5 Cozy, Fall Ice Cream Flavors Found in Old Town, Fort Collins

Hannah Adams
Beyond the Oval
Published in
3 min readSep 15, 2015

Autumn — It’s nearly that time of year again. It’s that breath of fresh, crisp air that everyone craves by the end of our adventurous Colorado summers. We’ve rafted down rivers, raved at Red Rocks, and road-tripped around, leaving our bodies ready for some relief. It’s time to transition from climbing up to sky-touching mountain summits to climbing into a pile of blankets. What better companion in bed this fall than a seasonally-flavored scoop (or two) (or three) of ice cream? Nothing comes to mind. Thankfully, Fort Collins is fully stocked with these 5 cozy, fall flavors to make our snuggle sessions extra satisfying!

1. Marsh-Mallow S’more

You can still feel warm from bonfire memories with this nostalgic marshmallow flavor offered at Kilwins. This signature flavor is rooted in Kilwins love for hand-crafted marshmallows since 1947.

https://www.kilwins.com/fortcollins

2. Coffee, Coffee, Buzz Buzz Buzz

A flavor to surely get you buzzing, this coffee ice cream and espresso bean fudge chunk mix from Ben & Jerry’s has the energy boost ingredients needed for those late night Netflix binges.

http://www.benjerry.com/fortcollins

3. Caramel Apple

What’s fall without a classic caramel apple? Now, you can conveniently find that same staple taste in your ice cream! This sweet apple concoction is made right in Old Town at “Best Ice Cream in Fort Collins” award-winning eleven years in a row, Walrus.

http://www.walrusicecream.com/index2.html

4. Pumpkin Pie

Missing momma’s pumpkin pie? It happens, but this textured pumpkin pie flavor with grainy bits of crust, also offered at Walrus, will make you feel right at home.

In the slight chance that this flavor doesn’t suit your fancy, check out this entire Pinterest board dedicated to pumpkin recipes!

https://www.pinterest.com/damndelicious/pumpkin/

5. Oatmeal Cookie Batter

Last but not least, you can’t go wrong with this fluffy, yet mild mix of oatmeal and brown sugar in cookie batter ice cream form offered at Cold Stone Creamery.

http://www.coldstonecreamery.com/index.html

--

--