Unveiling the Future of Space Exploration: Innovations in Solar Sailing with Carbon Nanotubes

Oguzkirmizi
13 min readOct 22, 2023

--

First Things First: Story of How are We Going That Looooooong Road to Space

Image 1: Gemini-Titan II — used to launch two-man Gemini Spacecraft.

Behold, the audacious spectacle of humanity employing colossal contraptions, the mighty rockets, to transcend the very boundaries of Earth! These “mammoth marvels” demand even more colossal fuel tanks to conquer escape velocity (this is a term in physics which is used to explain the necessary velocity in order to escape from the gravitational attraction). Sometimes we change the fuel to have more efficiency but even by changing it, still we have a BIG fuel tank problem. Because we cannot store enough fuel on rockets to travel interplanetary. Thus, we are currently developing new alternative technologies like electrical combustion or spin launch but they cannot be enough to reach enough speed with small amounts of energy.

Since, in the quest for exploring the vastness of outer space, one major obstacle that scientists and engineers face is the issue of fuel consumption. Traditional space missions heavily rely on conventional fuels, such as liquid hydrogen, to achieve the necessary speed and escape Earth’s orbit. However, this reliance on fuel poses significant challenges when it comes to interplanetary travel.

Think, how beatiful can it be if we have another alternative that can solve these problems. Wait! WE HAVE…

Image 2: From LIGHTSAIL 2 SAIL DEPLOYMENT TEST SUCCESS, 23 MAY 2016 The Planetary Society’s LightSail 2 spacecraft sits on its deployment table following a successful day-in-the-life test at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo on May 23, 2016. Jason Davis / The Planetary Society

“O Captain, my Captain!” Walt Whitman metophorically says to call his ship, to call his captain. People were sailing through the eternal oceans and seas back then. When we found the end of them, we started to think beyond the limits we see. In addition, humanity loves to use it’s old methods for brand new areas such as space. So, there comes a “magical” part with the space sailing concept. Especially, when CNTs integrate to the solar sails, they add more emission and efficiency to the magic.

Why Ought We Embrace Solar Sailing’s Noble Course?

The limited capacity of spacecrafts to carry fuel becomes a major hindrance in their ability to reach higher speeds and cover longer distances. A large portion of the fuel is consumed during the escape from Earth’s gravitational pull, leaving little room for additional fuel that could be used for propulsion in outer space.

In an era of burgeoning possibilities, where the realms of science and technology converge, the arcane yet promising art of solar sailing, emboldened by the integration of carbon nanotubes, stands as a beacon of innovation. As we delve into this captivating journey, we shall unearth the intricate synergy between advanced materials and celestial propulsion, ushering in a new dawn of space exploration. Join me as we embark on a voyage to fathom the profound significance of these pioneering developments, illuminating the path to the future of cosmic exploration.

Image 3: From LIGHTSAIL 2 ARTIST CONCEPT WITH EARTH BEHIND Artist’s concept of LightSail 2 above Earth.Image: Josh Spradling / The Planetary Society

Wait, What is Solar Sailing Actually?

Think of a GIANT blue kite and you are flying it in a very windy day. It will rise and move untill the wind stops. It can even go vertically up or down if you let it to do. So, what if your giant blue kite has no rope and it starts to go up. It will pass through the atmosphere (yes, our kite is fireproof) and eventually it will not stop because there is nothing that can obstruct it by friction. Moreover, we can make our wind by using laser to direct it on the way we want. Unfortunately we have come to the end of our kite’s story. It is time to dive in SOLAR SAILS story. Kites have a lot in common with solar sails in moving principals. Luckily, solar sails do not need wind to fly!

Image 4: Our imaginary GIANT blue kite (via. Unsplash — https://unsplash.com/photos/blue-butterfly-in-flight-MBDX-tPnqpY)

Recent History of Space Sailing Theory

Space sailing (or solar sailing) was a theory when it was started to have been worked on at the beginning. The idea was belonging to the Johannes Kepler at first. His observations on comets which were leaving their star trails around the Sun. Then, James Clerk Maxwell’s electromagnetic fields theory proved the light(photon) pressure concept. Moreover, this concept became a topic for science fiction books as well. Arthur C. Clarke, wrote the “Sunjammer”, a short story about race between solar sails which use radiation pressure.

