Revolutionary Girl Utena Collector’s Edition III Blu Ray Review (Part 1)

DoctorKev
DoctorKev
Feb 19 · 9 min read
Image for post
Image for post

Remember last time when I expressed my concern that Revolutionary Girl Utena might disappear up its own rear end in the next arc? Thankfully that hasn’t quite happened, but boy does this show like to make its viewers work that much harder to parse what is actually going on, over and above the overwrought emotional teenage drama and stylised visuals.

This final blu-ray volume delves into some deep, dark and distressing territory, so if discussion about sexual/emotional abuse, incest and rape is likely to upset you, perhaps this isn’t the article for you.

Image for post
Image for post
Utena and Anthy return to fight again, but their apparently united front overlies much disturbing interpersonal trauma

At a grand 460 minutes, this volume is significantly meatier than the previous two — that’s because while they each comprised 12 episodes, this contains the final 15 episodes plus the subsequent theatrical movie. Due to the extreme density of subject matter, I’ll discuss the first of this set’s two main arcs here, and leave the second arc and the movie for their own articles (forthcoming as soon as I can reduce my brain’s setting from “fried” to “I can maybe write words coherently now.”)

The Akio Ohtori Saga (Contains detailed spoilers for episodes 25–33)

Image for post
Image for post
The man the arc is named for — now everyone boo and hiss

Technically this arc started with episode 24 in the last set, but that was a relatively inconsequential clip show. The story starts proper in episode 25 with the return of previously disgraced Saionji, who is manipulated by creepy shirtless T-posing shonen-ai duo Touga and Akio into dueling against Utena yet again. This marks the first appearance of Akio’s bright red hot rod “sex car”, a not-so-subtle allusion to the way Akio controls his targets using the superficial trappings of adulthood while arresting their emotional development and twisting their desires to fit his own. The car is very prominent in this arc, popping up in every episode, crashing through walls, poking up vertically (phallically?) through the floor during the duels… Basically if a character takes a ride in Akio’s car, they have somehow been violated… or at least used by him. Although he was creepy before, Akio certainly crosses the line here into out-and-out antagonism.

Image for post
Image for post
“Boys night” in Akio’s Sex Car. He likes to change things up every now and then. He’s an equal-opportunities kind of guy, a kind of pansex-abuser.

It’s clear that Akio wants to possess the power of Dios for himself, and the presence of Utena as some kind of blemish-less “Prince” is an obstacle to his plans. In the previous arc, he manipulated Nemuro and his Black Rose duelists to attack Utena via targeting his sister (and Utena’s “Rose Bride”) Anthy. Now he (and sometimes Touga) whisper in the ears of various characters to make them choose their own replacement Rose Brides to challenge Utena and Anthy as mirrored duos. Even mild-mannered Miki is drawn into Akio’s web, and his sister Kozue becomes his “Bride”… because of course she does. There’s not a single untwisted sibling relationship in this show.

Image for post
Image for post
Kozue takes fashion tips from Anthy

Horrible character Shiori makes a reappearance (the purple-haired girl that ginger goddess Juri inexplicably loves… I mean she’s trash…) only to be manipulated by Juri’s former mentor Ruka and used as his “Bride” then discarded when he loses the duel. Ruka is another hateful and manipulative male who forces himself on Juri with an unwanted kiss. He knows full well she likes girls (particularly Shiori) but does it anyway. Thankfully she draws blood from biting his lip, but seriously, dude… Consent is a thing? Anyway somehow Ruka becomes Juri’s “Bride” in the next duel. I guess the “Bride” title is non-gender specific, much like Utena’s “Prince” identity.

Image for post
Image for post
Nanami and her egg in one of the most absurd yet strangely heartbreaking episodes of anime I’ve ever watched

Even mostly-absurd-comedy character Nanami is manipulated into dueling, with her brother as support. I say support, but Touga acts like such an incredible asshole to his sister. Nanami idolises him, and gains social status due to him — once he rejects her, she loses her confidence, her friends, her place in society, exposing how broken and insecure she really is. Nanami doesn’t truly lust after her brother — but he mercilessly teases and provokes her, stepping over lines she knows should never be crossed, because she witnesses something terrible involving the third, most twisted brother-sister relationship in the entire show and realises she could never act the same way with Touga.

Image for post
Image for post
Um… spying on your creepy brother in the shower like this isn’t exactly normal behaviour. I love how his silhouette reflects his horrible, narcissistic personality
Image for post
Image for post
Faced with relentless mean-spirited manipulation from both her brother Touga and from Akio, Nanami takes out her anger and frustration on Utena

Yes, via Nanami we finally get visual confirmation of what we had suspected… Akio doesn’t just emotionally control his sister, he regularly fucks her too. On his sofa. In the observatory/living room next door to the bedroom he insisted Anthy and Utena now share. As a presumably long-term sufferer of this abuse, Anthy seems powerless to resist — yet her relationship with Utena seems to bring her happiness. Akio wants to subvert and break that — he can’t stand his sister — his possession — giving herself emotionally to anyone else. Anthy also gives Utena strength, and after she loses the Sword of Dios, Anthy is able to pull a sword of Utena’s own strength directly from Utena’s heart. The other duelists in this arc also have their swords drawn by their “Brides”, in a twisted parody of the mutual trust and friendship shared by Utena and Anthy. No wonder they all lose, and no wonder Akio wants to disrupt their relationship.

Image for post
Image for post
Anthy looks helpless after being used yet again as a sex toy by her brother
Image for post
Image for post
Utena and Anthy sleep facing one another in conjoined beds, holding hands. I’m not entirely sure what Akio was up to when making the sleeping arrangements. It’s very… weird.

