What is the future of Fashion Resale Businesses: A Deep Dive into ThredUP and The RealReal
Sustainable Fashion’s New Frontier: Evaluating the Growth and Challenges of ThredUP and The RealReal
In the ever-evolving landscape of retail, the resale market has emerged as a significant player, with companies like ThredUP and The RealReal leading the charge. These online platforms have revolutionized the way we buy and sell used clothing, offering a sustainable alternative to fast fashion. But as they navigate the choppy waters of the retail industry, questions about their profitability and long-term viability persist.
What is ThredUP?
ThredUP, founded in 2009 by James Reinhart, has been at the forefront of modernizing the thrift industry, transforming the way we perceive and engage with second-hand clothing.
The genesis of ThredUP was rooted in a simple realization. Reinhart, now the company’s CEO, found himself staring at a closet full of clothes he no longer wore. He recognized the inherent value in these garments and saw an opportunity to redefine the retail landscape. Little did he know, this insight would not only disrupt the apparel industry but also have profound implications for our environment.
ThredUP’s mission is to revolutionize the thrift industry by making it easy for people to buy and sell high-quality second-hand clothes. The company’s innovative platform has democratized access to fashion, enabling consumers to enjoy the thrill of finding unique pieces without the hefty price tag often associated with brand-new items.
But ThredUP’s impact extends beyond the fashion industry. By promoting the reuse of clothing, the company is contributing to a more sustainable future. Every item bought or sold on ThredUP is one less item in a landfill, helping to reduce the environmental impact of the fashion industry, one of the world’s largest polluters.
What is The RealReal?
The RealReal is revolutionizing luxury resale by providing an end-to-end service that unlocks supply from consignors and creates a trusted, curated marketplace for buyers globally. They aggregate and curate unique, pre-owned designer fashion, luxury watches, rare and desirable jewellery, home decor and fine art, making it available to consumers at a fraction of the retail price.
The RealReal is a leader in authenticated luxury consignment. With an expert behind every item, they ensure everything they sell is 100% real. They have a rigorous process overseen by experts, ensuring that every item is authenticated. Their team of brand authenticators, gemologists, horologists, and art curators inspect thousands of items each day, so you can be sure every item is 100% authenticated.
The company has a strong commitment to sustainability, helping to extend the lifecycle of luxury items and reduce the environmental impact of production and waste. By promoting the circular economy, The RealReal is contributing to a more sustainable future for fashion. They provide a seamless shopping experience for customers across different channels.
The Stats
The resale market is a reflection of our changing attitudes towards consumption. As we become more conscious of the environmental impact of our choices, the demand for sustainable alternatives is on the rise.
ThredUP has shown promising growth in recent times.
- The first quarter of 2023 saw the company surpass its own revenue forecasts, posting a total revenue of $75.9 million, marking a 4% increase year-over-year.
- This growth, however, was not without its challenges.
- Despite the overall rise in sales, ThredUP’s order volume dipped by 8%, indicating a potential slowdown in consumer demand.
On the other hand, The RealReal also exceeded expectations.
- It reported a gross merchandise value of $444 million for the quarter ending March 31, a 4% increase year-over-year.
- However, total revenue fell by 3%, reflecting the complexities of the luxury resale market.
What are the Advantages of Fashion Resale Businesses?
The growth of ThredUP and The RealReal is indicative of a larger trend — the rise of conscious consumerism.
As sustainability becomes a priority for consumers, the demand for second-hand clothing is on the rise. By providing a platform for consumers to buy and sell used clothing, these companies are not only promoting sustainability but also democratizing fashion, making it accessible to a wider audience.
Moreover, ThredUP’s decision to list its stock on the Long-Term Stock Exchange (LTSE), a sustainability-focused exchange, is a testament to its commitment to sustainable practices. This move could potentially attract environmentally conscious investors, further bolstering its growth.
What are the Ares of Improvement for Fashion Resale Businesses?
Despite their growth, both ThredUP and The RealReal have seen a significant decline in their stock value since going public, losing more than 80% of their value.
This can be attributed to their inability to operate profitably, a glaring issue that has raised concerns among investors. The managed marketplace model that these companies operate, where they take in products from sellers, sort the inventory, and create the listings to sell to buyers, is capital-intensive. This has been a primary reason for their struggle to achieve profitability.
What is the future of Fashion Resale Businesses?
As ThredUP and The RealReal navigate these challenges, they continue to innovate and adapt.
The RealReal’s strategic shift towards high-value consignment and distancing from lower-priced transactions is a calculated approach to enhance profitability. But will these strategies be enough to ensure their long-term viability?
- Can they strike a balance between growth and profitability?
- Will the rise in conscious consumerism continue to fuel their growth, or will the challenges of the resale market prove too daunting?
- Moreover, how will these companies navigate the complexities of the resale market?
- Will they be able to maintain their momentum in the face of increasing competition?
- And how will they address the concerns of investors regarding their profitability?
The growth of ThredUP and The RealReal is a testament to the potential of the resale market. But as they continue to navigate the challenges of the retail industry, their journey serves as a reminder of the complexities of sustainable retail.
As we grapple with these questions, we are reminded of the complexities of sustainable retail and the challenges that lie ahead.
I would love to hear your take on this. Drop a comment below or Email me!
About the Author: Shreya is a passionate and curious Slow Lifestyle Lover who has over a decade of experience in the Fashion Industry. She has worked in various roles of Design and Business Development with big fashion retailers like H&M and also with smaller brands and export houses. She has an in-depth understanding of the Garment Designing and Production Supply Chain. She uses this knowledge and experience to guide businesses and consumers to start their journey toward Sustainable and Circular Choices. Get in touch with her.
If you learned something new, please ‘clap’ this post anywhere from 1–20 times and follow me so that this article gets seen by others.
Follow me for regular updates from the world of Design, Fashion, and Sustainability.
Buy Me A Coffee if you genuinely love my work! this gives me tons of motivation to keep creating amazing content for you guys.
Cheers to more adventures together!
