Critique: What it means for your designs.
Most designers either love or hate the word critique. It can place a designer in a situation where something they’ve put their heart and soul into gets torn down. Some designers might look at a situation like that and see it as a failure, but designers who want to grow and evolve should see it as an opportunity. What didn’t work about what you presented? Listen to the feedback your peers give you and analyze what’s being said and suggested.
Or maybe your work is well received, but then what? Again, another opportunity. No one is perfect, so find out what you could have improved on whether it be from your peers, professors or bosses. Maybe your project was great, but your presentation could have used some improvement. Everyone has weak spots, and addressing those pain points will only help you to become that much stronger as a designer.
That being said, take it with a grain of salt. Listening to all comments and questions during a critique is important, but you have to know how to filter. This is a skill I’ve found to be incredibly useful during critiques (of which I’ve sat through hundreds during my time as a graphic designer). Listen to all of the feedback your receiving, but don’t take it as the final say. For example, if a peer mentions that they don’t like a color you used, ask why. If it turns out they just aren’t a fan of that color in general, then they’re “talking just to talk”. Unfortunately for that person, them not liking the color has nothing to do with the actual project, but instead is just a personal preference.
Pick and choose your battles. Don’t be afraid to stand up for something you really believe in. With that being said, don’t be a jerk about it either. Listen to what those critiquing your work have to say and if you disagree take the time to explain your point of view to them. Try to get them to see it through your eyes and maybe they’ll have a different opinion in the end. If the person critiquing your work still isn’t a fan, but you feel adamant about keeping what you’ve created, then it’s time for a compromise.
My final thoughts on the subject:
Don’t take it personally. Listen closely. Utilize opportunities. Grow and evolve.
