The origins and history of mindset psychology
If you want to grow your branches high and wide as a mindset practitioner, it is important you develop a deep system of roots in the origins and history of mindset psychology. However, opportunities to study the history of mindset tend to be few and far between, and the small number of opportunities that do exist, typically centre around stories that are partial and incomplete, and that sometimes contain inaccurate and unsubstantiated claims.
I am a mindset practitioner, and a few years ago I had a realisation that mindset history was a critical gap in contemporary literature, and it was also a largely unexplored topic in mindset education and training programs. So, I decided to undertake a major research project in the area of mindset history, and share a review paper on what I learned. A preprint of my findings is available here.
A brief summary of what I found was that mindset psychology has a century-long history of explicit research and practice, with its origin phase taking place between 1908 and 1939, early inquiries occurring between 1940 and 1987, and contemporary bodies of work emerging in and beyond 1988 (see Figure 1). This review also identifies some of the traditions of research and practice that are closely related to the origins and history of mindset psychology, some of which span back hundreds and thousands of years. Then, there are the lineages of research and practice that did not explicitly use the term mindset, but which bear some resemblance to it, and are in some way related to this history.
I was somewhat surprised to find that very little of this history is currently being acknowledged by practitioners in the field, nor is it being taught in much depth as part of mindset education and training programs.
I believe acknowledging the history of mindset is important, because it provides a context for understanding current and emerging ideas, for promoting critical reflection, and for showing respect to the lineage of people that contributed to the origins and evolution of mindset psychology. Without appropriate levels of historical acknowledgement, voices from the past become silenced, new ideas become decontextualised from the ideas that came before them, and there is a reduced capacity for understanding and critical examination.
If you’re curious to learn more about the origins and history of mindset, I encourage you to spend some time studying the history presented in this paper. The findings may surprise you.
If you have any reflections to share after reading this paper, I would love to know: 1) How well does the history presented here align with the story of mindset history you currently hold? 2) What do these historical findings mean for your mindset work or life practice moving forward? 3) What do you think this history means for the field of mindset as a whole?
Please share this paper with anyone who you think might be interested in learning more about mindset history.
I’m also looking for a few people to peer-review this paper. If you would like to support this process, please send me a PM.
References: Buchanan, A. (2024). The history of mindset: Honouring lineage, transcending partial stories, making mindset research and practice an interdisciplinary and intergenerational project. [Preprint]. https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/dsb97
