Misleading: Video does not show fire in Vatican City
【點擊查看本文中文版】By Catherine Chan 陳雅琳, Isaac Norman and Abe Wong 黃曉瑜
On July 11, a tweet in Chinese claimed the Vatican City, an independent city-state and the headquarters of the Roman Catholic Church, was “engulfed with fire” but “the media did not report it.”
The post included a video showing vehicles moving on a street while a plume of dark gray smoke is visible in the sky. This video was also shared by other Twitter users in English ( here and here) with similar claims.
Altogether, these tweets have been retweeted over 3,400 times and received nearly 7,000 likes at the time of writing. The clip itself has been viewed more than 450,000 times.
However, this video does not show the Vatican. The fire took place more than 10 kilometers away in an area called Centocelle in eastern Rome.
Through an image search, Annie Lab traced the video to a Facebook page named Inews24.it, a news and media company based in Italy, according to the description. This Facebook version of the video says it was taken by Inews24’s reporter.
Annie Lab reached out to the news outlet on July 18 and they said it was their original footage and it was shot on July 9 in Centocelle, not in Vatican City.
We also found a news video by Reuters about a fire that occurred in Centocelle Archeological Park, which appears to show the same incident.
We have geolocated the street in the Twitter video and can confirm that this was taken in Via Papiria, Centocelle.
As opposed to the claim in the Chinese tweet, the Centocelle fire has been widely reported by the media ( here, here and here).
According to the Brussel Times, the authorities in the city suspected arson.
Below is a map of fires that broke out in Rome so far this year made by Vigili del Fuoco, Italy’s fire and rescue service agency. No fire has been recorded to have occurred in the Vatican.
This claim has also been fact-checked by Belgian magazine Knack.
Disclaimer: Although faculty members at the Journalism & Media Studies Centre at the University of Hong Kong have done everything possible to verify the accuracy of the story, we cannot guarantee there are no mistakes. If you notice an error or have any questions, please email us.
Originally published at https://annielab.org on July 21, 2022.
