The Weekly Arc: August 18, 2017
Welcome to Arc’s newsletter, sent out once per week, highlighting the best and most interesting stories from around the web. The Weekly Arc is curated by Berny Belvedere. Past editions can be accessed here.
Chaos and violence turned to tragedy Saturday as hundreds of white nationalists, neo-Nazis and Ku Klux Klan members — planning to stage what they described as their largest rally in decades to “take America back” — clashed with counterprotesters in the streets and a car plowed into crowds, leaving one person dead and 19 others injured. …
The driver of the Challenger, James Alex Fields Jr., 20, of Ohio, was arrested and charged. …
Earlier, police evacuated a downtown park as rallygoers and counterprotesters traded blows and hurled bottles and chemical irritants at one another, putting an end to the noon rally before it officially began.
Despite the decision to quash the rally, clashes continued on side streets and throughout downtown, including the pedestrian mall at Water and Fourth streets where the Challenger slammed into counterprotesters and two other cars in the early afternoon, sending bystanders running and screaming. …
In brief remarks at a late-afternoon news conference in New Jersey to discuss veterans’ health care, Trump said he was following the events in Charlottesville closely. “The hate and the division must stop and must stop right now,” Trump said, without specifically mentioning white nationalists or their views. “We condemn in the strongest possible terms this egregious display of hatred, bigotry and violence on many sides. On many sides.” — The Washington Post
Once Trump made these comments, the Charlottesville saga took a turn in a new direction. Had Trump denounced the neo-Nazis and KKKers on Saturday, rather than on Monday, it would have left the white supremacists ideologically ostracized. Attribution of blame would have been laid at the feet of a fringe group not in sync with the priorities of the White House. Not everyone would buy this disassociation — including those with an a priori commitment to eliminating Trump — but enough would. And this would have enabled Trump to offer comfort to the targets of white supremacist hate.
Of course, I’m couching this in terms of political fallout. But that’s simply due to how I’ve framed it. I’m doing that because we analyze politics here on Arc. Yet the bigger problem isn’t the opportunity lost, but the moral failure of holding back from unequivocally denouncing the white supremacists.
On this point, see this Twitter thread by Ross Douthat.
For a more comprehensive take, read Nicholas Grossman’s piece published here on Arc:
Charlottesville Cracked the Trump Coalition
White supremacists and the future of American politics
Cathy Young, also here on Arc, explains how it’s possible — and why it’s morally desirable — to strongly denounce the white supremacists who marched in Charlottesville while also being clear-headed about the danger antifa poses.
How To Talk (And Not To Talk) About Violence On “Both Sides”
Neither equivalence nor exculpation will do
Since the white nationalist rally was originally planned as a protest against the city’s decision to remove a statue of Robert E. Lee, the issue over Confederate monuments was thrust again into the spotlight.
On Arc, we published three pieces in favor of bringing down Confederate monuments and two pieces against doing so.
A related issue involved asking where the line should be drawn. Should monuments to Washington and Jefferson, two slave-owners, also come down?
We explored all the facets of the discussion in these posts.
Actually, those posts didn’t cover everything. There was still the question of what to do with these monuments:
Forget Confederate Statues. These Other Monuments Need To Come Down. Now.
Here are 5 statues that aren’t so much morally problematic as they are artistically problematic
Spain was hit by its worst terrorist attack in more than a decade on Thursday, when a van driver plowed into dozens of people enjoying a sunny afternoon on one of Barcelona’s most famous thoroughfares, killing at least 13 people and leaving 80 bloodied on the pavement.
Hours later, the Catalan police said they foiled a second vehicular attack, in the seaside town of Cambrils, 70 miles to the south, fatally shooting four people. A fifth died later of wounds, the police said. The suspects appeared to be wearing explosive belts, though these devices were later found to be fake, police said. Six civilians and one police officer were injured during the episode, the Catalan emergency services said.
