Overcoming Destructive Leadership in the Workplace

Advice From a Leadership Expert

Orion Siebert
3 min readMar 8, 2024
Boss yelling at an employee

I. Introduction

Toxic leadership has become an epidemic that silently infects organizations globally, leaving a wake of human wreckage in its path. Practical solutions exist to curb this scourge and develop an ethical, caring management culture focused on actualizing human potential.

Many so-called leaders wield power without principle, dictating through intimidation and aggression rather than inspiring. They prioritize self-interest over the needs of employees, customers and organizational mission. The resulting fear-based culture rewards silence over truth-telling, gradually normalize abuse.

II. Defining Destructive Leadership

Manager speaking with an office of employees

We must delineate clearly that destructive leadership is not an occasional lapse of judgement under pressure, but rather a habitual pattern of bullying, manipulation or purposeful marginalization of others.

Research correlates toxic leadership with increased turnover, absenteeism, decreased innovation, and poorer performance metrics across industries. Fostering inclusion, psychological safety and care for human dignity conversely lifts both people and organizational outcomes.

III. Recognizing the Signs

Business man sitting in a chair in an office at sunset

Destructive leaders exhibit predictable patterns by which they maintain dominance and control. Hypervigilance to these verbal and behavioral warning signs can accelerate intervention.

Common red flags include persistently berating staff in public, showing callous disregard for others’ needs, shameless self-promoting while devaluing team members’ contributions. Suffering employees often describe psychological imprisonment where they feel powerless to escape despite profound sadness at work.

IV. The Vital Need for Intervention

A bunch of business people sitting in a circle having an intervention

Toxic conduct invariably decays organizational DNA over time. Surfacing and confronting issues early remains vital before dysfunction becomes endemic and inflicts irreparable damage on both people and institutional outcomes.

Research reveals that even witnesses to chronic abuse can experience symptoms resembling PTSD for years afterwards if the perpetrator faces no accountability and remains in power. We must therefore act with courage, recognizing both the human toll and performance cost of inaction.

V. How to Effectively Intervene

man talking to a woman at a business HR

After privately documenting incidents, solutions often require enlisting peer allies across power levels, visibly supporting each other’s humanity. File formal complaints through proper channels, escalating respectfully but decisively if needed until finding resolution.

The path forward relies on our collective moral courage to name injustice, engage in difficult conversations, and ultimately transform culture through tenacious dedication to each person’s growth and dignity.

VI. Instilling Cultural Change

business men shaking hands in an office at sunset

Select supervisors lead by inspiring others’ highest selves rather than wielding an iron fist. This empowers staff at all levels to fully express their capabilities.

Cultural transformation requires that all employees internalize, through ongoing training, the vital expectation of caring leadership. Establish clear reporting procedures should violations occur, with strict accountability for abuse of power.

When people’s growth becomes the currency over profits, all of society progresses.

If you enjoyed this article and want a deeper dive into destructive leadership, listen to the episode this article was based on.

If you want to read more, then consider reading last week’s post.

--

--