Inside the Deer Box: The Abduction of Paul Martin Andrews

Rorie Jane McCormack
After the Fact
Published in
11 min readFeb 20, 2024

--

Featured episode image from Propensity: A True Crime Anthology Podcast from Paul Martin Andrews episode. Digital collage featuring images of Martin as a child and as an adult.
Image: Rorie Jane McCormack, Propensity: A True Crime Anthology Podcas

On a freezing morning in 1973, a teenage boy was abducted by a serial sex offender and kept chained in a subterranean box buried in the woods. Police and his family searched frantically for him, but it was as if he had vanished into thin air. There were no clues, no witnesses and no trace of the boy. What investigators didn’t know was that the boy was in fact alive. And he was being forced to endure the unthinkable to survive his violent captor. Years later, that boy, now a man, would become a powerful victim’s advocate and would lead a campaign to change legislation to better protect children from predators.

Listen to the podcast episode on this case here:

The Day of the Abduction

Thursday the 11th of January 1973 was extremely cold. A heavy belt of snow extended from North Carolina to Virginia. The city of Norfolk, Virginia saw 9 inches or 23 centimetres of snow, the heaviest single snowfall residents had seen since 1963. Across the Elizabeth River from Norfolk, in the independent city of Portsmouth, school children…

--

--

Rorie Jane McCormack
After the Fact

Lover of words. Creator of things. Curator of dark curiosities. Host of Propensity: A True Crime Anthology Podcast. Writer of Books (Coming 2024).