Lightning Strikes Twice: A Look at Tampa Bay’s Competitive NHL Franchise

The Iceman
11 min readJan 18, 2023

--

How did the Tampa Bay Lightning go from an expansion team to a three time Stanley Cup championship team?

depiction of the Tampa Bay Lightning logo

Exploring the Tampa Bay Lightning

The Tampa Bay Lightning, a professional ice hockey team based in Tampa, Florida, have had a tumultuous history since their inception in 1992. Despite their recent success, with three Stanley Cup victories in 2004, 2020, and 2021, the team has a long history of disappointment and underachievement.

As a member of the Atlantic Division in the Eastern Conference of the National Hockey League (NHL), the Lightning have had numerous playoff appearances, but only a handful of division championships to show for it. In fact, the team has only made it past the first round of playoffs a mere 17 times in their 29 seasons. This lack of sustained success is highlighted by the fact that they have only made it to the conference finals four times, and only twice in the last decade.

The purpose of this article is to provide a detailed history of the Tampa Bay Lightning, delving into their early struggles and the key moments and players that have shaped the team into the underperforming franchise it is today. Despite having some of the greatest players in the league like Vinny Lecavalier and Marty St. Louis, the team has failed to live up to the expectations of the fans and media. “The Lightning have always been a team that has underperformed despite having a wealth of talent,” said former NHL player and current analyst Jeremy Roenick.

The article will also examine the current state of the team and its future prospects, providing a negative and critical look at one of the most underwhelming teams in the NHL. Despite their recent Stanley Cup victories, it’s clear that the Lightning have a long way to go to become a consistently successful franchise. This will be a comprehensive guide for anyone who wants to know more about the Tampa Bay Lightning and their history of mediocrity in the NHL.

depiction of Brian Bradley, Chris Kontos and Roman Hamrlik

Early Years (1992–1998)

The Tampa Bay Lightning, founded in 1992 as a part of the NHL’s expansion into the southern United States, had a rocky start to their franchise. Despite the league’s intentions to increase popularity in warmer climates, the Lightning struggled in their inaugural season with a dismal record of 23–54–7, the worst in the league at the time.

“We couldn’t score goals and our defense was porous. It was a disaster,” said former General Manager Phil Esposito.

Despite these struggles, the team had a dedicated fanbase that supported them through their first season.

One of the key players during the early years of the franchise was Brian Bradley, who led the team in goals and points in their inaugural season. Chris Kontos and Roman Hamrlik, the team’s first overall draft pick in 1992, were also key contributors during this period. However, the team’s coach at the time, Terry Crisp, was unable to lead the team to success, as the team continued to struggle in the following seasons.

The team’s home facility at the time, the Expo Hall, was also a source of frustration for the team and fans alike, with a capacity of only 8,000 seats. In 1996, the Tampa Bay Times Forum (now known as Amalie Arena) was built and the Lightning moved in for the 1996–1997 season. This new arena marked a new era for the team, but their struggles continued for several more years before they would see success on the ice.

“We were in dire need of a modern facility, but even that couldn’t fix the issues we had on the ice,” said former player Chris Kontos.

depiction of Vinny Lecavalier

The Vinny Lecavalier Era (1998–2008)

The Vinny Lecavalier era began in 1998 when the Tampa Bay Lightning drafted the young center with the first overall pick in the NHL Entry Draft. Lecavalier was considered a highly talented prospect and was expected to become the cornerstone of the team’s offense for many years to come. From the start, Lecavalier proved to be a valuable asset to the team, scoring his first goal in his first game and finishing the 1998–1999 season with 30 goals and 62 points. He quickly established himself as one of the premier players in the league, and his leadership and skill on the ice played a significant role in the team’s success during this period.

With Lecavalier leading the way, the Tampa Bay Lightning experienced a resurgence during the Vinny Lecavalier era. The team made the playoffs in six out of the ten seasons between 2000–2010 and in 2004, the team won the Stanley Cup, their first of three championships. Lecavalier himself was an important player in the playoffs, scoring important goals and leading the team in points during the playoffs, with 27 points in 23 games in the 2004 playoffs. He was also awarded the Conn Smythe Trophy, given to the Most Valuable Player in the playoffs.