The Barcelona attack was at least the sixth time in the past few years that assailants using vehicles as deadly weapons have struck a European city. …
The Islamic State claimed responsibility for the Barcelona assault, which shattered a peaceful afternoon in one of Europe’s most picturesque cities. President Trump and other Western leaders quickly condemned the attack and pledged cooperation. …
Witnesses described people screaming and running for their lives as the van driver wove back and forth just after 5:30 p.m., apparently trying to hit as many people as he could. Police officers swept through the area near Las Ramblas, a wide boulevard with a large pedestrian section, moving people out of the area.
Videos taken by witnesses and posted online showed men, women and children motionless on the ground amid broken umbrellas and chairs, in the shade of trees, many bleeding profusely. Paramedics and friends knelt to comfort them as police sirens wailed. — The New York Times
Other Attacks: Nigeria and Finland
At least 30 people were killed and more than 80 others injured in a triple suicide attack Tuesday in the town of Mandarari, in Nigeria’s Borno State, according to civilian vigilantes fighting Boko Haram Islamists in the area.
Three female suicide bombers detonated their explosive belts in a local market and outside a nearby camp for people displaced by Boko Haram violence. — CNN
Two people were killed and at least six injured — including a mom pushing a stroller — in a stabbing spree in the Finnish city of Turku, where cops shot and wounded the suspected assailant. — New York Post
We know for certain the attacks in Barcelona and Nigeria were carried out by Islamic extremists. While there are fewer details currently available regarding the attack in Finland, the police have confirmed they are treating this as a terror attack. Is there any doubt they’ll point to the same source?
The leaders of General Electric Co., 3M Co., Campbell Soup Co. and United Technologies Corp. on Wednesday became the latest corporate chiefs to leave a White House council on manufacturing after President Donald Trump’s responses to the recent violence in Charlottesville, Va. …
Jeff Immelt, chairman of General Electric Co., said he had resigned Wednesday morning, citing President Trump’s remarks Tuesday, in which he reiterated that both sides were to blame for the weekend violence between white supremacists and counterprotesters. “The President’s statements yesterday were deeply troubling,” Mr. Immelt said in a statement. “The Committee I joined had the intention to foster policies that promote American manufacturing and growth. However, given the ongoing tone of the discussion, I no longer feel that this Council can accomplish these goals.”
Inge Thulin, CEO of 3M, which makes Post-it Notes and industrial adhesives, said he was resigning because the council was out of step with 3M’s focus on diversity and environmental sustainability.
“I believe the initiative is no longer an effective vehicle for 3M to advance these goals,” he said.
Denise Morrison, CEO of Campbell Soup, said she was resigning following Tuesday’s remarks from the president. “Racism and murder are unequivocally reprehensible and are not morally equivalent to anything else that happened in Charlottesville. I believe the President should have been — and still needs to be — unambiguous on that point,” Ms. Morrison said in a statement.
Greg Hayes, CEO of United Technologies, said he also had resigned Wednesday, citing the events of the last week. President Trump had criticized the company during his campaign for closing a factory and shipping work to Mexico. Mr. Hayes later struck a deal with the White House to keep some of the jobs in Indiana. — The Wall Street Journal
President Trump on Friday dismissed his embattled chief strategist Stephen K. Bannon, an architect of his 2016 general election victory and the champion of his nationalist impulses, in a major White House shake-up that follows a week of racial unrest.
With his presidency floundering and his legislative agenda in shambles, administration officials said Trump’s empowered new chief of staff, John F. Kelly, moved to fire Bannon in an effort to tame warring factions and bring stability to a White House at risk of caving under its own self-destructive tendencies.
A combative populist on trade and immigration, Bannon has arguably been Trump’s ideological id on the issues that propelled his candidacy. He has served as a key liaison to the president’s conservative base and the custodian of his campaign promises.
