I totally agree with you and as I said, I just tried to focus my solution on the basis of fitt’s law.
There are many other solutions and experiences that might come into play and are better than the previous one; and that is the reason I ( and we all, in fact) love designing! :D
Thanks for pointing out the most human problem of this subject. I obviously went through this before designing my solution, and found out that there are many factors apart from the distance and area that impact your decision making process. So, I just tried to focus my design decisions only on the basis of fitts’ law.