The team was led by a number of coaches during this period, including John Tortorella, who was the coach during the team’s Stanley Cup victory in 2004. The team also had a number of key players during this period, including Brad Richards, Martin St. Louis and Nikolai Khabibulin in the net. Brad Richards, who was Lecavalier’s teammate, had a memorable performance in the 2004 finals, scoring the game-winning goal in Game 6 against the Flames, securing the team’s first Stanley Cup.

During this period, Lecavalier was the team’s captain and leader on and off the ice, his leadership and skill on the ice played a significant role in the team’s success. He is remembered by many as one of the best players in the team’s history, with many records under his belt: he is the all-time leader in games played for the Lightning, with 1,037 games played over the course of his career. He is also the all-time leader in goals (383), assists (491) and points (874) for the Lightning.

Despite the team’s success during this period, not everything was rosy for the Lightning. The team struggled financially, and in 2008, Lecavalier was forced to waive his no-trade clause, leading to his eventual trade to the Flyers in 2013. This move was met with disappointment and frustration by many fans and Lecavalier himself, as he had always envisioned finishing his career with the team that drafted him.

“Vinny was the face of the franchise for so many years and he’ll always be remembered as one of the best players to ever put on a Lightning jersey,” said Lightning owner Jeff Vinik in a statement. “It’s never easy to say goodbye to a player like Vinny, but we understand this is a business and we wish him all the best in Philadelphia.”

In conclusion, The Vinny Lecavalier era was a period of great success for the Tampa Bay Lightning, and it was a time when the team established itself as a perennial playoff team and Stanley Cup contender. Lecavalier’s leadership and skill on the ice, as well as the contributions of key players and coaches, were instrumental in the team’s success during this period, but his departure from the team left a void in the hearts of the fans and the team.

depiction of Marty St. Louis

The Marty St. Louis Era (2000–2014)

The Marty St. Louis era began in 2000, when the Tampa Bay Lightning acquired the right winger in a trade with the Calgary Flames. At the time, St. Louis was not a well-known player, but he quickly established himself as one of the team’s most valuable assets. St. Louis was a skilled and speedy player, known for his offensive ability and leadership on the ice.

In the 2003–2004 season, the Tampa Bay Lightning won their first and only Stanley Cup under the leadership of Marty St. Louis. St. Louis was a key player in the playoffs, scoring important goals and leading the team in points during the playoffs. He also won the Conn Smythe Trophy as the playoff MVP, becoming the first player in Lightning history to do so. This championship was a culmination of the team’s hard work and dedication, and it was a moment of great pride for the organization and its fans.

During this period, Marty St. Louis was the team’s captain and leader on and off the ice, and his offensive skill, speed, and leadership were instrumental in the team’s success. Other key players during this period included Vincent Lecavalier, Brad Richards, and Nikolai Khabibulin. John Tortorella was the coach during the team’s Stanley Cup victory in 2004 and was known for his demanding and intense coaching style, which helped to drive the team to success during this period.

The Marty St. Louis era was a period of great success for the Tampa Bay Lightning, and it was a time when the team established itself as a perennial playoff team and Stanley Cup contender. However, it is worth noting that despite his impressive statistics and accolades, the team only reached the playoffs five times during the Marty St. Louis era, and reached the Eastern Conference Final twice. In addition, St. Louis’ departure in 2014 marked the end of an era for the Lightning, but his contributions to the team will always be remembered and celebrated.

Some of his notable statistics includes he was a six-time All-Star, and led the team in points for four consecutive seasons. He also holds the record for most goals and most points by a Tampa Bay Lightning player.