Bannon has been a lightning rod for controversy since joining Trump’s campaign last summer, but attracted particular scorn in recent days for encouraging and amplifying the president’s divisive remarks in the wake of last week’s deadly white supremacist demonstration in Charlottesville, Va. — The Washington Post
When I first heard the news, I tweeted this:
Are you sick of spending your money on items of questionable utility such as milk and bread? Instead, use those funds to help support a publication you believe in.
Please visit our Patreon page and help us build something special.
- Stephen Bannon Out at the White House After Turbulent Run by Maggie Haberman, Michael D. Shear, and Glenn Thrush (The New York Times)
- The Rise and Fall of Steve Bannon by Ryan Lizza (The New Yorker)
- Bannon Plots Fox Competitor, Global Expansion by Jonathan Swan and Mike Allen (Axios)
- There’s No ‘Nazi’ Exception to the First Amendment by Charles C. W. Cooke (National Review)
- It’s The End Of The Presidency As We Know It, And I Feel Fine by Ryan Huber (Arc)
- 7 Things Republicans Could Do To Check Trump Without Ditching Conservative Policy by Matthew Yglesias (Vox)
- Charlottesville Cracked the Trump Coalition by Nicholas Grossman (Arc)
- Trump’s Disastrous Mishandling of Charlottesville Will Have Consequences by Michael Brendan Dougherty (National Review)
- Donald Trump Needs To Not Be President Yesterday by Robert Tracinski (The Federalist)
- Steve Bannon’s Fantasy, Donald Trump’s Reality by Ben Smith (BuzzFeed)
- The Fake History President by Robert Schlesinger (U.S. News & World Report)
- A Simple Theory of Trumpian Policy Effectiveness by Justin Fox (Bloomberg View)
- French President Emmanuel Macron’s Fall From Grace, Explained by Sarah Wildman (Vox)
- This is Not Sustainable. Something Has to Give. The Nation Cannot Tolerate 3.5 More Years of This. by Erick Erickson (The Resurgent)
- Megachurch Magic, Vol. 1 by Berny Belvedere (Arc)
- A Look At America’s Latest Report On Religious Persecution (The Economist)
- Do We Need A God? by Dave DuBay (Arc)
- After Charlottesville, Will White Pastors Finally Take Racism Seriously? by Jemar Tisby (The Washington Post)
- Why Evangelicals are Drawn to the Alt-Right by Stephen Wolfe (Reformation500)
- How To Talk (And Not To Talk) About Violence On “Both Sides” by Cathy Young (Arc)
- Leave the Washington and Jefferson Monuments Alone by Berny Belvedere (Arc)
- Effacing The Past by Steve Hays (Arc)
- Why Is The Left Obsessed With Tearing Down Statues? by C’Zar Bernstein (Arc)
- 15 Theses About Confederate Iconography by Berny Belvedere (Arc)
- Your Arguments Against Removing The Statues Are Bad by Nicholas Grossman (Arc)
- What Identity Politics Hath Wrought by Michael Barone (American Enterprise Institute)
- The Poison of Identity Politics by The Editorial Board (The Wall Street Journal)
- Debating the Liberal Case Against Identity Politics by Sean Illing (Vox)
- Six Degrees of Racism by Ryan Huber (Arc)
- Militarism by Matt Reimann (Medium)
- Senator Ben Sasse Delivers Chilling Truth In A Post Entitled ‘The Next Charlottesville’ by Kimberly Ross (RedState)
- Should We Diagnose Donald Trump? by Andrés Ruiz (Arc)
- How to Win Friends and Stigmatize Nazis by Conor Friedersdorf (The Atlantic)
- Abraham Lincoln Monument Torched in Chicago: ‘An Absolute Disgraceful Act’ by Douglas Ernst (The Washington Times)
- Who Can Break Cycle of Dysfunction by Cathy Young (Newsday)
- The Unintended Consequences of Ending Insurer ‘Bailouts’ by Robert VerBruggen (National Review)
