Open letter to Premier Christy Clark: B.C. businesses support a stronger carbon tax

B.C. Climate Leadership Plan with $10 per tonne per year increase will benefit the economy

More than 130 B.C. businesses have signed the following open letter calling on the B.C. government to commit to strengthening the province’s carbon tax as part of the Climate Leadership Plan, due out this spring.

The Board of Change, Clean Energy BC, Climate Smart Businesses Inc., Pembina Institute and Clean Energy Canada initiated the letter, which was released today (March 30).

March 29, 2016

The Honourable Christy Clark, MLA
Premier of the Province of British Columbia
Box 9041
Station PROV GOVT
Victoria, B.C. V8W 9E1

Dear Premier,

As businesses representing the diversity of B.C.’s economy, we write to you in support of the Climate Leadership Team’s recommendation to begin increasing the carbon tax by $10 per tonne per year in July 2018.[1] The province’s carbon tax has been widely praised as an effective climate policy because of its ability to reduce carbon pollution, increase innovation, and support economic growth.

We also support the Team’s recommendations to use incremental carbon tax revenue to reduce other taxes; support vulnerable British Columbians; maintain the competitiveness of our emission-intensive, trade-exposed sectors;[2] and invest in innovation and climate solutions. The combined fiscal package finds a good balance between economic, environmental, and social objectives.

These decisions should be finalized this spring as part of the Climate Leadership Plan. Communicating the decisions early will give businesses and British Columbians time to plan and figure out the solutions that make the most sense for them.

Here are three key reasons we support next steps on the carbon tax:

1. B.C.’s economy will benefit. During the first phase of B.C.’s carbon tax, the province’s economic growth outperformed the rest of the country, and studies that examined B.C.’s carbon tax in detail found no impact on economic growth.[3],[4] According to the Climate Leadership Team’s report, B.C.’s GDP will grow by an average of 2.1% per year under the Team’s recommendations, with growth distributed across the economy. There are also less quantifiable benefits. Having B.C. recognized as part of the solution to climate change helps attract good people and companies to the province — we can’t afford to lose that advantage.

2. B.C.’s clean energy and clean tech businesses will thrive. As of 2014, over 68,000 British Columbians were working in clean economy jobs — up 12.5% from 2010.[5] Those people work in businesses that supply renewable energy, help improve energy efficiency, and develop a host of other clean energy and climate change solutions. These businesses serve domestic and international markets, and they work in partnership with universities, local governments, and First Nations around the province. They are well positioned to help B.C. continue its transition to a clean energy economy, and help meet a rapidly growing global demand for those solutions.

3. B.C.’s businesses will be better partners in reducing carbon pollution. Close to one-third of B.C.’s carbon pollution is under the direct control of the province’s 170,000 small and medium-sized businesses, which employ more than one million people.[6] We are part of the solution when we work in energy efficient buildings, drive cleaner vehicles and reduce waste. Strengthening the carbon tax in conjunction with incentives like a tax credit will encourage businesses to accelerate investment in solutions like training, technology, retrofitting and improved processes.[7]

In 2008, the Climate Action Plan — with the carbon tax as its central pillar — helped move the province’s economy ahead, it helped boost the province’s reputation and it helped the environment. Taking the next steps on the carbon tax as part of the Climate Leadership Plan is an opportunity to build on those initial successes, and it is an opportunity we must seize as a province.

Sincerely,

1660 East Broadway Holdings Ltd.

275 Lansdowne Street Ltd.

3106 Cambie Street Ltd.

977 Fort Street Ltd.

Acme Systemic Results

Acuere Consulting Inc.

Aeolis Wind Power

Altaqua Hydroenergy Corp

Alterra Power Corp.

ARYZTA Canada

ATD Waste Systems Inc.

Avalon Mechanical Consultants Ltd.

Avid Consulting Group Ltd.

B. Small Enterprises Ltd.

BC Bioenergy Network

Blue Fuel Energy

Bluefin Electric Marine Inc.

Board of Change

Bruce Haden Architect Ltd.

Bullfrog Power

Canada Ticket Inc.

Canadian Electric Vehicles Ltd.

Canadian Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Association

Carbon Engineering

Carbon Free Group

Cascadia Instrumentation Inc.

Chinook Power Corp.

Clean and Green Carpets

Clean Energy BC

Climate Smart Businesses Inc.

Communities + Architecture Inc.

Compass Resource Managment

Conversations for Responsible Economic Development

Dageraad Brewing

Dakota Projects Ltd.

Demand Side Energy

DL Safety Consulting Ltd.

Dovetail Consulting Group

Dudoc Vancouver

Duvon Holdings Ltd.

Dysco Services Ltd.

Eagle Wing Tours

Earthvoice Strategies Inc.

EasySun Powergrids Inc.

Ebbwater Consulting

eco-Options Energy Cooperative

Ecofish Research

Ecotrust Canada Capital

Emergent Waste Solutions Inc.

Energy Revolution Services

EnerSys Analytics Inc.

EnviroMez Services

ESSA Technologies Ltd.

