What if the Asian and American football leagues have Europe’s reputation and prestige?

Image for post
Image for post

This simulation has been on our list for a while! It’s quite unlikely in real life, but we really wanted to find out what would happen if the Asian and American leagues and cups switched their reputation with Europe’s. Perhaps a massive match-fixing scandal could cause something like this?

We simulated this theory for 100 years and this is what happened!

What we asked ourselves

  • What will be the short term effect if the Asian Champions League and Copa Liberatores have the reputation of the current European Champions league? Would players flock overseas for prestige or would their club’s reputation and high salary make them stick around?
  • What if Brasil and China become the biggest leagues in the world? Will this trickle down and increase the quality of youth and let us enter a new era of South-American dominance on the world stage?
  • Will China finally qualify for the world cup?

How did we simulate this

The concept is quite simple. All the European competitions and cup’s reputations have been decreased to 2 stars at most, with the current big leagues like England and Spain having 2 stars, semi-big leagues having 1,5, etc. etc…

The league reputation from Asian and North/South American leagues have been increased to 4,5 stars at most, with China, Brazil, and Mexico having the highest rep.

We also made the Copa Libertadores the biggest cup in the world, with the Asian Champions League, Asian Nations League, and Copa America following closely behind.

Basically, we made it very unattractive to play in Europe, but we didn’t touch the clubs’ reputations as we wanted to see if the club’s rep would increase/decrease naturally.

Download the database from our steam workshop and try it yourself!

Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Leagues at the start: Asia, Europe, North America
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
S-A Leagues, Worldwide cup reputations

The first 5 years

Things didn’t kick off as exciting as we might’ve hoped in the first 5 years, we don’t see any massive superstars moving to the other side of the world.
There is still some surprising transfer activity though. Kai Havertz makes a 74m move to Chinese Huaxia Xingfu in 2022. Usually an unlikely transfer for a 24y old German, but not anymore as China is one of the most exciting leagues in the world now!
Furthermore, we can see that a lot of players are moving back to their home countries, or staying there in the first place since Europe isn’t that interesting of a move anymore, Casemiro is a good example.
Another thing we see is that the MLS clubs are getting a lot more young foreign players as opposed to being a retirement league.

As we hoped, the clubs within the most popular leagues are also turning into the most popular clubs worldwide, with Gremio, Corinthians, and Tigres forming the top 3. FC Bayern, PSG, Benfica, and Napoli are the only European clubs still in the top 10!

Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Chinese League Transfers, Casemiro back to Brazil, World Reputations
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Mexicans returning home, MLS getting talented youngsters

20 Years In

20 years in and the world has completely changed. We don’t see the national teams getting much better yet but on a club level, the tides have completely changed.

The two best players in the world ‘Laurin Spork’ (yeah, really) and ‘Marcelo Pasini’ both play for Corinthians, which would now be the most prestigious club if not for Al-Ittihad from Saudi Arabia (which is now the retirement league, paying a ton of cash for 30-year-old foreigners).
We now see more or less an even distribution of the world’s top players between European and Brazilian clubs.

China is now attracting so much talent from abroad that they eventually become naturalized Chinese which allows Chinese clubs to have more (originally foreign) players in their starting 11!

On a country level, we see that the vast majority of Mexican and Brazilian players now play in their home country, with the exception of clubs like Man United splashing cash every now and then. The rich European clubs remain rich!

Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Mexican players playing in Mexico, Brazilians in Brazil, The two best players in the world at Corinthians!
Image for post
Image for post
The two best players in the world at Corinthians!
Image for post
Image for post
Naturalized Chinese players

50 years in

A Mexican playing for Al-Ahli is now the best player in the world, who would’ve thought. Furthermore, we still see a big influence of European giants like Man City and Barcelona, which is interesting because their competitions are still only on a 2,5-star rep at most.
The major clubs are now a nice mix of Brazilian, Saudi, Korean and Mexican, with Gremio still topping the list (not surprising as they won the Copa Libertadores 8 times in the last 10 years!)

Finally, we also see some influence of the increased reputations in the World cup: Ecuador, Brazil (3x), Mexico, and Argentina have all won the cup since 2018!
Asian countries are also doing much better, with a lot of them in the top 50 of the world.

Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post
Image for post

100 years!

The US and Australia have won the world cup…

Image for post
Image for post

We didn’t believe it either, but the US has actually won the world cup! And Australia too! Other than that we continue to see a South American dominance with Colombia, Chile, and Uruguay in addition to the countries who already won it. Almost every S-A country has now won the World Cup in the last 100 years!

On a club level we see a lot more Asian clubs in the top 20 though, but overall still a good presence of both continents. What we don’t see is any European club in the top 100, it looks they still have not recovered from their poor league reputation. PSG is now the biggest European club with 4 stars (and are still writing fat checks)!

Before we end this write-up we still have some more good news, China has finally made it to the world cup!!! Even to the quarter-finals!

I hope you enjoyed the read, see you next time!

Image for post
Image for post
Reputations in Europe
Image for post
Image for post
The most reputable clubs in the world
Image for post
Image for post
The last cup winners and major nations
Image for post
Image for post
China is finally qualifying for the World Cup!
Image for post
Image for post
PSG still writing checks

Written by

I ran a couple of simulations related to football/soccer and I might publish more!

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store