ConvertKit Review + Why It’s Better Than MailChimp For PPC

Before we dive into the ConvertKit review on why you should be using ConvertKit over MailChimp (or Aweber) for your email marketing platform, let me quickly tell you how I got here:

Like most people, I started collecting emails using MailChimp (coupled with SumoMe) as my email service provider (ESP).

Why? Because it was free (up to 2000 subscribers). Then I realized I needed some automation, so I upgraded MailChimp to the $10/month plan.

But then what if I go from talking about AdWords to writing about Facebook Ads? Are these people the same audience? Do they want the same emails? Sure there’s probably a lot of overlap, but not 100%.

With MailChimp, I would have to create a new ‘list’ and start from scratch. With ConvertKit, you can just tag people based on what they open or click in your emails (indicating they are interested).

Let’s pretend for a moment that I did have separate lists on MailChimp for AdWords and Facebook Ads.

What if I want to send an email to both lists at once? It’s nearly impossible.. so you end up sending the same email to both lists. But you have a bunch of overlap (people on both lists), so they get your email twice. That’s not good.

Plus they count each email in every list as a separate subscriber, so you potentially pay for the same person 2, 3 or more times.

Do you see why ConvertKit is so much more powerful, user-friendly and customer-friendly?

There’s a few other reason that pushed me over the edge from MailChimp to ConvertKit (even though it starts $19/month higher than I was paying):

  • You actually get more subscribers for the entry-level price: $10 for 500 on MailChimp vs $29 for 1000 on ConvertKit.
  • ConverKit integrates nicely with Gumroad, Teachable, LeadPages and more!
ConvertKit Integrations
  • They let you set up unlimited forms that can each deliver their own custom lead magnet (but you can send people through the same welcome email sequence).

I figured I could hold off on buying LeadPages for a little while if I signed up for ConvertKit because it had the custom forms and opt-in giveaways that I wanted to be able to provide.

What else makes ConverKit awesome?

  • Nathan Barry is the founder (he met me and a few others in Denver when he accidently showed up a month early — ask him about it!)
  • Even though they’re a relatively new player in the email space, the company is transparent and looks to be on a steady growth curve. Check out their metrics here.
  • The interface is easy to use and intuitive. Nathan has a background in design and user experience and it shows.

Sequences (formerly Courses) In ConvertKit

For example, when you go to edit your email sequences, changing the number of days before your next email goes out is not only easy to do — but it’s clear when each one will go out:

You can also drag and drop the emails to rearrange the order your emails go out within your sequence. See the little hamburger menu? Just click and drag.

Broadcast Emails With ConvertKit

If you want to quickly send a broadcast to your entire list or just a specific segment, it’s only a few clicks:

That way, you only send emails to people who actually want to read them. This will keep your open and engagement rates high, which will help your emails keep getting into your customer’s inbox.


I touched on automations earlier, but there’s a lot more you can do:

  • When someone buys a product, add them to a specific ‘thank you + bonus’ sequence
  • When someone buys a product, remove them from the ‘sales’ sequence
  • Tag someone based on the links they click (like I showed you earlier)

Feel free to get creative, this is the fun part!

Check out the automation blueprints ConvertKit put together to help you get started.

Cold Subscribers

We define cold subscribers as anyone who hasn’t opened or clicked an email in the last 90 days and has been subscribed for at least 30 days. -ConvertKit

I’ll let them explain the process, but this makes it really easy to send an email to re-engage your cold subscribers. If they don’t respond or click, delete them.

Incentive Emails (aka Lead Magnets)

Every time someone signs up to your list, you should have them confirm their email address. But one of the unique features with ConvertKit is that this ‘confirmation email’ can double as your lead magnet download. This saves your customer a step and just makes things really slick. Probably my favorite feature.

Why is it better than MailChimp for PPC?

No matter which page you send someone to through AdWords or Facebook Ads, you can set up a lead form or opt-in bribe that aligns perfectly with your ad and landing page. This will increase your conversion rates and lower your cost per lead.

Simply write a series of emails that will automatically go out to keep educating and building the relationship on autopilot.

Have multiple categories or services? Create separate sequences of emails (auto-responders in MailChimp lingo) that align with the category or service they subscribed on.

Bonus tip: introduce your other services in your email sequence — think of this as a cross-sell.

This means you can take a cold, never-heard-of-you-before audience and turn them into a warm (or hot) ready-to-buy customer while you continue to work on your business.

So why shouldn’t you switch?

  • If you have less than 2,000 subscribers and don’t need the automation features.
  • You focus more on e-commerce and take advantage of MailChimp’s abandoned cart features (this is their specialty if you ask me — but ConverKit does integrate with Shopify and WooCommerce).
  • You need highly designed emails (these tend to not perform as well, but again, if you’re running at e-commerce store it makes sense that you use images more than most).

Need a few more reasons why you should NOT switch? Check out this post.

Your Turn

Have you switched to ConvertKit? Let me know how your experience has been.

Still thinking about switching? I’m happy to answer any questions you might have (their support team is busy enough).

Here’s to turning your email marketing up a few notches!

Post originally appeared on Paid Insights