The Weekly Arc: May 5, 2017
Welcome to Arc’s newsletter, sent out once per week, highlighting the best and most interesting stories from around the web. The Weekly Arc is curated by Berny Belvedere. Past editions can be accessed here.
Republicans Pass Healthcare Bill in the House
House Republicans on Thursday narrowly passed a controversial bill to overhaul the nation’s health-care system, claiming a major victory even as the measure faces an uncertain fate in the closely divided U.S. Senate.
Under intense pressure to show they can govern and to make good on their promise to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act, Republicans pushed through the bill after adopting a last-minute change that earned it just enough votes to pass. However, the House version fell significantly short of the GOP’s long-held goals, making major dents in large portions of the current law but not outright repealing it.
The bumpy, months-long process that led to Thursday’s vote also violated some of the GOP’s own promises on how they would govern.
The measure proceeded without the benefit of an analysis from the Congressional Budget Office of its cost and impact on insurance coverage, and it did so after many Republicans openly acknowledged that they hadn’t read the bill. President Trump also promised “insurance for everybody,” which the measure will not achieve.
The American Health Care Act, which passed by a vote of 217 to 213, nonetheless represented a significant if incomplete political victory for President Trump, who has struggled to secure legislative wins early in his presidency. The vote was also an important win for House Speaker Paul D. Ryan (R-Wis.), who has spent years trying to dismantle Obamacare but has struggled in recent months to unite an ideologically divided caucus.
The House bill would shift power to states to set important health insurance rules. And it would end the ACA’s subsidies for eligible people who buy health plans through marketplaces created under the law, creating and substituting new tax credits. It also would rescind several taxes that have helped pay for the law, including ones imposed on Americans with high incomes, health insurers, medical devices and tanning salons.
Among the bill’s more contentious provisions is one that would allow states to let insurers return to their old practice of charging more to customers with preexisting medical problems — a practice that current law prohibits. — The Washington Post
This piece in Politico takes a peak under the hood to look at what exactly is in the bill.
Democrats Were…Not Happy
The House speaker, Paul Ryan, and other Republicans falsely accused Democrats of rushing the Affordable Care Act through Congress. On Thursday, in a display of breathtaking hypocrisy, House Republicans — without holding any hearings or giving the Congressional Budget Office time to do an analysis — passed a bill that would strip at least 24 million Americans of health insurance. …
The bill now moves to the Senate, where several centrist Republicans are opposed to it. The best hope for defeating this legislation rests with lawmakers like Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia, Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rob Portman of Ohio. But Mr. Trump and far-right groups will put tremendous pressure on them to pass this dreadful bill or something similarly terrible. The health of millions of Americans is now in their hands. — The New York Times Editorial Board
Here is a roundup by CNN of reaction from Democrats.
France To Elect A New President
Two weeks ago, on April 23, the people of France narrowed the field of presidential hopefuls to two: Emmanuel Macron and Marine Le Pen. This Sunday, May 7, they’ll once again go to the polls and vote to put either Macron or Le Pen in the Élysée Palace.
In this roundup, I point to 5 must-read pieces (really, it’s more than 5) to get acquainted with France’s current moment.
Our conservative media landscape is dominated by loud voices with little interest, and little incentive, in producing smart analysis. If you value the work we do, if you appreciate the model of news and commentary we embody, then we are asking for your help.
To support us at $2 per month, please click here.