The theory became reality in 2006 when NASA’s Glenn Research Center actually prepared a solar sail-NanoSailD. This solar sail launched succesfully to the Earth orbit in 2011. This mission showed that solar sail technology can measure and collect data faster and more accurate. Another benefit of using solar sail is, getting rid of nearly 8000 pieces of space debris caused by launch. Basically, solar sailing have good impacts on not only after launching process but also launching process itself.

Space Sailing is changing the rules for exploring the space. In basic terms, spaceship uses the electrophotonic particles and photons from solar winds or Earth’s surface. This new method unlocks the potential for interplanetery missions to be faster and to have lower costs from alternative space travel methods. Solar sails have extended sails which capture the momentum of light from source. One of good things of solar sailing is, the “source” can be a concentrated laser based on Earth or they can use stars’ -mostly Sun’s for us- light. Solar sails utilize sunlight as a means of propulsion, harnessing the energy from photons emitted by the Sun. By deploying large reflective sails that capture and reflect sunlight, spacecrafts can generate thrust without relying solely on traditional fuels.

Diagram 1: Mechanical principals of solar sails, from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/326158620_Strong_Solar_Radiation_Forces_from_Anomalously_Reflecting_Metasurfaces_for_Solar_Sail_Attitude_Control
Image 5: Steam clouds, the product of the SLS main engines’ hydrogen-oxygen reaction, pour from an RS-25 engine during testing at NASA’s Stennis Space Center.

Solar sails offer several advantages over conventional propulsion systems. They eliminate the need for carrying excessive amounts of fuel, enabling spacecrafts to travel longer distances with greater efficiency. Additionally, solar sails provide continuous acceleration as long as they are exposed to sunlight, allowing for gradual but steady increases in speed over time.

- Solar sailing and CNTs

  • In the realm of space exploration, a remarkable synergy emerges when solar sails and carbon nanotubes take the stage. This partnership represents a profound convergence of cutting-edge technology and our insatiable human drive for innovation.
  • Solar sails, these silent giants of space, utilize the radiant force of sunlight to gracefully navigate the cosmic ocean. In their performance, they rely on carbon nanotubes, a material renowned for its exceptional properties. These tiny structures contribute vital enhancements to the sails’ structure and functionality, showcasing the potential to revolutionize our approach to space exploration.
  • This connection demonstrates our capacity to leverage advanced materials to achieve feats that, at first glance, might appear insurmountable. As we direct our gaze towards the star-studded canvas of space, the marriage of solar sails and carbon nanotubes ushers in a new era of exploration and discovery. This partnership holds the promise of propelling us towards distant planets, asteroids, and the enigmatic frontiers of interstellar space.

While solar sail technology is still in its early stages of development and implementation, it holds immense potential for revolutionizing space exploration missions. By reducing dependence on traditional fuels and offering a more sustainable approach to interplanetary travel, solar sails pave the way for exciting possibilities in our quest to explore distant worlds within our solar system and beyond.

As we continue to push boundaries and expand our understanding In the vast of outer space, it is crucial that we explore alternative propulsion methods like solar sails to overcome the challenges posed by limited fuel resources. By embracing innovative technologies and seeking sustainable solutions, we can unlock new frontiers in space exploration while minimizing our impact on Earth’s precious resources.

Solution: Innovative, Efficient, Necessary

Carbon Nanotubes (CNTs) show tremendous promise in space sailing and interplanetary missions. Their distinctive atomic geometry provides exceptional flexibility and a remarkable strength-to-weight ratio, thanks to their hexagonal lattice shape. CNTs can withstand high tensile forces while remaining lightweight, making them an ideal material for space exploration. Their superior flexure tolerance allows them to endure harsh conditions, including high UV radiation and thermal cycling(-170°C to +165°C.) in outer space, making them suitable for long-duration missions and fostering innovative technologies in space exploration. CNTs offer a path towards more efficient and sustainable space travel, potentially revolutionizing our approach to interplanetary missions and extending our reach into the cosmos.

By harnessing the properties of CNTs, scientists and engineers can develop advanced materials that enable more efficient propulsion systems, lightweight spacecraft structures, and improved energy storage solutions. These advancements have the potential to enhance the feasibility and success rate of interplanetary missions while reducing costs associated with traditional spacecraft designs.