- 13 Ways to Strengthen America’s Economy by Noah Smith (Bloomberg View)
- NAFTA Renegotiation: Separating Fact From Fiction by Amanda Waldron (Brookings)
- Should We Subsidize Manufacturing? by Joshua Rothman (The New Yorker)
- On the Promise of the Craft Industry by Matt Reimann (Medium)
- Fighting Status Inequality by Matt Reimann (Medium)
- Business Rivals Agree on Policy by David Abney and Frederick W. Smith (The Wall Street Journal)
- The Curse of Middle-Aged Capitalism by Robert J. Samuelson (The Washington Post)
- The Fight for $15 Is Having a Rough Year by Connor D. Wolf (Inside Sources)
- Neo-Nazis Expose the Internet’s Big Weakness by Elaine Ou (Bloomberg View)
- Apple Will Become A Major Player In Hollywood By Spending $1 Billion On Original TV Shows And Movies by Nathan McAlone (Business Insider)
- Too Much Power Lies in Tech Companies’ Hands by Stephen L. Carter (Bloomberg View)
- Why Researchers Are Figuring Out How to Hack Climate Change with Solar Shading by Scott K. Johnson (Medium)
- Conservatives Turn On Silicon Valley — And The Free Market by James Pethokoukis (The Week)
- Sustainability in the Startup Era by Tom Littrell (Medium)
- Is Tesla Really A Disruptor? (And Why The Answer Matters) by Larry Downes and Paul Nunes (Harvard Business Review)
- The Simple Reasons Why Amazon is Not a Monopoly by Charles Sizemore (Yahoo! Finance)
- What Cigarettes Can Teach Us About the Risks of Breakthrough Technology by Jacob Ward (Medium)
- These 5 Statues Are A Disgrace And Need To Be Torn Down Immediately by Berny Belvedere (The Federalist)
- Netflix Cofounder’s MoviePass Will Now Let You See One Movie Per Day In Theaters For $10 A Month by John Lynch (Business Insider)
- The Best Movie About the Great Recession is “Land of the Lost” by Nic Rowan (Arc)
- Netflix’s ‘Icarus’ Is A Thrilling Documentary With Scary Relevance by Eric Melin (Scene Stealers)
- Ranked: The 21 Best Heist Movies of All Time by Jason Guerrasio (Business Insider)
- “Game of Thrones” Season 7, Episode 5 Recap: The Book of Love by Sarah Larson (The New Yorker)
- Taylor Swift Won Her Day In Court. Here’s What You Need To Know. by Constance Grady (Vox)
- Amid Barcelona’s Transition, Messi is More Important Than Ever Before by Sid Lowe (ESPN FC)
- The Official 2017 Arc Digital NBA Redraft Rounds 1–3 by Brandon Anderson (Arc)
- Eight Shakeups That Can Knock Chalk Out of College Football in 2017 by Bill Bender (SportingNews)
- How Does The Sammy Watkins Trade Shake Up Fantasy Football? by Brandon Anderson (Arc)
- Around the NFL, QBs Are Training and Eating the Tom Brady Way by Ben Volin (The Boston Globe)
- Jose Mourinho Wary of Roadworks Despite Manchester United’s Fast Start by Stuart James (The Guardian)
Have you experienced the transformative thrill of liking a page on Facebook, or following an account on Twitter? No? Well, then, carpe diem!
This Week In History
1960 — The Beatles perform publicly for the first time.
1662 — Blaise Pascal (b. 1623), French polymath best known within philosophy for his eponymous wager, passes away. You can read about his wager here.
1866 — The U.S. Civil War is officially declared over by President Andrew Johnson.
1959 — Hawaii becomes the 50th U.S. state.
1862 — Claude Debussy, prominent French composer, is born.
1946 — Keith Moon, drummer for The Who, is born. Moon was probably the most aggressive and easily one of the most technically gifted drummers in pop music history.
1814 — During the War of 1812, Great Britain captures Washington D.C. and does great damage.
To live is the rarest thing in the world. Most people exist, that is all.
— Oscar Wilde