Benetton defends child labour

Secret Camera recordings reveal Benetton managers defending child labour in Bangladesh.


Made In Italy: A Documentary by Liza Boschin, Elena Marzano & Shafiur Rahman

UPDATE OCTOBER 2015: Made in Italy wins first prize Pietri Di Donato awards.

UPDATE NOVEMBER 2014: Made in Italy wins the Aretè prize

Secret camera recordings show that Italian clothes maker Benetton uses suppliers who still employ child labour in Bangladesh. A RAI 3 television investigation has revealed that months after the collapse of garment factories in Rana Plaza where over 1100 people died, serious health and safety measures have still not been addressed including locked factory gates which can be deadly in the event of a fire. The report shows that Benetton, one of Italy’s best known clothing brands, continues to flout good practice in Bangladesh and its managers defending the use of child labour.

Details: Presa Diretta journalists travelled to Bangladesh to investigate how the garment industry works in Bangladesh. Using a secret camera, they filmed Benetton country manager saying that

  1. Child labour would be sanctioned by “missionaries”. Actual quote: “Even the missionaries are glad they are there.”
  2. Child labour is only what happened in Italy “50 years ago”.
  3. Benetton only signed up to improve conditions because of public opinion.
  4. Benetton knew all along that they were producing in Rana Plaza despite the initial denial
“Even the missionaries are glad they are there.”

The film also reveals that top category factories where Benetton produces clothing have extremely unsafe working practices including locked gates — a practice known to be responsible for scores of deaths in the history of Bangladeshi garment factories.

The film shows a Benetton subcontractor confirming that girls as young as 13 work at his factory.

Child labour in Benetton subcontractor factory

The journalists talked to workers who remain without compensation months after the disaster and live very difficult lives — physically, psychologically and financially. The journalists were attacked during the course of making the documentary when they were mistaken for foreign buyers by workers running away from police fire.

Union officials and workers told the journalists how they are subject to harassment by hired thugs and the police and that establishing rights for the ordinary worker is extremely difficult.

Background: On April 24th 2013, the Rana Plaza Building in Savar collapsed causing the deaths of more than 1100 garment factory workers and over 2000 injured. The building hosted garment factories producing for household brands including Primark, Mango, Walmart and Benetton. The tragedy brought to light the continuing unsafe working conditions of millions of Bangladeshi people working in the textile industry.

Quotes:

“Benetton dragged their feet in responding to us. They refused to be interviewed about the findings we made available to them. These include the questions around child labour and locked gates at factories producing for Olimpias, a Benetton group company. They avoided all mention of their country manager defending child labour.” Liza Boschin, Journalist, Presa Diretta, Rai 3.

“It was beyond imagination that the industrialists, in their pursuit of profit, would stir up such a moment, comparable to a war, where people are gunned down.” Kazi Ruhul Amin. General Secretary, Garment Workers Trade Union Centre

“On the 24th, since (Rana Plaza) was so badly cracked, nobody wanted to go inside (…) but supervisors forced us to get to work. Many of us where beaten and brought inside.” Nasrin, former New Wave Style employee, a Benetton subcontractor, and Rana Plaza survivor.

“When we unionists go to discuss with factory owners and government representatives about wages, when we ask why they are not allowed to do trade unions, why female workers are being harassed, why there is no democratic law act for workers , soon enough we end up being falsely prosecuted, harassed or even killed” Mishu Moshrefa, president of Garments Workers Unity Forum


Links/Press Coverage:

Original Broadcast: http://bit.ly/rai3presadiretta

The Guardian reported the story here.

Danwatch reported the story here.

Euronews here.

Radio Television Suisse reported it here.

Huffington Post reported it here.

Clean Clothes Campaign reported it here.

Labour Behind the Label report here.

Minmote covered it here from VG ( Norway).

EticaNews

English Version of the film: please contact one of the people below for access.

Spokespeople:
Liza Boschin, Journalist, liza.boschin@me.com
Tel: +39 380669220 Twitter: @lizaboschin
Shafiur Rahman, Producer, Bangladesh, shafiur@gmail.com Tel: +44 7880501913 Twitter: @shafiur or
http://srdocs.net

All links below refer to the documentary:

Show your support

Clapping shows how much you appreciated Shafiur Rahman’s story.