Ideas don’t matter. Customer problems do.
A story of solving the wrong problems at lightning speed and how to fix it.
There is a simple equation for commercially successful innovation:
Innovation = Creating viable and feasible SOLUTIONS for unmet customer PROBLEMS.
When we look at how innovation is happening in many companies today, we see that people naturally gravitate towards the first part of the equation.
They start with the idea (a solution approach) before the actual customer problem is being properly defined or validated in detail.
They solve the “how” prior to the “what” and the “why”.
In surveys of 106 C-suite executives in 17 countries, 85% strongly agreed or agreed that their organizations were bad at problem diagnosis, and 87% strongly agreed or agreed that this flaw carried significant costs.*
So if we know that…
- …people are paying to get rid of a pain or problem.
- …a properly defined customer problem is one of two essential variables of the equation for successful innovation.
- …we dramatically reduce the failure rate of product/service launches if the solutions are rooted in true consumer needs.
Why are we still prioritizing solutions over problems?
- The need for quick results. Failing fast vs. getting it right.
Digging deep, reframing the problem, and empathizing with users cost time and money. This is what companies see when they have to invest in a prior phase than actually building the solution. But this is one of the reasons why 95% of new product launches fail** and 94% of global executives are unsatisfied with the performance of their business in the area of innovation.***
Ideation is not, and never was, the first step in building a solution. You are reducing the failure rate and the associated costs in the long run if you are familiar with the nature of the topic and decomposed the user’s needs in a systematic way.
2. Solution bias
We all like to solve problems and want to jump in directly in building the next big thing. But it is unlikely to happen without a systematic prior discovery phase.
We believe we know the pros and cons of our potential solution and communicate them to our boss or teams in a non-negotiable, predefined way. We, therefore, take away the need for them to think, to challenge, to dig deeper and we take away the possibility to reframe the problem before building a solution. This lack of shared understanding opens the door to subjective assumptions and potential misunderstandings.
Once someone is really convinced about his/her idea, in most cases there is no turning back. They are biased and very likely to ignore all signs of potential failure on the way.
3. We confuse assumptions with problems
In innovation, many people tend to build houses on unreliable foundations — not validated assumptions.
We think we know what customer want, but unfortunately, this is not “Sixth-Sense” or “Minority Report” and we can’t read people’s minds if don’t talk to them. We are actually guessing or gambling with the future success of our products and services.
It is good to have a structured set of assumptions about our customers, but we can only validate them by actually interviewing them with the right questions and structure.
How to fix it?
I am sorry to say, but there is no shortcut.
You can only drive towards better business outcomes with a solid, systematic, repeatable, and data-driven discovery phase.
- You have to talk to your customers, understand what drives and motivates them. Talk to them early and often to understand their needs, desires, pain points, and preferences. You need the right interview techniques to effectively collect, synthesize and extract the right information to proceed with.
- You have to find out what the customer's functional, emotional, social, and financial needs are to properly address them.
- You have to understand how the customer measures value. What is his/her metric? For example “Minimise the time it takes to order your groceries online via the company app”.
- You have to find a way to measure the intensity of his/her struggles to know how to prioritize different solution approaches. How important is the issue to them and how satisfied are they with current alternatives. The gap between both factors serves as a score for the attractiveness of the opportunity.
Innovation requires actionable and differentiated insights to build upon. This is the lifeblood of innovation and 1 of 2 important variables in the equation for commercially successful innovation. Skipping an intense problem discovery phase might create fancy, shiny “solutions” to non-existent problems that end up in the landfill and the graveyard of new product launches.
Do you want to take action and create more meaningful products and services? Let’s talk
Sign up for my newsletter and get insights on new capabilities and processes to de-risk innovation.
Helping companies with effective strategies and execution for a systematic, user- and growth-centered innovation.
My name is Fabian Roschig and I am a consultant for innovation strategies and innovation management.
My mission is to drive innovation at all levels, based on the individual strengths of each organization, to enable and accelerate sustainable commercial growth. Together we make this happen by setting clear goals, focusing on the right balance between strategy and execution, and using validated, systematic methods and tools that guarantee continuous, measurable results.
For more than 12 years, I have had the privilege to successfully plan, implement or optimize new strategies, products, and services, innovation programs, structures, agile teams as well as processes for a variety of clients and employers such as The Coca-Cola Company, Condor, kicker, Dr. Oetker or TUI. In doing so, I work closely with executive boards, middle management, cross-functional teams, and external service providers.
**Based on Harvard Business School professor Clayton Christensen, Study for 30,000+ products which are launched every year -2019
***Based on McKinsey Survey — 2019
The problem is...you have no problem | Sifted
Good commercial ideas thrive by addressing a problem, a pain that hurts so much, people would pay to get rid of it…
Are You Solving the Right Problems?
In Brief The Issue Many C-suite executives (85% of those surveyed) say their companies struggle with problem diagnosis…
The eight essentials of innovation
It's no secret: innovation is difficult for well-established companies. By and large, they are better executors than…