That is not an ad hominem.
Kendra Anthrope

“That is not an ad hominem. Please go look at what an ad hominem is. I in no way attacked you personally; I claimed that your statement was Russian propagandist.”

Ehm: Claiming that a statement is “propaganda” is an address to the author and an attempt to invoke a feeling of guilt by association. It is basically the definition of what an ad-hominem is; attempting to tarnish the messenger rather that argue the message.

“You claimed that Putin had brought economic success to Russia via deregulation.”

No I didn’t: I never made that claim. I do not think that that particular claim was an ad-hominem. I just think it was a case of the lazy confirmation bias that I am used to hearing. I was very clear that Putin is not responsible for the beginning of the recovery in Russia, but he certainly has encouraged it. But I do not, and I did not credit him for it. I simply suggested that he was right to continue it.

I also know that economies tend to fluctuate, and a two year low is hardly a sign of anything when the economy has been improving for over twenty years despite the sanctions designed to prevent that. You are talking about a country that is just recovering from a century of communism; and also dealing with constant hostility on its borders and constant attempts from the west to undermine its economy.

I also know that both life expectancy rates and birth rates have improved enormously. Another sign of recovery:

“You did the same thing when you claimed that Trump had merely “criticized” the media. You and I both know he has gone far, far beyond simply “criticizing” the media.”

Really? Specifics please: What has he done other than criticise? And not just examples of journalists barred from press conferences because everyone understands that for every journalist in a press conference at that level, there are hundreds that are barred from entry. But what has Trump done in terms of the press that Obama didn’t do?

One clap, two clap, three clap, forty?

By clapping more or less, you can signal to us which stories really stand out.