Judge praises responsible reporting as reporters win battle to reveal name of teenage murderer

Rocky Price was jailed at Preston Crown Court

Journalists from multiple news organisations have ensured a teenager who murdered a woman, put her body in a wheelie bin and ultimately burying her in a shallow grave is named.

LancsLive, the Lancashire Telegraph, the BBC and the Press Association joined forced to get reporting restrictions lifted following the conviction of Rocky Price, 17, at Preston Crown Court.

Price was found guilty of murdering Lindsay Birbeck in Accrington last year. At the time of the offence, he was 16 years old. Price will turn 18 in February, and throughout the case was protected by the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act.

The application for reporting restrictions to be lifted was opposed by Mark Stuart, representing the defence, who said that identifying Price, could cause the killer problems behind bars.

But the judge overseeing the case, Her Honour Mrs Justice Yip, praised the journalists “very responsible reporting” of the case.

She said: “The murder was a truly shocking event. This was a dreadful crime which generated strong public interest.

“The public naturally wish to know who this person was as they come to terms with something that rocked the local community.

CCTV footage released by police

“The defendant’s photograph was already placed in the public domain [as part of a CCTV appeal]. I consider it inconceivable anybody who would wish him ill-harm would not discover his identity.

“The wider public are likely to want to know his identity and background with a view to making sense of how such a young person could do something so dreadful.

“There is a strong public interest in full and unrestricted reporting of what is plainly an exceptional case. The real public interest exists now at the time of conviction and sentence.

“Continuing reporting restrictions would substantially and considerably restrict the freedom of the press.”

The press application stated: “We submit the balancing exercise should be in our favour. To a certain extent the identity of the defendant is already in the public domain after the release of a CCTV clip by the police.

“Our default position is that publishing names and addresses is part of the principle of open justice.

“Issues of families fears over reprisals or public outcry over defendants could be a familiar complaint across the land whatever their age.”

Mr Stuart, defending, said: “[Price] is in a young offenders institute and is a category A prisoner.

“While some inmates may have some inkling what the position is, the concern is if he is named there is a significant prospect others would find out his name and that could cause him some difficulties.

“There is certainly a potential that those in custody may feel a degree of revulsion about what he has done and may even verbally or physically abuse him.

“It may be difficult for him to respond and report it to the appropriate authorities. The effect of revealing his name will also have an effect on various members of his family.”

Price admitted to assisting in the disposal of her body but claimed he played no role in her death, saying he was offered “a lot of money’ by an unknown man to ‘get rid of the body”.

LancsLive editor Luke Beardsworth said: “The murder of Lindsay Birbeck was a horrific crime that first brought a community together then left it in shock.

“Once the defendant was found guilty, it was inevitable that people in that community were going to know who the name and many already did.

“Lancs Live has been following this from taking part in the searches for Lindsay last year to this decision by the judge and it’s right and proper that this decision was made after the applications from ourselves, BBC, PA and the Lancashire Telegraph.

“Both Jon Macpherson [of LancsLive] and Amy Farnworth [of the Lancashire Telegraph] have done exceptional work in keeping that community updated.

“The presence of online court listings and visibility of his name at Preston Crown Court in previous hearings had rendered the reporting restrictions redundant by the time the trial was over.

“None of this is more important than the need for the family to be given the time to grieve for Lindsay. Our thoughts and best wishes go out to Steven, Sarah and all of her loved ones.”

LancsLive has produced a detailed backgrounder using Shorthand — read it here.

--

--

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store