try to master technology, as long as they are still in Japan, the country where the technology originated.
In the case of Indonesian migrant workers in Japan, the push and pull models theory of migration is highly relevant. This theory explains why individuals migrate from one country to another by identifying the factors that push them away from their home country and the factors that pull them towards a new destination.
“Push-pull models highlight economic, environmental, and demographic forces that drive people away from their origins and toward their destinations. ‘Push forces’ include population increase, lack of economic possibilities, and political repression, while ‘pull factors’ include labor demand, land availability, economic opportunity, and political freedom.”
For Indonesian migrant workers, several push factors drive their migration to Japan. Economic conditions in Indonesia, including limited job opportunities and low wages, compel individuals to seek better prospects abroad. Poverty and lack of education and skills further exacerbate the situation, leaving many Indonesians with few viable options for improving their quality of life within their home country. Political instability and social issues, such as inadequate healthcare and social services, also contribute to the desire to migrate.
Conversely, pull factors in Japan attract Indonesian workers. Japan’s robust economy offers numerous job opportunities, particularly in sectors experiencing labor shortages, such as healthcare, manufacturing, and construction. The promise of higher wages and better working conditions is a significant draw. Additionally, Japan’s reputation for safety, high standards of living, and modern infrastructure appeals to many seeking a more stable and prosperous environment. Opportunities for skill development and career advancement further incentivize migration to Japan.
The application of the push and pull models theory to Indonesian migrant workers in Japan is evident in the structured and legal pathways facilitated by bilateral agreements and recruitment programs. These agreements often focus on specific sectors where Japan has a labor shortage, aligning with the pull factors that attract Indonesian workers. For instance, the Technical Intern Training Program (TITP) and the Specified Skilled Worker (SSW) visa programs are designed to address Japan’s need for foreign labor while providing Indonesian workers with opportunities for employment and skill enhancement.
These bilateral agreements and recruitment programs are crucial in ensuring that migration is orderly and beneficial for both countries. They provide a framework for the recruitment, training, and placement of Indonesian workers in Japan, offering legal protections and support services to help workers adapt to their new environment. This structured approach helps to mitigate some of the challenges associated with migration, such as exploitation and legal uncertainties.
In conclusion, the push and pull models theory of migration effectively explains the movement of Indonesian migrant workers to Japan. Push factors such as economic conditions, poverty, lack of education and skills, political instability, and social issues drive Indonesians to seek opportunities abroad. Pull factors, including economic opportunities, higher standards of living, skill development, and a reputation for safety and modernity, attract them to Japan. Bilateral agreements and recruitment programs play a vital role in facilitating this migration, ensuring a structured and legal pathway for workers and aligning with the pull factors that draw Indonesian workers to Japan.
In 2023, Heri Akhmadi as an Indonesian Ambassador to Japan said that the number of Indonesian migrant workers in Japan has increased compared to Indonesian students. The Indonesian Ambassador to Japan highlighted that many Indonesians choose to work in Japan due to the attractive employment opportunities and favorable working conditions. The shift indicates a growing preference for employment over education among Indonesians moving to Japan. There are various factors influencing this trend, such as economic incentives and the demand for labor in Japan.
The migration of Indonesian workers to Japan is a complex phenomenon driven by a combination of push and pull factors. Economic difficulties and limited opportunities in Indonesia push individuals to seek better prospects abroad, while Japan’s demand for labor, higher living standards, and opportunities for skill enhancement pull them in. This migration is further supported by structured bilateral agreements and recruitment programs, providing a legal pathway for Indonesian workers to contribute to sectors where Japan faces labor shortages. These workers not only seek financial improvement but also personal and professional growth, making their journey both challenging and transformative.
Reference :
- Castles, S., Miller, M. J., & Ammendola, G. (2005). The Age of Migration: International Population movements in the Modern world. American Foreign Policy Interests, 27(6), 537–542. https://doi.org/10.1080/10803920500434037
- Priyadi, E. S. (2019). TENAGA KERJA INDONESIA DI JEPANG; STUDI TENTANG MOTIVASI YANG MELATARBELAKANGI SESEORANG MENJADI TRAINEE. Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3370845
- Salam, S. N. (2023). PERLINDUNGAN HUKUM TERHADAP PEKERJA MIGRAN INDONESIA DI JEPANG. jurnal-umbuton.ac.id. https://doi.org/10.35326/judicatum.v1i2.4893
- Ng, S. (2023, July 25). Dubes RI Ungkap Pekerja Migran ke Jepang Meningkat Dibanding Mahasiswa. Detiknews. https://news.detik.com/berita/d-6840778/dubes-ri-ungkap-pekerja-migran-ke-jepang-meningkat-dibanding-mahasiswa/amp