Backyard Church

Thoughts on applying a 2000 year old religion to 21st Century life

Member-only story

The Hell Dilemma: Why I Can’t Believe in a God Who Tortures People

A Deep Dive into Why Hell and a Loving God Don’t Add Up

Dan Foster
Backyard Church
Published in
5 min readFeb 11, 2025

--

Image source: Canva Pro

There I was, sitting in another small group Bible study when the topic of salvation came up. Christians, it seems, are always speculating about who will be saved from the fires of Hell and who won’t be and how exactly God will decide.

I suppose there is something in us that wants to rest assured that we don’t end up on the wrong side of the ledger, and so people of faith — and maybe even people of no faith — hypothesize and ruminate on this issue.

In a TV interview, Martin Iles, the head of the Australian Christian Lobby, stated, “The mainstream Christian belief is that all people are destined for hell, from birth, unless they find salvation through Jesus.” This was certainly the belief that I was taught as fact growing up in the evangelical Church.

But I’ll level with you. I am finding it increasingly difficult to square away the idea of a loving God with the doctrine of eternal torment in the fires of Hell.

There, I said it.

In my former life, I would have called myself a heretic. Nowadays, I am kind enough to acknowledge that I am simply pulling apart everything I once believed and testing it for its usefulness…

--

--

Backyard Church
Backyard Church

Published in Backyard Church

Thoughts on applying a 2000 year old religion to 21st Century life

Dan Foster
Dan Foster

Written by Dan Foster

Writer, Poet, Blogger: Tackling life, faith, culture, religion, politics, and spirituality. Connect with me: https://linktr.ee/DanFosterWriter

Responses (36)