- So the House Passed its Health Care Bill. What Now? by Molly E. Reynolds (Brookings)
- Health Care, from the Top by Kevin D. Williamson (National Review)
- The House GOP’s Shameful Healthcare Victory by John Cassidy (The New Yorker)
- AHCA is a Betrayal of all the GOP’s Promises on Health Care by Matthew Yglesias (Vox)
- The Right Needs Better Storytellers by Noah Rothman (Commentary)
- Trump Has A Dangerous Disability by George F. Will (The Washington Post)
- This Week Proves the U.S. Government Will Eventually Default by Tho Bishop (Arc)
- What Is Going On at the Heritage Foundation? by Reihan Salam (Slate)
- Why Has Theresa May Called For A Snap Election? by Berny Belvedere (Arc)
- Some Thoughts on Greenwich, Winnetka, and Why Hillary Clinton Lost by Josh Barro (Business Insider)
- Trump’s Executive Order on Religious Liberty Is Worse Than Useless by David French (National Review)
- ‘Their Dream President’: Trump Just Gave White Evangelicals a Big Boost by Sarah Pulliam Bailey (The Washington Post)
- The Mistake Christians Made in Defending Bill O’Reilly by Katelyn Beaty (The New York Times)
- Francis and Benedict: Two Popes, Two Divergent Approaches to Islam by Christopher Lamb (Religion News Service)
- Why White Evangelicals Are ‘Splintering’ Politically by Danielle Kurtzleben (NPR)
- I Write on the Internet. I’m Sorry. by Michael Brendan Dougherty (The Week)
- This Is What A Modern-Day Witch Hunt Looks Like by Jesse Singal (New York Magazine)
- Bret Stephens, Intolerance, and Bad Journalism by Cathy Young (Arc)
- The Collapse of American Identity by Robert P. Jones (The New York Times)
- The Future of France by Berny Belvedere (Arc)
- Alex Jones Will Never Stop Being Alex Jones by Charlie Warzel (BuzzFeed)
- The Left’s Parallel Justice System by Seth Barron (City Journal)
- Texas Could Go Bankrupt by Joel Looper (Arc)
- QWERTY, Health Care, and Public Policy by Louis D. Johnston (Arc)
- The Spiritual Ruin of a Universal Basic Income by Damon Linker (The Week)
- Economics, Not Identity, is Key to Reviving American Liberalism by Rana Foroohar (Financial Times)
- This Is What Being Recession-Proof Looks Like by Berny Belvedere (Arc)
- We’re Getting Awfully Close to Full Employment by Neil Irwin (The New York Times)
- U.S. Jobs Growth Bounces Back in April by Adam Samson (Financial Times)
- Tax Lies for the Gullible by Thomas Sowell (Investor’s Business Daily)
- The Key to Unleashing the American Economy by Charlie Gerow (Arc)
- The Age of Misinformation by Jonathan Zittrain (The Atlantic)
- Apple’s Billion-Dollar Investment Provides a Blueprint for U.S. Manufacturing by Issie Lapowsky (Wired)
- Crooked Media and Podcasting for Growth by Lucas Quagliata (Arc)
- Sorry, Bus Drivers: Self-Driving Mass Transit is on the Way by Brett Williams (Mashable)
- These 5 Big Tech Trends Are Changing the Way We Learn by Raya Bidshahri (Singularity Hub)
- The Techno-Libertarians Praying for Dystopia by Mark O’Connell (New York Magazine)
- Nintendo is Firing on All Cylinders Right Now by Dave Smith (Business Insider)
- The Summer Movies We’re Actually Excited For (The Ringer)
- How LaVar Ball’s Gamble on a Signature Shoe Could Pay Off in a Big Way by Dayana Sarkisova (SB Nation)
- Stephen Colbert is Sorry-Not-Sorry for Hitting Trump Below the Belt by Callum Borchers (The Washington Post)
- If “The Handmaid’s Tale” is Not aWarning for the Trump Era, What is it a Warning For? by Leslie Loftis (Iron Ladies)
- A Brief Oral History of the Worst Nicknames in the NBA by Brandon Anderson (Arc)
- The Key to Understanding Playoff Adjustments by Kevin O’Connor (The Ringer)
- MLB has Fumbled Handling of Ridiculous, Futile Revenge Tactics between Orioles and Red Sox by Peter Botte (New York Daily News)
- 2017 NFL Draft Recap and Fantasy Football Fallout by Brandon Anderson (Arc)
- Adrian Wojnarowski Finally Won His War Against ESPN by Kevin Draper (Deadspin)
- Celtics Hero Isaiah Thomas Rises Above it all With Legendary Game 2 Performance by Matt Moore (CBS Sports)
- The Mean: “Commercials” (Episode 45) hosted by Ryan Huber (Arc)
I’ll be honest: We could use some likes and follows. Help us out.
This Week In History
May 6
1856 — Sigmund Freud, one of the most significant figures in recent intellectual history, is born.
1954 — Roger Bannister of the UK becomes the first person to run a 4 minute mile, recording 3:59:4.
May 7
1840 — Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky, one of the greatest classical composers ever, is born.
May 9
1962 — The Beatles, the greatest group in music history, sign their first contract with EMI Parlophone. Spend some time rediscovering them today.
May 11
1981 — Bob Marley (b. 1945), the great popularizer of reggae and one of the most successful artists of all time, passes away.
1995 — In New York City, more than 170 countries decide to extend the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty indefinitely and without conditions.
Quote
Sigmund Freud:
We are never so defenseless against suffering as when we love.