I give the same argument for segwit as well. It ignores bitcoin’s gold like properties and assumes that scaling bitcoin’s transactions per second will raise its value. We need to consider not messing with bitcoin’s value proposition whatsoever and neither proposal considers this because they both start with the tacit assumption that increasing bitcoin’s tps solves a significant problem.
I believe you will be one of the first mainstream bitcoiners to realize this because you are thinking outside of the community’s box already.
It’s obvious once you drop the tacit assumption.