Etalim Inc

Ethical Bean Coffee

Fairware

False Creek Collision

Farallon Consultants Limited

Fenix Energy

Festival Cinemas Ltd.

GeaZone

Ghost Films Inc.

Global Unicycle Creative Inc

Green Chamber of Commerce BC

Green Sky Sustainability Consulting Inc.

Growing City

GW Solutions

Harvey McKinnon Associates

HASTe Worker’s Cooperative

Hemlock Printers Ltd.

Hydrogen Technology & Energy Corporation

Inland Comfort Air Conditioning Ltd.

Innergex Renewable Energy Inc.

Inventys Thermal Technologies Inc.

James Glave Communications

Jinzi Investments Ltd.

Julian Griggs & Associates Ltd.

Kambo Green Solutions Inc.

Kisik Aerial Survey

Kootenay Country Store Co-operative

Kumu Agency

Lanefab Design / Build

Light House Sustainable Building Centre

Mazzi Consulting Services

Mills Office Productivity

MK Ince & Associates

Modo Car Coop

Mountain Equipment Co-op (MEC)

Murray McFadden MD Inc

Naikun Wind Energy Group

NEI Investments

Nexterra

Northwest Hydraulic Consultants Ltd.

Novex Delivery Solutions

Perkins+Will

Pinna Sustainability

Praxispoint Consulting Group

Pure Industrial Real Estate Trust

PW Trenchless Construction Inc.

Rangate North Woodworking Solutions Inc.

RDC Fine Homes

Realize Strategies Co-operative

Recollective Consulting

Recycling Alternative

Reeve Consulting

Reliable Controls Corporation

Renewable Power Corp.

Responsible Investment Association

S2G Biochemicals

Salt Spring Consulting Ltd.

Schein Foundation

Sea Breeze Power Corp.

SES Consulting

SFU Community Trust

Sharp Six Services

Shift Delivery

Spa Utopia Health and Wellness centre

SPUD.ca

Starr Schein Enterprises Incorporated

Stone Event Imports, Ltd.

Strandberg Consulting Inc.

Strathcona Business Improvement Association

Sun Bright Solar Inc.

Super Grocer & Pharmacy

Sustainability Ventures

Swift Creek Consulting

Swiss Solar Tech Ltd.

Switch Materials Inc.

The Cleaning Solution

The Kerrisdale Lumber Company

Travesia Partners

Umbrella Property Services

Vancouver Economic Commission

Vancouver Renewable Energy

Vanterre Projects Corp

VeloMetro Mobility Inc.

Walas Concepts

Westpark Electric Ltd.

cc: Minister of Community, Sport and Cultural Development Peter Fassbender
Minister of Energy and Mines Bill Bennett
Minister of Environment Mary Polak
Minister of Finance Mike de Jong
Minister of Jobs, Tourism and Skills Training Shirley Bond
Minister of Natural Gas Development Rich Coleman
Minister of Transportation and Infrastructure Todd Stone
Parliamentary Secretary Jordan Sturdy

Notes

[1] The Climate Leadership Team’s recommendations are available here: http://bit.ly/1OvykvE. The Team recommended that the annual $10 per tonne increases continue for five years, at which point it would be reviewed. The rate schedule was selected because it helped achieve the economic, social and environmental components of the Team’s mandate.

[2] The recommendation to use a portion of carbon tax revenue to maintain the competitiveness of emissions-intensive, trade-exposed sectors was only intended for situations when those sectors were at an economic disadvantage because B.C.’s climate policy was stronger than its competitors. Furthermore, any support for those sectors was supposed to be designed in a way to avoid undermining the incentive to reduce carbon pollution.

[3] Stewart Elgie, “Just the facts: Did the carbon tax shift burden or buoy B.C.’s economy?,” Sustainable Prosperity, July 9, 2014. http://bit.ly/21G6t1R

[4] Brian C. Murray and Nicolas Rivers, B.C.’s Revenue Neutral Carbon Tax: A Review of the Latest “Grand Experiment” in Environmental Policy (Sustainable Prosperity, 2015). http://bit.ly/1dA74Ou

[5] Pacific Coast Collaborative, West Coast Clean Economy: 2010–2014 Jobs Update (2015). http://bit.ly/1PZ6vyS

[6] Climate Smart calculations based on B.C.’s Community Energy and Emissions Inventory (2012), Statistics Canada’s Canadian Business Counts (2015), and ICBC vehicle counts.

[7] Research conducted by the SFU School for Public Policy for Climate Smart, showed that targeted incentives like an investment tax credit could help small and medium businesses cut their carbon pollution. In a November 2, 2015 letter to Minister of Environment Mary Polak, Climate Smart provided analysis of the potential impact of an investment tax credit. “If one third of them apply for the tax credits, preliminary estimates indicate B.C. could reduce carbon pollution by 1.2 million tonnes annually by 2020. This would yield annual operating savings to those businesses of half a billion dollars.”

(Businesses are still welcome to sign on to the letter until April 7, 2016.)