Hey VC — show me the statement, not the brochure!

A look into how Frontline tracks and evaluates value-add to our portfolio companies

Will Prendergast
Apr 25, 2017 · 5 min read

One of our core beliefs at Frontline is that learning at the speed of your own experience is not fast enough to win. This is why our first hire outside of the partners in 2012 was a Head of Platform.

Kim’s role was to figure out how we accelerate the development of our portfolio companies through group learning and giving them access to specialised knowledge on-demand.

As the funding environment gets more competitive, we are constantly thinking about how we keep the Frontline “product” in tune with the best founders’ needs. At the end of the day, we are selling a commodity called capital — so being a standout funding partner is not straightforward. Beyond capital, the two areas where funds can differentiate themselves are: (1) Team and (2) Value-Add.

Team

When you take on a seed investor, you are going on a long journey together. Making sure that you have good personal chemistry really matters. It is also important that you find an investor whom you feel thinks with a clear mind, even when the going gets tough (as I have shared views about before: “Solve for Rational”).

As we built the Frontline team, we thought long and hard about personal style and how any potential new member of the Frontline team will interact with the best entrepreneurs. Thomas, who joined us last year, was grilled by three of our portfolio CEOs during his last round of interviews — one of them early on a Sunday morning in Dublin Airport, as the CEO was on his way to the US. Sorry Thomas!

Value-Add

Like many entrepreneurs, I am often underwhelmed by the claims of “value-add” activities many VC firms make. The reason entrepreneurs have been let down is because many firms do not:

  1. Invest dedicated resources (time and money) in value-add. It is seen as something that the investor does in their spare time.

How have we tried to combat this?

  1. Invest in value-add from Day One

We invested in the Head of Platform role from day 1 to make sure someone came into work everyday thinking about how we are accelerating learning and enabling knowledge access for our teams. Investing in some ways was the easy part, but we got lucky in hiring Kim, who has set the pace for this Head of Platform role in Europe.

Since then, we have added three members to the team who all came from impressive operational roles — as Chief Revenue Officer (Stephen, Twitter), CTO (Steve, Swrve), and CFO (Laura, OpenHydro).

They are incredible resources that all of our companies can access on-demand before they can afford to hire a CRO, CTO, or CFO of that experience level.

2. (and 3.) Understand and be held accountable

In conversation with Paddy Benson last year about how Moltin could show their customers what value they were adding for them, it occurred to me how we should deal with points (2) and (3) above. We are calling it the “Value-Add Statement.”

You wouldn’t accept it if your bank said, “We will take care of your money, but cannot tell you exactly what is in there. But trust me, you will be able to access that in the future when you want it.”

As a customer, you want to see a statement that shows precisely what is in there and that you can access the money when needed. You want every important transaction written down, so that you can assess your financial position at any point in time.

With this concept in mind, we started 4 months ago capturing everything we did, as a team, to help our portfolio companies. We did this by bcc’ing all value-add activities (introductions, advice, etc.) to an email inbox and then transferring to a spreadsheet.

Image for post
Image for post
Example of a value statement review with a portfolio CEO

Our findings so far:

  1. In the first month, we realised we were doing lots of small things to help the companies — but things that didn’t drastically move the needle. We stopped tracking those to the statement and stopped ourselves from allocating time to things that didn’t really add that much value.
Image for post
Image for post
Breakdown of Frontline portfolio company : Frontline team member

3. Our companies’ challenges are pretty consistent. Here is the percentage breakdown of value-add activities by category:

  • Fundraising 34%

Now, we are moving from the “Data Capture” phase into the “Review” phase of the Value-Add Statements product. We are sitting down with some of our investee CEOs to review where we have interacted with them, ask for their input on what was helpful or not, and discern whether this has met their expectations for value-add. We did our first review with a portfolio company, pictured above.

Out of this, we expect to be able to further refine what “Platform” means and decide where to double down. The goal is to exceed the expectations of each of the founding teams we work with. If we do that, we will have transformed our capital (a commodity) into a differentiated service that will continue to attract the very best entrepreneurs in Europe.

I would like to see a future where, in 3 years, every founder could sit down with their investors at year end for a Value Statement review.

As a VC fund, how else do you ensure product / market fit with your entrepreneur customers?

At the Front Line

Frontline is the venture firm for globally ambitious B2B…

Will Prendergast

Written by

Trained as a chemical engineer and a chef - ended up in venture capital. Partner @ FrontLine Ventures http://ie.linkedin.com/in/willprendergast/

At the Front Line

Frontline is the venture firm for globally ambitious B2B companies, on both sides of the Atlantic

Will Prendergast

Written by

Trained as a chemical engineer and a chef - ended up in venture capital. Partner @ FrontLine Ventures http://ie.linkedin.com/in/willprendergast/

At the Front Line

Frontline is the venture firm for globally ambitious B2B companies, on both sides of the Atlantic

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store