From Deep Waters: Piracy in East Hampton
In the serene town of East Hampton, nestled along the eastern coast of Long Island, unfolds a tale of daring piracy and elusive treasures that has enchanted generations and left an enduring mark on its picturesque landscape. While East Hampton is now celebrated for its upscale boutiques and serene beaches, centuries ago, its waters teemed with adventurers and tales of plunder, with Captain William Kidd standing as one of the most infamous figures of that era.
Captain Kidd, a legendary icon of the Golden Age of Piracy, etched his name into East Hampton’s annals with stories of buried riches and audacious exploits. Of particular note was his rendezvous with Gardiners Island, a chapter that highlights both his daring adventures and the allure of concealed wealth.
According to lore, Kidd and his trusted quartermaster, Hendrick van der Heul, arrived in East Hampton in 1699 after their exploits in the East Indies. Following the division of their spoils at Little Northwest Creek, the duo went their separate ways, leaving behind a veil of mystery and speculation. Whispers abound of Kidd stashing treasures throughout Long Island, including the fabled Money Ponds near the Montauk Lighthouse, adding to the mystique of the region.
However, it was Kidd’s encounter with Mrs. Gardiner, the esteemed proprietor of Gardiners Island, that solidified his ties to East Hampton. In a bid to clear his tarnished reputation, Kidd made a stop on the island en route to Boston, where he purportedly buried a substantial cache of treasure with Mrs. Gardiner’s consent. This treasure trove, comprising gold, silver, jewels, and other precious artifacts, was intended as pivotal evidence in Kidd’s impending trial.
In a gesture of gratitude, Kidd bestowed upon Mrs. Gardiner a piece of gold cloth and a bag of sugar, coupled with dire warnings should the treasure vanish. Despite his ominous proclamations, Kidd ultimately met his demise at the gallows, leaving behind a legacy veiled in intrigue and enigma. Mrs. Gardiner, entrusted with the task of presenting the treasure as evidence, retained a diamond as a silent testament to her involvement in the saga.
Today, the legend of Captain Kidd’s treasure continues to captivate the imaginations of East Hampton’s denizens and visitors alike. The allure of concealed wealth persists, with intrepid explorers scouring the town in pursuit of clues and artifacts that may unravel the mysteries of Kidd’s adventures. As they wander the quaint thoroughfares of East Hampton, they are reminded of the town’s storied past and the tantalizing prospect of stumbling upon a long-lost treasure, thus adding yet another intriguing chapter to its illustrious history.