- SWCNTs

  • Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes (SWCNTs) are exceptional nanomaterials with a wide range of desirable properties and attributes that make them highly valuable in various scientific, technological, and industrial applications. SWCNTs are emerging as a groundbreaking material in the field of solar sailing. Solar sailing is a revolutionary concept that harnesses the power of photons from the sun to propel spacecraft through the vacuum of space. SWCNTs play a vital role in this technology due to their remarkable properties. These nanotubes are incredibly lightweight and have an unparalleled strength-to-weight ratio, making them ideal for crafting the sails of solar sail spacecraft.
  • SWCNTs’ extraordinary electrical conductivity and thermal properties allow for effective control of the sail’s shape and temperature. When exposed to sunlight, the photons exert pressure on the SWCNT-based sail, propelling the spacecraft forward without the need for conventional propulsion methods, such as chemical rockets. This provides a highly efficient and environmentally friendly means of space travel, as solar sails require no fuel and can continue accelerating over time as long as they remain exposed to sunlight.
Image 6: Schematic representation of single walled carbon nanotube (SWCNT)

Applications

Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) have a host of applications in industries ranging from aerospace to electronics. One particularly interesting use case for CNTs is in solar sailing. CNTs are firstly used in combustion engines because of the durability and heat resistance in Black Brant (especially in Black Brant IX) rockets by NASA. Then the applications became expanding to different areas. Due to their low cost, they have chosen in Mars, Saturn and Venus missions.

Solar sailing refers to the use of light pressure exerted by photons from a star to propel a spacecraft. Using a large, reflective sail, a spacecraft can capture photons and convert their momentum into movement. This technology has the potential for faster and more efficient travel, as it doesn’t require any fuel, engines, or propellant.

Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) have various potential applications in outer space (categorized in graph 1), including the manufacturing of lightweight and durable materials for spacecraft, improving the performance of solar sails, and developing more efficient and reliable energy storage systems for electronics in space. The unique properties of CNTs, such as their high strength-to-weight ratio and electrical conductivity, make them attractive for space exploration.

Graph 1: “Systems analysis of carbon nanotubes: opportunities and challenges for space applications” from Jamshid A Samareh and Emilie J Siochi 2017 Nanotechnology

- JAXA

  • CNTs have been used in combustion engines for their durability and heat resistance, but they’ve also found a use in solar sailing. Because of their low cost, they’ve been chosen for missions to Mars, Saturn, and Venus. JAXA’s IKAROS mission proved that CNTs are ideal for solar sailing, opening up new possibilities for space exploration.
  • The success of IKAROS showed that solar sailing missions could be regulated and calculated based on experimental launches. With CNTs, solar sails can be made to be lighter and faster, while requiring less force. This makes them more efficient and capable of traveling longer distances than traditional methods.

- NASA

  • NASA has identified carbon nanotubes (CNTs) as a promising new technology that can help them achieve their extraordinary missions. Early reports have highlighted the potential applications of CNTs for NASA missions, showing that composites reinforced with single-wall CNTs offer significant improvements over traditional materials like aluminum 2219-T87. However, these early reports did not account for large volume manufacturing constraints, structural design considerations, and other factors like durability and application to non-load bearing components. As a result, some assumptions made in these studies may not be acceptable for certain design situations.
  • One of the promising concepts identified in a workshop on nanotechnology in space exploration was the use of CNTs in thermal, radiation, and impact protective shields (TRIPS). TRIPS is a multifunctional thermal protection system that incorporates hydrogenated CNTs to provide radiation shielding and micrometeorite and orbital debris protection. While the storage level of hydrogen in CNTs may not be adequate to make a significant difference, the TRIPS concept represents an interesting example of technology push that would require a technology pull to identify and quantify the systems-level benefits and risks.
  • Commercial companies are investing in diverse applications of CNTs, but there are still challenges in understanding why the properties of CNT yarns and sheets remain lower than the properties of individual CNTs. Retaining the observed nanoscale properties at the macroscale is important for broad utility of CNTs. The recent NASA Nanotechnology roadmap includes a wide range of technologies and development pathways for the next 20 years, with a focus on applied research and development activities that can have the greatest potential influence on NASA missions. However, there is often a weak link between speculated utility and actual mission demand, and a better understanding of performance requirements and insertion opportunities for CNTs is needed.
Image 7: Photo of NanoSail-D from https://science.nasa.gov/mission/nanosail-d/