Moving Utena (and Anthy) into his residence was only the first part of Akio’s plan. He begins to relentlessly pursue her — little touches, caresses, smiles. He gently nurses her injured ankle while a sinister Anthy watches from the background, her eyes hidden by her glasses’ reflection. He kisses her, and Utena is conflicted — this man is engaged, not to mention the fact he’s an adult — not just any adult, but one in authority over her and her entire school. But Utena is a teenage girl, innocent and emotionally immature. She doesn’t know how to handle this attention from a man she clearly idolises. She doesn’t notice how creepy his relationship with his sister is, nor does she realise how complicit the abused Anthy is in helping Akio to also abuse Utena.

Image for post
Image for post
That’s an unsettling vibe you’re cultivating there, Anthy dear.

All this culminates in the extremely upsetting episode 33. Initially it appears to be nothing but another clip show — we’re shown recaps of this arc’s fights interspersed with Akio in his Sex Car speaking to the Shadow Girls (who have returned in their UFO and now apparently run a radio show) and a first-person perspective of Utena in a hotel room, acting quite unlike her usual self. There’s a building sense of wrongness, of dread here. Why is Utena so fixated on weird little details about food preparation? Why does she seem so nervous and ill-at-ease? Where is the usually confident, breezy girl we all love? Why did Anthy send her to deliver a bouquet of flowers to Akio? We understand only too late when we see Utena, obviously naked, in bed, her hand grasped by Akio’s. Afterwards we see her in his car — remember what I said it symbolised earlier? Utena looks simultaneously older, but also sadder.

Image for post
Image for post
Utena’s first kiss with Akio, which he clearly uses to kindle self-doubt and guilt, as well as to seduce her.

It took me a couple of watches of this episode to truly understand what had just happened. My daughter was much quicker than me at picking up the subtext and expressed her vociferous disgust at Akio’s behaviour. Sometimes with these character designs it’s a little difficult to remember that these are middle-school children. Not even in high school. Utena is 14 years old. No matter if Utena apparently consented (which I would argue from the context she did not offer explicit consent and when she tried to talk to Akio he ignored her and kept pressing onwards) the fact that he is an adult makes this statutory rape.

Image for post
Image for post
No matter how mature she looks or acts, Utena is a 14-year-old girl, and to see her pressured into being in this situation is deeply distressing

Akio is not just an adulterer (he’s already pretty much discarded his fiancé by now, plus it’s clear he also fucked her mother), he’s not just a sister-fucker, he’s a rapist. And it’s not only limited to girls either — it’s clear from several scenes that he has been sexually intimate with Touga too — they’re both shirtless on a bed in previous episodes. Touga was sexually abused by his foster father (after basically being sold into sexual slavery by his biological parents) so Akio uses this broken boy to manipulate others. Akio is basically Satan, and he has used his magnetic allure to try and tarnish Utena’s valorous prince identity.

Image for post
Image for post
Afterwards during the drive home, Utena can’t even look Akio in the eye. She appears vulnerable, somehow older and more stereotypically female.

It’s been a while since a piece of fiction made me feel so physically sick because of a character, and Utena managed it with merely subtext and hints, blink-and-you’ll-miss-them cuts and the heartbreaking facial expression of a young girl who knows what she is doing is wrong, what is being done to her is wrong, but feels powerless to escape the path she finds herself on. Akio weaponises her guilt at sleeping with an engaged man to make her feel responsible for her own rape. What a bastard.

Image for post
Image for post
Touga T-poses for dominance… but really he’s just a hurt and abused little boy, taken advantage of by Akio

I’ve commented before that often Utena seems more like a supporting character in her own show — which is fine when the other characters are as colourful and complex as they are in this show. What makes Revolutionary Girl Utena so enduring though, is how it subverts previously concrete gendered expectations of female characters. Akio is desperate to squash Utena down, to make her a compliant little feminine girl, to rob her of her princely agency. In the next arc, finally, we’ll see our main girl seize her own destiny separate from any adults’ and from any man’s machinations. As soon as I’ve gathered my thoughts on it, I’ll try to do it justice in my next article.

Image for post
Image for post
The contents of the third set, taken from Anime Limited’s website

Revolutionary Girl Utena Part 3: The Apocalypse Saga Collector’s Edition Blu-ray
Series Director
: Kunihiko Ikuhara
Production Studio: JC Staff
Original Japanese TV broadcast: Sept. 17th 1997 — Dec. 24th 1997
UK Blu-ray release: Sept. 14th 2020
Runtime: 460 minutes (episodes 25–39, movie)
Video: 1080p pillarboxed 4:3 ratio
Audio: Japanese with English subtitles, English dub
Distributor: Anime Limited

You’re reading AniTAY, a non-professional blog whose writers love everything anime related. To join in on the fun, check out our website, visit our official subreddit, follow us on Twitter, or give us a like on our Facebook page.

AniTAY-Official

Everything Anime and Beyond

DoctorKev

Written by

DoctorKev

Physician. Obsessed with anime, manga, comic-books. Husband and father. Christian. Fascinated by tensions between modern culture and traditional faith. Bit odd.

AniTAY-Official

A Community Blog dedicated to East Asian Culture

DoctorKev

Written by

DoctorKev

Physician. Obsessed with anime, manga, comic-books. Husband and father. Christian. Fascinated by tensions between modern culture and traditional faith. Bit odd.

AniTAY-Official

A Community Blog dedicated to East Asian Culture

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store