Thomas Nagel on “Darwinian Imperialism”, Naturalism and Mind (Part Two)

Paul Austin Murphy
6 min readJan 21, 2022

Thomas Nagel fights “Darwinist imperialism” and Naturalism

Thomas Nagel being burned at the stake by satanic “Darwinian” and “materialist” analytic philosophers in red robes.

“The total world-view of modern man [has] let itself be determined by the positive sciences [which has resulted in] an indifferent turning-away from the questions which are decisive for a genuine humanity.”

Edmund Husserl (see source here)

Skip the following square-bracketed introduction if you’ve already read my ‘Thomas Nagel as Philosopher-Priest and New Mysterian (Part One)’.

[This essay was written quite some time ago. The style is somewhat rhetorical, literary and psychologistic. That said, I still agree with much of its philosophical content. However, if I were to write it today, the style would be a little different. Indeed most analytic philosophers would probably regard this essay as one long ad hominem against the American philosopher Thomas Nagel (1937-). Sure; there is an element of the ad hominem in the following. Yet hopefully it will be shown that there’s more to the essay than that.

[In fact I chose to write in a rhetorical style partly in response to the clear and prevalent rhetoric and “psychologising” I found…

--

--