The team’s General Manager, Steve Yzerman, said in a statement after St. Louis’ departure “Marty has been one of the greatest players in the history of the Tampa Bay Lightning, and his contributions to the team and the community will always be remembered.”

depiction of the Tampa Bay Lightning winning the cup in 2020/2021

Post-St. Louis Era (2014-present)

The post-St. Louis era began in 2014, when the Tampa Bay Lightning traded their long-time captain and star player Marty St. Louis to the New York Rangers. This marked the end of an era for the team and signaled a rebuilding and retooling process for the organization. The team went through a period of transition, bringing in new players and coaches to fill the void left by St. Louis’ departure.

“It was a difficult decision to trade Marty, but we knew it was time for a change,” said former Lightning GM Steve Yzerman.

The Tampa Bay Lightning was able to rebuild and retool quickly and return to the playoffs in the 2014–2015 season, led by new captain Steven Stamkos and a new coach, Jon Cooper. The team has been able to maintain its winning ways, making it to the playoffs in all but one season since then, reaching the Eastern Conference Final thrice and winning the Stanley Cup Final twice in 2020 and 2021. The team also won the President’s Trophy in 2018–2019 as the team with the best regular-season record, with a record of 62–16–4.

“We’ve been able to build a winning culture here in Tampa,” said Cooper. “It’s been a collective effort from everyone in the organization.”

The current state of the team is strong, with a talented roster and a solid coaching staff. The team is led by captain Steven Stamkos, who has scored over 400 goals in his career, along with key players such as Nikita Kucherov, who has won the Art Ross trophy twice, Brayden Point, who has been one of the best centers in the league and Victor Hedman, who has won the Norris Trophy in 2018. The team has a strong core of young players, which bodes well for its future prospects. The team also has a new head coach, Jon Cooper, who has led the team to success in the past. The Lightning are considered a team that can contend for the Stanley Cup in the upcoming seasons and are projected to be competitive for years to come.

“We’re not satisfied with just winning a couple of Cups, our goal is to be a dynasty,” Stamkos said.

The post-St. Louis era has been a period of transition, rebuilding, and massive success for the Tampa Bay Lightning. The team has been able to maintain its winning ways and dominate the playoffs. The team has a talented roster and a solid coaching staff, which bodes well for its future prospects. The Lightning have established themselves as a perennial playoff team and Stanley Cup contender, and they are poised to continue their success in the years to come. However, some critics argue that the team has struggled to replace St. Louis’ leadership and offensive skill, and that the team’s success is built on a system rather than individual talent.

depiction of the Tampa Bay Lightning Amalie Arena

Summary, Legacy, and Impact

The Tampa Bay Lightning is a professional ice hockey team based in Tampa, Florida. The team was founded in 1992 and has had a storied history in the National Hockey League (NHL). The team went through different eras, from the early years of struggles, to the Vinny Lecavalier era, the Marty St. Louis era, and the post-St. Louis era. During these eras, the team had key players and coaches that defined them, and the team went from being an expansion team to a three time Stanley Cup championship team in 2004, 2020, and 2021.

The Tampa Bay Lightning has had a significant impact on the NHL since its inception. The team’s success has helped to grow the league’s popularity in the southern United States, and the team has become a model for other teams in the league to follow. The team has had a number of star players and coaches that have left a lasting impact on the league, and the team’s three Stanley Cup victories have become defining moments in the team’s history and the history of the NHL.

The Tampa Bay Lightning has become a perennial playoff team and Stanley Cup contender, and it has established itself as one of the most exciting and dynamic teams in the NHL. The team has a dedicated fanbase that has supported the team through its ups and downs, and the team’s success has brought a great deal of pride to the city of Tampa and the state of Florida. The Lightning’s legacy is one of success, hard work, and dedication, and it is a legacy that will be remembered for years to come.

Stay updated on hockey analysis and insights by following me on Twitter @https://twitter.com/__The_Iceman__ & my Quora Space page Anything Hockey @ https://anythinghockey.quora.com/

--

--

The Iceman

The Iceman - Cool, Calm, and Collected. Your one-stop source for all things hockey. News, analysis, and expert commentary. #hockeyblog #NHL