Member-only story

CULTURE

Why The Free Speech Movement in America Has a Race Problem

When selectively applied, this principle loses its vibrancy.

Dr. Allison Wiltz
AfroSapiophile
Published in
7 min readJan 14, 2025

--

Woman wearing business casual outfit | Photo by Bave Pictures via Pexels

When only some groups have free speech, the principle is gravely undermined. Like paint bottles with too much-added water, the vibrancy is lost. A society that only strives to elevate the voices of the privileged and powerful while silencing the most marginalized has only created the façade of liberty. And yet, throughout America’s history, someone’s race has often determined whether their voice would be amplified or silenced. While free speech is typically described as a right all citizens enjoy, the modern free speech movement is tinged with racism. To understand why, we must start at the beginning.

Students learn in history class that Congress ratified the First Amendment in 1791. And yet, schools do not usually provide the racialized context — that during this period, most Black people in the country were enslaved by White people. Thus, they were deprived of a platform to speak freely about their conditions. “Free speech for me but not for thee” seemed to encompass the sentiment of slave-owning legislators. They didn’t have to explicitly write in the Constitution that these rights were only reserved for White people because their actions spoke louder than words. In 1836, the…

--

--

AfroSapiophile
AfroSapiophile

Published in AfroSapiophile

AfroSapiophile is a hub for critical thinking and analysis pertaining to civil rights, human rights, systemic racism and sexism across politics, entertainment, and history.

Dr. Allison Wiltz
Dr. Allison Wiltz

Written by Dr. Allison Wiltz

Black womanist scholar with a PhD from New Orleans, LA with bylines in Oprah Daily, Momentum, ZORA, Cultured. #WEOC Founder

Responses (19)