Blows Against the Empire

After having its way with the NBC/Universal buy, Comcast thought its consumer-unfriendly merger with Time Warner Cable would be a snap. Not so fast….

Susan Crawford
Dec 8, 2014 · Unlisted
Image for post
Image for post

Years ago, Comcast and Time Warner Cable and their brethren carried out a series of swaps and deals aimed at dividing up the country’s cable subscribers.

Comcast has been hard at work buying advertising and deploying lobbying firms — three dozen of them, at last count — in an effort to give the merger an air of inevitability. But on Wednesday, that air got a little choppier: a new group, aptly named the “Stop Mega-Comcast Coalition” and made up of a diverse array of media companies and public interest groups (everyone from Glenn Beck’s Blaze TV to the Writer’s Guild West) introduced itself to the world and announced that it was out to block the deal.

We’ve been here before. Four years ago, the Comcast-NBCU merger sailed through; opposition to the deal was disorganized and disheveled, and the agencies involved (the Department of Justice and the FCC) convinced themselves that the lack of consumer benefits accompanying the merger could be remedied by special conditions imposed on Comcast.

Today things are different. For starters, the government now recognizes that Comcast is really an infrastructure company selling a service — high-speed Internet access — that Americans feel is a utility. FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler in a recent speech noted pointedly that cable dominates the marketplace for Internet access services over 25 Mbps. And Comcast’s ability to turn all the levers over which it has power, including all its exclusive connections to millions of American eyeballs, means that it can shape the destinies of innumerable varieties of American companies.

Everyone from video equipment manufacturers to freelance Hollywood writers is worried that if they aren’t nice to Comcast they won’t survive.

And now the FCC understands, perhaps even better than it did when it considered the Comcast/NBCU merger, that Comcast has to show genuine consumer benefits in order to get this merger through. Comcast has pushed forward hundreds of community organizations and lawmakers who have testified in support of the merger, but the benefits they tout — speedier innovation, better programming — ring hollow in comparison to the problems.

When one company can decide at its leisure — under no pressure from either competition or oversight — how, when, and why particular information reaches more than half of American households, at what price, we’ve got a problem.

There’s nothing evil about Comcast. It just seeks to lower its unit costs, and it’s well-managed, enough to do what AOL/Time Warner couldn’t. But even though bigness isn’t bad and Comcast isn’t evil, in the absence of any visible benefit to American consumers, it’s hard to see why the FCC would let this latest merger proceed. Gene Kimmelman, president of Public Knowledge, a key member of the Stop Mega-Comcast Coalition, thinks the time is right and the feds will be receptive to the group’s message. He’s not alone—there is a definite vibe among Comcast watchers that this time the powerhouse might not get its way.

So let’s assume the feds do the right thing and block this mega merger. The bigger question is: what next.

Until then, it’s good to hear the other side of the Comcast discussion speaking with one voice. If the government doesn’t listen, they’ll be setting a new standard for tone-deafness.

Image for post
Image for post

Follow Backchannel: Twitter | Facebook

Backchannel

Mining the tech world for lively and meaningful tales and…

Thanks to Steven Levy

Unlisted

Susan Crawford

Written by

Contributor to @backchnnl; prof @Harvard_Law; books (#TheResponsiveCity, #CaptiveAudience); all things tech & Internet

Backchannel

Mining the tech world for lively and meaningful tales and analysis.

Susan Crawford

Written by

Contributor to @backchnnl; prof @Harvard_Law; books (#TheResponsiveCity, #CaptiveAudience); all things tech & Internet

Backchannel

Mining the tech world for lively and meaningful tales and analysis.

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store