I’m not 100% sure what you mean by my “credentials”. Do you mean what I write on this site?

To give a few more specifics, I was on the Commons from about 10:30 am to about 12:30 pm, at which point I got tired of the whole thing and left. I saw this up close:

It was exactly as ugly as it looks in the video. I also saw this (and took my own video of it):

The fact that I have to go to “alternative” sites like Breitbart to find any mention of these things that I saw does make me suspicious of the bias of the “mainstream” press.

However, the most damning thing about it was the attitude of the people I talked to. Almost all of them were filled with a vicious self-righteousness and were disinclined to engage in any sort of reasonable discussion, preferring to throw baseless accusations and threats of violence against me. [I also did not seek out Antifa to talk to, in fact I did not talk to Antifa at all since I already know their positions on e.g. political violence. I talked to random people.] And every single one (except the one rally-goer I talked to, of course) defended political violence. This is what I mean when I say the whole thing was a gigantic display of hate, and the behavior of those who are supposedly against hate is deeply troubling.

[Many of the signs at the counter-protest were quite nice (though others were clearly vicious), but talking to the protesters really lowered my opinion of them. The fact that I couldn’t find a single protester willing to agree that the Antifa maybe go a bit too far was quite unnerving.]

I’ve seen the photos of the people with the Kekistan flag, but I didn’t see them personally. Despite the fact that the Kekistan flag is obviously meant to evoke the Nazi flag (specifically this version), I don’t regard it as a sign of neo-Nazism or white supremacy, just of trollery; but I do understand if you think it signifies white supremacy.

The flags I did see from the rally-going side were: several American flags (both current and historical); a Canadian flag; a Palestinian flag; an Israeli flag; an American-ish flag I couldn’t identify (it’s the one in the middle of this photo); and a “Don’t Tread on Me” flag. I also saw one sign that said “Blue Lives Matter”.

To counterbalance the Kekistan flags and “Stop White Genocide” shirts I missed, there is also the awful counter-protest stuff I missed, including “Kill All Nazis” and “Nazi Death is Progress” signs, an “America Was Never Great” hat, and a Soviet flag. There’s also some positive stuff at the rally that I missed, such as this rally-goer’s gay pride flag and signs that said “Black Live Do Matter” (which I think supports the not-Nazis hypothesis).

I mentioned the Communism I saw in the counter-protest because it’s the moral equivalent of Nazism (worse, in fact, in terms of lives claimed in toto) — and yet apparently punching “Nazis” (who are usually not Nazis at all) is moral while punching Communists (who are definitely Communists) is beyond the pale. Here’s a whole delegation from Socialist Alternative, including a guy who apparently isn’t terribly bothered by the fact that his shirt features Lenin (who killed millions and laid the groundwork for further mass murder carried on by his successors). I submit that that guy’s shirt is infinitely worse than e.g. the Kekistan flag.

)

    Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
    Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
    Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade