Head of Talent: one of the hardest hires you will make

Image for post
Image for post

Recruiting, retaining and developing talent is one of the biggest challenges for a start-up. In the early days, the CEO often assumes this role, however, we find that most of the companies we work with, not long after Series A, find they’re hiring at such a pace, and growing the team so fast, that they start to need a “Head of Talent”. Yet, despite this being a key role for the business, we’ve found that there’s not a lot of knowledge and guidance out there on figuring out what a head of talent means for your business, when to bring one on board or what a great head of talent looks like…

So recently we hosted a roundtable discussion at BGF Ventures HQ on “What makes a great head of talent?”. We were lucky enough to be joined by 14 heads of talent and people development managers from organisations such as Google, Facebook and Unruly, talent experts, as well as founders and heads of talent from earlier stage businesses in our portfolio (see below for full list of participants).

We want to share the top 4 topics that emerged from the discussion with the wider start-up community:

What exactly does a head of talent do?

The specifics will vary by company but Deana Murfitt shared a useful framework that neatly captures the role of a head of talent in any organisation:

Image for post
Image for post

1. Resourcing: finding talent externally or moving talent internally to meet the needs of the business

2. Relations: ensuring that employees have an understanding of company culture, values and performance expectations

3. Reward: delivering the company’s promise in return for performance; it is also how the company culture and values are delivered e.g. share options as a reward can demonstrate that employees have ownership of company success

4. Development: training and learning at an individual level but also organisational development

As the company grows, there will be new business needs which requires a new resourcing structure and so the cycle continues.

In an ideal world, your start-up would have a great head of talent doing all of the above but in reality, as some of our own founders noted, this may not be feasible or even desired — which brings us to the next topic…

Why would a young start-up need a head of talent?

Given how important talent is to the business, we acknowledged that many founders are reluctant to relinquish control and find it hard to trust someone else to do what they believe is their responsibility.

Our talent experts encourage founders to think about some of the reasons why a head of talent might be appropriate for your business:

· To keep up the pace of growth: because you have become a roadblock, slowing down the pace of hiring and hence business growth as you are heavily involved in every recruitment process;

· To ensure talent issues are handled appropriately: because people matters are taking up a disproportionate amount of your time as you are the only person in the company that employees can speak to about people issues;

· To effectively manage processes: because you don’t have all the knowledge and skills of an experienced people manager who would know the finer details of an EMI option scheme for example;

· To focus your efforts on what you do best: because you enjoy and are good at some talent functions like interviewing candidates but you find everything else a drain on your energy

This is not an exhaustive checklist by any means but if you have experienced any of the above, it is a probably a good time to start thinking about bringing in help. A junior professional can solve your issues in the short-term perhaps, but in the medium-long term, a great head of talent is a must!

What should a CEO delegate to a head of talent?

As to how the transition to having a head of talent, there is no one sweeping right answer but here some things to consider.

Hire well ahead of time

Most CEOs start thinking about establishing this role when one or more of the above issues mentioned above will soon cause something to blow up in the business. One of our talent managers was hired when there were just 30 people in her company. While this seems a little early, it allowed her to develop the talent function ahead of the curve and build relationships with early employees and gain their trust. If you have the means, then this could be a great approach.

Ensure your head of talent evolves with the company

It is important to note the role of the head of talent changes as the start-up develops and it may be that the person behind this role also changes. Start-ups experience inflexion points which mark the beginning of what is hopefully a period of fast growth. When asked if hiring someone like a consultant to just help them through these periods would be a good option, our talent experts vehemently disagreed questioning ‘how they can hire for cultural fit if they don’t know your culture and values’ or ‘how they can create development programmes if they haven’t followed the journey of your existing employees’?

It takes time for someone to ‘own’ the talent function

Most of our group agreed that it was unlikely you would find one individual who will be in an expert at everything, own all the talent functions initially and in fact maybe you don’t want them to. Start off delegating a few talent functions like ‘reward’ or ‘development’ — they might be the ones that you are most comfortable parting with, consume the most time for you and/or feel you are least equipped to manage on your own. Then over time you can transition the talent function entirely including the areas you were most reluctant to outsource. As an example, the ‘relations’ function should only be delegated when you can trust that your head of talent really understands your culture and values.

One of our talent experts observed that sometimes once a head of talent is brought on board within a start-up, everyone else stops doing that role so it is important to highlight that everyone, especially the leadership team, should continue to feel empowered to contribute to recruiting, retaining and developing talent.

What makes a great head of talent?

There was no shortage of useful frameworks in our discussion and Jane Reddin introduced one she developed to help us understand how to think about hiring a great head of talent or any role for that matter. It’s called ‘HACK’.

Hook: this involves articulating in slick macro and micro statements, exactly why a head of talent might want to join your company e.g. you might describe your company mission, describe the ideal candidate, or describe the exact reason why your company is the right fit for them all to ‘hook’ them

Achievement: this involves articulating what good looks like and what exactly is a head of talent is going to do for you this year?

Competency Key: To make things even more interesting, Jane uses a metaphor, a trifle (yes, a trifle), within this framework to articulate who it is you want to hire.

Image for post
Image for post

Here is what the layers of the trifle represent:

Cream — this is all about the culture fit and values; do they have the behaviours we are looking for?

Custard — this is all about the competencies/functional strengths they must have to be a great head of talent

Jelly/sponge — this is all about their track record; what and to what extent have they worked in talent before?

This tool helps to dissect the various things you need to be looking for instead of having just a vague profile in your head. The proportions between each of the layers can vary — e.g. there could be a lot of cream and only a little bit of jelly/sponge but that might end being a great candidate for you.

Having great people skills for this role is a no-brainer but beyond this, our panellists highlighted high EQ, adaptability and resilience as essential intangible qualities a head of talent needs to have.

As one of our own founders noted, a head of talent is one of the hardest hires you will make. The above are some tools you can use to understand when to hire one and what to look out for but one thing we learned that every start-up that has hired one will have a different story to how they got there.


Cate Poulson-Head of Talent Network @ BGF

David Cruickshank-COO @ Gousto

Deana Murfitt-People & Change consultant, formerly Chief People Officer @ Unruly Media

Emma Bolger-Talent @ Network Locum

Emma Rapoport-Formerly People Development Manager & Consultant @ Google

Harry Briggs (Chair)-Partner @ BGF Ventures

James Osmond-COO @ Triptease

Jane Reddin-Talent advisor @ Balderton Capital

Kelsey Traher-COO @ Marvel App

Laura Pettitt-Director @ Insignis Consulting

Michael Walker-‎Head of People & Operations @ Mastered

Michelle Coventry-Head of Talent & People Ops @ Kindred Capital

Suzanne Martin-People Manager@ Firefly Learning

Timo Boldt -CEO & Founder @ Gousto

Yifhat Arnstein-Executive coach @ Facebook and The Coaching Room

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch

Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore

Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store