- Planetary

  • The Planetary Society is actively researching and developing specific applications of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) for space exploration. One of the key areas they are focusing on is utilizing CNTs in the manufacturing of high-performance solar sails.
  • Solar sails made with CNTs have the potential to significantly enhance the performance and durability of propulsion systems for spacecraft. By incorporating CNTs into the construction of solar sails, the Planetary Society aims to improve their strength-to-weight ratio, enabling spacecraft to generate more propulsive force while keeping the overall weight of the sail system low. The use of CNTs can also enhance the structural integrity of the sail, allowing it to withstand the harsh conditions of space more effectively.
  • In addition to solar sails, the Planetary Society is exploring the integration of CNTs in energy storage systems for electronics in space. CNTs offer unique properties such as high electrical conductivity and large surface area, making them attractive for developing lightweight and efficient energy storage solutions. By utilizing CNTs, the Planetary Society aims to enhance the energy storage capacity and reliability of onboard electronics, ensuring longer operational lifetimes for spacecraft missions.

In summary, the Planetary Society is specifically focusing on utilizing CNTs in the development of high-performance solar sails, energy storage systems, and thermal management solutions. Their research and development efforts aim to harness the unique properties of CNTs to enhance propulsion, energy storage, and protection capabilities in space exploration missions.

Why Do We Need This Technology In Future?

The synergy between solar sailing and carbon nanotubes is undeniably promising for the future of space exploration. As technology continues to evolve, solar sails may soon become a standard propulsion method for missions ranging from interplanetary exploration to deep space observations. The advancements in material science and engineering made possible by CNTs have the potential to open new frontiers in our quest to understand the cosmos.

- Energy Source

  • At the heart of solar sailing lies the most abundant resource in our solar system: sunlight. Unlike traditional rocket propulsion, which requires finite fuel reserves, solar sails capture and convert the energy of photons emitted by the Sun into forward thrust. This creates the potential for indefinite acceleration and the ability to reach astounding speeds. In essence, solar sails offer an “infinite” propulsion source that can power missions far beyond the limits of traditional space travel.

- Budget

  • One of the most compelling aspects of solar sailing is its sustainability. Traditional rocket launches release chemicals and byproducts into space, contributing to the growing problem of space debris. Solar sails, on the other hand, are environmentally friendly and produce no harmful emissions. This sustainability is crucial as we strive to minimize our ecological footprint in space and beyond.
  • Moreover, solar sailing offers substantial cost savings. By eliminating the need for heavy and expensive rocket propellants, it significantly reduces mission expenses. This cost-effectiveness not only makes space exploration more accessible but also allows for more missions to be launched, including those with smaller budgets.

- Interplanetary Exploration

  • Enhanced solar sails will enable faster interplanetary missions. As we aspire to explore the far reaches of our solar system, these technologies will enable spacecraft to reach their destinations more rapidly, revolutionizing our understanding of other planets, moons, and celestial bodies. We can anticipate more frequent missions to the outer planets, asteroid belts, and beyond.

- Space-Based Manufacturing and Power Generation

  • CNTs might find applications in space-based manufacturing. Their unique properties, including exceptional strength and thermal conductivity, make them ideal for creating tools, structures, and even materials in the vacuum of space. This could lead to the establishment of off-world manufacturing facilities, expanding our reach into the cosmos.
  • CNTs hold the potential for applications beyond propulsion in space. These exceptional materials could be used to construct lightweight, durable structures for solar power arrays in space. These arrays could capture energy from the sun without the interference of Earth’s atmosphere and then transmit that energy back to our planet, potentially revolutionizing our energy generation and distribution systems.

Conclusion

CNTs have already revolutionized space exploration by making solar sailing more accessible and cheaper. As technology continues to improve, it’s expected that CNTs will play an even greater role in developing new methods for space travel. The future of space exploration looks bright, and CNTs will be at the forefront of this exciting journey.

The future of space exploration shines brightly, thanks to the groundbreaking synergy of carbon nanotubes and solar sailing. These two innovations have the potential to revolutionize our approach to space travel, enabling more efficient and sustainable missions to explore the cosmos. As we gaze toward the stars, CNT-enhanced solar sails will be our guiding light, propelling us into a future marked by scientific discovery and technological advancements that will shape generations to come. Together, they represent the vanguard of humanity’s expansion into the universe, pioneering the path to the stars.

--

--

Oguzkirmizi

Universe explorer innovator at TKS | A curious mind fascinated by the intricacies of quantum mechanics | Technology aficionado on a mission to change the world